• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'On the whole, religious beliefs have done more to stimulate change than to hold it back.' Discuss

Extracts from this document...


Simon Shapcott 'On the whole, religious beliefs have done more to stimulate change than to hold it back.' Discuss Since the early part of the 15th century, science and the scientific understanding that we have of the world has been steadily increasing. The changes that this new science brought about were huge; from works in astronomy to anatomy, every walk of life was affected in some way. This rise in science came at a time when an institutionalised church ruled the Western World and the religious beliefs of the church were considered to be unquestionably true. Did this church support and help nurture the growing scientific world or did it in fact, try to hold it back and suppress its growth? The focus of this essay will be to look at change as the growth of scientific understanding and to see whether religion has held it back or stimulated it. As both these ideas are polarized a middle ground between the two needs to be looked for. It is always difficult to generalise what religious beliefs are. As Einstein (1954) put it most people would agree on what is meant by science but they are likely to disagree on what is the meaning of religion. Here the focus will be on the rise of science in the Western World and the conflicts and harmonies it has with the Christian religion, be it Catholicism or Protestantism. It is necessary to point out that this assessment would not be true of other religions, if you were to tackle the same argument ...read more.


When he did have it published it was condemned by the Inquisition as heretical, and placed on the Index of Prohibited Books, saying that it was "utterly contrary to the Holy Scriptures". (Barbour 1998) As you can see from the Inquisition's reason for banning Copernicus' book, the Church was banning anything that ran contrary to the Scriptures and their interpretation of it. It is clear to see that the Catholic Church in the 15th and 16th centuries were doing everything in their power to maintain the status quo and to suppress any change that could effect their power base. An increase in scientific understanding would do just that. There is another school of thought that would agree that religion has done more to stimulate change than to hold it back, or at the very least not done anything to hold it back. There was a small minority of Catholic thinkers who believed that scientific understanding did not conflict with religion. Cardinal Baronius, an important man in the Catholic Church said in 1598 "The intention of the Holy Ghost is to teach us how one goes to heaven, not how heaven goes." (Barbour 1998) Nevertheless they were in the significant minority. However, you needed to look at the Protestant church to see where religion has really helped stimulate change. There are many theologians and scientists that believe that religion has done much more to stimulate change and scientific understanding than to hold it back. ...read more.


This was why the Church opposed and tried to suppress any advance in science. The Protestant faith however has had a very different effect on science than Catholicism. Protestantism has actively encouraged the growth of science as it sees science as a way of understanding God through the scientific understanding of nature. Calvin and Luther both saw the scriptures as open for interpretation, not to be taken literally but used as a guide on how to live your life. So they had no problem with the conflicts that arose between the scriptures and the scientific discoveries that were made. It is possible to say when weighing up the evidence that the Christian religion as a whole has in fact done more to stimulate and encourage scientific change than to hold it back. The scientific movements in many Protestant countries grew up because of the desire to understand more about God and his work in nature. Without it there would have been no motivation for the scientists to pursue their work. "Although we seldom recognize it, scientific research requires certain basic beliefs about the order and rationality of matter, and its accessibility to the human mind . . . they came to us in their full force through the Judeo-Christian belief in an omnipotent God, creator and sustainer of all things. In such a world view it becomes sensible to try and understand the world, and this is the fundamental reason science developed as it did in the Middle Ages in Christian Europe, culminating in the brilliant achievements of the seventeenth century. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Places of Worship section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Places of Worship essays

  1. Explore the presentation of the theme of religion in "Angela's Ashes"

    This therefore indicates that religion was considered powerful and important, yet it was not fully comprehended by most people.

  2. In the Middle Ages how did religion both Help and Hinder medicine ?

    This was a hinderence because it meant their ideas couldn't be developed. One big hinderence was the fact that human dissection was forbidden, so they did not have much knowledge of anatomy like we do now. If they used Galen's ideas they were not always completely right, one idea that

  1. English Reformation

    With very few signs and demand for future reformations, it would appear that the strength of the Church triumphed over the 'small cells of committed adherents.'

  2. Studies of Religion

    It is usually in an outstanding position so it is clear for viewing which emphasises its ability to act as a memoriam of Jesus' ultimate sacrifice in Mark 15:33, to ensure the people who are in the church practicing the rite at the time are saved21.

  1. "Europe in the 15th century was very different to Europe today".

    for survival, people now prefer to live in large bustling towns or large villages, although there are still very many people who do prefer to live in the countryside the countryside itself is also very built up with main roads etc running through it.

  2. I believe that Lutheranism was very revolutionary as it challenged the beliefs and practises ...

    for Lutheranism shown by the fact that, by 1550, a total of 50 out of 65 imperial free cities were adhering the new faith. The decision to adopt Lutheranism generally came from the town council, yet often there was much pressure local populace to do so.

  1. How useful are the secondary sources provided in understanding Medieval Monasticism compared with the ...

    It obviously had power, and it was the biggest abbey in Europe by the 15th Century. I understand that very important goods were kept in this area, which increases the significance of the building. I also know that the bars were there in order to protect the abbey from the

  2. The process whereby religion looses its influence over social life and society is known ...

    Also politicians no longer find it necessary to be involved with members of the clergy and to have them symbolically legitimate their political position. This shows evidence, of decline in the relevance of religion, in contemporary Irish society. (Inglis, 1998: 220-222)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work