• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Let's Give murderers What they Deserve - the Death penalty.Explain the arguments for and against, and where the views of your chosen religion fit in.

Extracts from this document...


Religion and Criminal Justice Lets Give murderers What they Deserve - the Death penalty. Explain the arguments for and against, and where the views of your chosen religion fit in. 'Whosoever sheds man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed' Genesis 9:6 There are many arguments both for and against capital punishment. Some people argue for capital punishment, and often quote the verse above. Others argue against it, and say things like 'What if an innocent person is killed?', which has happened a number of times. I do believe that society should be kept safe, and murderers should be given what they deserve - the death penalty, but only if there is conclusive evidence that the suspect did actually commit the murder. Even though I hold this belief, most other Christians would disagree with me, and say that prisoners should be given a chance to reform. However, I think that if someone has committed a crime serious enough to warrant being put to death, they probably will already be so 'hardened', that they wouldn't be able to reform. In addition to the above, the following verse from the bible supports capital punishment: 'Anyone who hits a person and kills him must be put to death.' ...read more.


Some people say that if capital punishment only deters one murder per year, it is still worth it. Nearly all Christians oppose capital punishment. Some people say that abolition would send a message that it is possible to break the cycle of violence, and that it isn't necessary to take life. One of the major arguments against capital punishment is the fact that it is always possible a mistake will be made. In 1953, Derek Bentley was 19, but he had a mental age of 10/11. He went, with another, person called Christopher Craig went to commit a robbery. Chris was armed with a gun. When the policeman arrived at the scene, he grabbed Bentley, and so Chris started pointing the gun at the policeman. The policeman told Chris to give him the gun. Bentley then said something that could have two meanings - 'Let him have it'. Did he mean for Chris to give the policeman the gun, or for Chris to shoot the policeman? Whichever he meant, Chris took the latter as the meaning, and so he shot the policeman. Eventually they were arrested, and taken to court. Chris was to young to be sentenced to death, as he was only 16. However, Bentley was 19, and so he was sentenced to death, even though there was a lot of debating over what he meant when he said 'Let him have it'. ...read more.


In 1998 Karla Faye Tucker was due to be killed for the brutal murder of two people living in an apartment in Houston. During her time on death row, she committed her life to God, and just before her execution she pleaded for clemency. Different people had different views on her execution. Some said that her relationship with God is irrelevant. Others said 'How do you know the people she killed weren't born again Christians?', and cite the fact that the people she killed weren't given any special consideration. However, others said that as a born again believer, she would be able to reach a lot of people through her ministry in prison. As evidence to her rehabilitation she pointed towards her conversion. Gradually she drew support from conservative Christians, former prosecutors, human rights advocates and even a relative of one of her victims. This case would be extremely difficult to decide upon, but I would probably consult the victims' families, see what they thought would be the right thing, and then make my decision. I would probably end up reducing her sentence to life, with the chance of parole. In this case, I think that if the family of the murdered couple wanted her to be put to death, then it would be justified, but if they didn't, it would make it very difficult. Karla Faye Tucker was not given clemency, and killed by lethal injection on February 3rd 1998. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Capital Punishment section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Capital Punishment essays

  1. Does Queen Mary deserve her nickname of Bloody Mary?

    This would apply very much as to whether the writers were Catholic or Protestant. It must be accepted that all evidence must be taken into consideration when deciding whether Mary deserves her nickname. During the reign of the Tudors death was a common form of punishment for many crimes.

  2. The Impact of the Black Death on the Christian Faith

    During its time of plague, the Black Death was not known by its name now. In fact, the name of the "Black Death" was only given after its devastating sweep through medieval Europe. Both these forms of the Black Death, or also Black Plague, were caused by a bacterium called Yersina Pestis.

  1. Death Penalty Opinion.

    However, this is not to say that the society which inflicts capital punishment commits murder. Murder is an offensive act. Capital punishment, however effective it may be and through whatever ignorance it may be resorted to, is strictly a defensive act.

  2. Speaking and Listening If we execute murderers and there is in fact no ...

    Even if such executions have occurred, they are very rare. Imprisoning innocent people is also wrong, but we cannot empty the prisons because of that minimal risk. If improvements are needed in the system of representation, or in the use of scientific evidence such as DNA testing, then those reforms should be instituted.

  1. Outline the arguments for and against life after death? Assess the significance of the ...

    So this criticism of reincarnation is that even if we all have karmic reincarnationalists cannot convincingly argue that my karmic heir will be me. Secondly, immortality of the soul is the belief that the soul belongs to the realm of the eternal and can therefore exist after the death of the contingent body.

  2. Critically evaluate arguments for and against the death penalty.

    After looking at a short history of the death penalty and it's abolition in the UK, focus turns to those countries who still use capital punishment as the ultimate punishment for committing those brutal and heinous crimes. Many of these countries use capital punishment in different circumstances and for different reasons, for example religion or culture.

  1. The Death Penalty is wrong.

    Any punishment should contribute to the reduction of crime. The punishment for a crime should not be so idle a threat or so slight a deprivation that it has no deterrent or incapacitative effects. Most of all, it certainly should not contribute to an increase in crime. Does the death penalty really deter crime.

  2. The Punishment must fit the crime

    The upholding of what is just especially with rewards and punishment is maintained by the law and is of utmost importance in modern society. We live in a democracy where political leaders are decided by the people. This eradicates any possibility of anarchy and spreads power evenly not just giving it to the party in charge.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work