• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Medical ethics: Three scenarios Mabel, Jack and Rupert.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Medical ethics: Three scenarios Mabel, Jack and Rupert. Scenario one: Mabel Mabel situation brings up ethical arguments regarding abortion, sanctity of life and quality of life, ensoulment and woman's rights. From the perspective of Mabel the first thing she should consider is the quality of life that she would have if she kept the baby. It would also continue the trauma for the mother but also her existing her family. Further more it might be argued that any child of rape might also suffer trauma learning of their violent origins. By doing this Mabel would have to firstly consider her own personal desires in whether she wants to keep a baby at such a young age in those situations. But from making an allowance for her unborn baby she should determine whether the baby's life would be worthwhile. She should also use her own preferences in deciding weighing up the pain and pleasure giving from having a baby or the preferences to allow the baby to live. Her autonomy, which is the value, that comes from the ability to determine ones own future. From the medical ethics view Mabel should not allow her family of friends to make the decision for her as the baby life is in her hands. The baby is unable to determine its own future therefore this decision relies on the mother. ...read more.

Middle

Implantation is the moment when the cluster of cells travel down the fallopian tubes to implant the womb. Pre-embryo occurs when the individual emerges when the cells split and monozgotic twins emerge. The next stage is when the brain activity can be apparent. Viability is when the baby's heart begins to beat. The final perspective on when a person becomes part of a moral community is birth. To conclude I believe Mabel should have an abortion which is justified by the sanctity of life argument that I believe is most important in this situation. In 1938 when soldiers raped a young girl Dr Aleck Bourne gave the girl an abortion in order to safeguard her mental health. The primary consideration in Mabel case is the traumatic circumstances in which conception took place. In terms of violation or fights and reduction of autonomy would justify Mabel over having the rights over her own body. Scenario two: Jack Jack situation causes him to be in pain for 24 hours day 365 days a year for the rest of his life put simply his quality of life would be non-existent. He states that it is his desire and preference is death as his suffering has become unbearable and prolonged. But there are many different forms that euthanasia can take place in. ...read more.

Conclusion

But what is better, letting someone suffer a prolonged and very painful life, or allowing him or her to die with dignity, in peace and without pain? To conclude Jack has asked to die with dignity, but he will spend the last moments of his life, in a way, which to him, is undignified. Having the right to control over their own life and death helps people keep human dignity in the face of their suffering. People should not be left lingering in pain. They should not have to suffer when death is inevitable. Scenario three: Rupert Rupert's scenario is essentially a utilitarian problem but from the perspective of medical ethics it becomes more complicated. Responsibility is major factor in this scene are you willing to be directly responsible for killing 300,000 people or indirectly killing 12 million people. Sanctity of life augments would consider any action were is killing someone is morally and medically wrong. This is because killing someone s against what is written in the bible, which is thalt, shall not kill. Taking of life is prohibited. Another strong sanctity of life argument is destiny. If God has a purpose for all human beings then he himself has decided to let this action take place and we should not intervene in Gods will and absolute power. Also God loves his people equally regardless of status of gender and age. Therefore killing a community to save another would be an in direct conflict of all life being sacred. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Abortion and other medical issues section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Abortion and other medical issues essays

  1. An acceptance of the practice of abortion is incompatible with Christian beliefs in the ...

    In this view he agrees that abortion should be allowed and he does not see it as murder. Because to be murder, he believes that it would have to be a person and he does not believe that a foetus is a person.

  2. Abortion- Moral Issues

    A child with hope and aspirations should not lose the chance to live because of someone's carelessness. Although some people may argue that if a child would not be given a very good upbringing from a mother or father that are unable to cope it deserves to be given an

  1. Religion and Medical Issues

    Some Sikhs believe that it is unacceptable to proceed with IVF treatment; Sikhs believe that the IVF treatment is very similar to abortion. In the method of IVF treatment the eggs need to be fertilised and the eggs which are not fertilised get thrown away, to Sikhs this is similar to abortion as the egg's life has been ended/killed.

  2. Religion and Medical Ethics

    However IVF is a very long expensive process that has a low success rate only 15- 20% of IVF patients give birth. Another treatment similar to IVF is a form of A.I. (artificial insemination), artificial insemination by Husband (AIH). This process involves the husband's sperm being injected into the wife's uterus using mechanical means.

  1. Religion and Medical Ethics: Abortion

    Abortion would deny a foetus the chance to experience life, and gain knowledge and memories. I believe that the quote has a valid opinion, but on the other hand, understand that people cannot always provide for a child, or may have a medical problem which could cause them harm is they went through with a pregnancy.

  2. Coursework H: Medical Issues

    because of their beliefs in the sanctity of life and their belief that humans are made in the image of God as said in Genesis15. Protestants therefore also believe that humans must not be manipulated. Following this, although Protestants permit research on embryos, there are strict criteria that the research

  1. Abortion - a utilitarian view

    At the moment of the situation Jennifer having sex with the guy lead to the greatest happiness possibly and heavily relied on the condom to do its job during intercourse. As a result she now faces the controversial problem in society abortion.

  2. Abortion arguments and powerful images

    I have gathered information about the abortion numbers in 2005 in England and Wales. * There were a total of 186,416 abortions carried out legally and in 2004 the total number of abortions was 185,700 so the number of abortions has decreased by 0.4%.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work