'Luke's Gospel is the same as Matthew and Mark's Gospels.' Discuss this statement in the light of what you have studied regarding the Synoptic question, your answer should contain both agreement and disagreement with the above statement.

Authors Avatar

‘Luke’s Gospel is the same as Matthew and Mark’s Gospels.’

 Discuss this statement in the light of what you have studied regarding the Synoptic question, your answer should contain both agreement and disagreement with the above statement. (5)

The above statement one could argue that the statement above is wrong and one could also say that it is true. There ways in which it agrees and disagrees  with the statement above  regarding Luke’s Gospel.

One could put forward the argument that it is the same is in the fact that even though Luke’s Gospel contains 1150 verses (100%), 350 verses (17%) of it is identical to Mark’s Gospel and 200 verses (17%) is similar to Matthew. Luke’s Gospel covers most of the same stories as the other two Gospels except for the fact it leaves or adds in other stories that the other two have not mentioned.  For example in Luke it does not mention about the Three Wise Men and the star that led them to the stable where Jesus is born, but Matthew does. In Luke it mentions the parables of the lost coin and sheep, but in the other Gospels there is no mention of the parables. But a verse that they both contain is the death and resurrection of Jesus.

Join now!

Luke 23: 44- 49 (death of Jesus) and Luke 24: 1-12 (resurrection of Jesus)

Mark 15: 21- 32 (death of Jesus) and Mark 16: 1-8 (resurrection of Jesus)

Matthew 27: 32- 44 (death of Jesus) and Matthew 28: 1- 10 (resurrection of Jesus)

But, one could say that the above statement is untrue because the remaining 800 verses (53%) are completely unique towards Luke. Even though Luke has 47% same as two other Gospels, Luke’s writing is slightly different and his themes, which make the similar verses seem quite different. All of Luke’s sources state events that have ...

This is a preview of the whole essay