• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Kantians believe promises should always be kept even if breaking brings about benefits because if everyone starts breaking promises what is the point of making one.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Dr. Kirk McDermind Philosophy 100 10 March 2008 Essay 2- Kantians think promises must always be kept, in every circumstance A Kantian is another form of deontologists who believes that everyone should do what is morally right according to their beliefs without fear of consequences, yet they should never use people as "means to your end but as ends in themselves" (Martin 130). They are driven by the duty to show others respect. Kantian believes in respect and that we can use people to get what we want, as long as we respect them (by helping them get what they want/need) while we use them. As long as there is mutual respect toward each other while seeking one's own benefit, then it is ok. The situation with Kantian and her promise to coach her friends son to become a doctor even though he will kill patients is a hard one for a character like Kantian. Kantian could go two ways. Either keep the promise and coach her friends son or not coach and save future patients lives. ...read more.

Middle

Kantian's categorical imperative is telling her she has to keep her promise without questioning it. It will be morally good to keep a promise but bad to release a negligent doctor in society. Although it may benefit society Kantian could not careless because he will never break a promise even if society stands to benefit. "The reason you couldn't will that everyone should break promises when that would bring benefits is that if everyone did that, then the whole concept of promising would become meaningless"(133). Although society will stand to benefit from Kantians broken promise, she can not break her promise. Since Kantian has no "consideration of consequences" and believe they "are totally irreverent to moral thinking" (133). Breaking a promise is out of the question for Kantian even if she is teaching a boy who might accidentally murder people. Kantian is a complex character, even though he/she says that they will never break a promise, they have a loop hole in their belief that can make them. ...read more.

Conclusion

This will go against my belied and morals and I am not Kantian without my beliefs and morals." In the end Kantian has two ways to solve his problem and both ways will in a way go against his morals and go against his beliefs. One way Kantian could go is keep the promise and another way Kantian could go is respect himself, the future patients of the killer surgeon, his job, and break the promise. The smart choice will be to break the promise because the promise show that her friend and her friends son is using Kantian in a disrespectful way. If they respected Kantian they would know and understand his morals and they will see that the promise is disrespecting Kantian and everyone who is going to suffer from the situation if Kantian keeps the promise. So the whole promise was made by going against Kantians beliefs on respect and when Kantian sees this he will break the promise. Kantian would say " I, Kantian make promises based on Respect and if the promise I made is disrespectful in anyway to anyone then that cannot be a promise that Kantian made and definitely not a promise Kantian will keep". ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ethics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ethics essays

  1. Explain how a Hindu marriage service might guide a couple in their married life?

    This is because there is no one right away to believe or worship in the way that he or she chooses. Hinduism is not a religion that tries to persuade other people to join it, and sometimes Hindus resent the efforts of Christians and Muslims to try and convert other people to share their beliefs.

  2. Problems with Utilitarian and Kantian Ethics.

    Many find that utilitarianism is too demanding of us, that it asks too much of us when placed in real situations. An example is given of a perfectly healthy person going into a doctor's office who has five other patients in need of transplants.

  1. Different religious and philosophical views on controversial topics.

    Comic relief Comic relief is when most charity is given in the UK. This should be an inherently good thing; however, should we need events like this to spur out charitable nature. Surely charity should be a natural human instinct?

  2. "Miller's plays show is that happiness can only be achieved by making moral compromises" ...

    Miller uses irony to demonstrate that even when people believe that a person has made moral compromises, happiness is still possible. This is shown in All My Sons by the fact that Joe knew that he caused death but because a court found him innocent i.e.

  1. To what extent, if at all, should conscience be ignored when making moral decisions?

    St Thomas Moore refused to sign an oath that declared Henry VIII marriage to Catharine of Aragon invalid. He resigned as chancellor he was imprisoned, then eventually beheaded for treason. In Robert Bolt's play 'A Man for all Seasons' Thomas Moore sums up his position as follows; "When a man

  2. How might a moral relativist respond to the claim that people should always tell ...

    An important weakness of ethical naturalism is that there are so many objections to it. The most famous objection to ethical naturalism comes from G E Moore (1873-1958). In his book Principal Ethics, Moore argues that all forms of ethical naturalism, by seeking to define moral words like 'good',' bad'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work