Menna Mansour
900-06-0504
Rhet 102-25
Essay 2, Draft 3.
Dr. Verlenden
Muslims and the west: a never ending conflict.
When it comes to the relationship between Middle East Muslims and Western Christians, both communities, the Islamic and the Western, divide taking either side. Husain Haqqani in “Why Muslims Always Blame the West” wrote about how the Islamic communities, particularly in the Middle East, blame many societies, but mostly western, for all of the problems they currently face in their own countries. Haqqani believes that if people in the Middle East solve such problems; conflict between both sides would be minimized. Even though Haqqani has stressed numerous points that people in the Middle East and in the West should ponder upon, his essay does not put into account recent events found in the Muslim world, it helped the reader in envisioning a simplistic picture of West-East political relationships, and in addition, he jumps to several conclusions in which his support is either too little or non-existent.
Haqqani misrepresented the recent events in the Islamic world in his essay. Haqqani claims that "the conduct and rhetoric of Muslim leaders and their failure to address the stagnation of their societies has also fueled the tensions between Islam and the West (Haqqani, 1)". For such conclusions to be made, fair amount of knowledge of both societies must be kept into consideration. On the other hand, Amil Imani, the author of the article of “Is Islam Misrepresented?” believes that Muslims are misrepresented through the media, especially through the news. She argues that “A case in point is the media’s portrayal of Islam, articulated by politicians and pundits—the talking heads on television and radio, as well as the analysts who write for newspapers and magazines (Imani)". Imani believes that most politicians and media exploit the Islamic communities; however, Muslims have been tolerant towards non-Muslims from the days of Prophet Muhammad up to this very day (Imani). She also mentions that “early on, Muhammad was meek and proclaimed, “For you, your religion, and for me, my religion (Imani)”. Such a statement made by the Prophet himself shows how much the Islamic community bears with other people and their different religions. Quoting something that has been said by the Muslim prophet proves her credibility and her strong support.