• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Outline The Criticisms Of Action Based Ethical Systems

Extracts from this document...


Outline The Criticisms Of Action Based Ethical Systems One criticism would be that Action- Based Ethics lack a motivational component. Critics claim that action based ethics are uninspiring and very negative. They would say that it fails to inspire someone to action. Most of the commandments and rules in such systems are innately negative "Thou shalt not..." There is something unfit about a morality which is so unevenly defined in terms of "Thou shalt nots", emphasising innocence instead of an "energetic pursuit of the Good". The only sure principle is a reciprocal duty to do no harm. This kind of theory places a very low value on morality, judging it mainly as a necessary evil. The aretaist rejects this judgement, they see morality as an intrinsically worthwhile activity. ...read more.


In this regard, the legalistic bent of modern moral theory has the effect of weakening the spirit of morality. Rules often get in the way of kindness and spontaneous charity. Also, action based ethics often ignore the spiritual dimension of ethics. Action based ethics reduce all moral judgement to judgements about actions and neglect the spiritual qualities of gratitude, self respect, sympathy, having one's emotions in proper order, and aspiring to become a certain kind of person. Virtue ethicists often cite Kant's theory as a model of an anti- virtue ethics. They point out that a trial of Kant's extreme action- centred approach highlights the need for a virtue alternative. For Kant; natural goodness is morally irrelevant. The fact that you actually want to help someone is of no moral importance. ...read more.


We don't make moral decisions as rational atoms in a vacuum, and it is sheer ideological sightlessness that allows this disfigured perception. It is in communities that such virtues as loyalty, natural affection, spontaneous sympathy, and shared concerns arise and sustain the group. It is out of this primary loyalty that the proper dispositions arise that flow out to the rest of humanity. Seeing how people actually learn to be moral and how they are inspired to act morally is vital to moral theory itself, and this, it seems, has everything to do with the virtues. In conclusion, rule-governed systems are uninspiring and unmotivating, negative, improperly legalistic, neglectful of the spiritual dimension, overly rationalistic, and atomistic. Against this background of dissatisfaction with traditional moral theory, virtue ethics has reasserted itself as offering something that captures the essence of the moral point of view. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ethics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ethics essays

  1. Compare and contrast Plato and Aristotle on the acquisition of ethical understanding.

    This is backed up by Plato's argument that philosophers should become guardians in the state, as they know what is the best for the individual and the group and so it is obvious that they have acquired ethics in Plato's mind.

  2. Christian Aid - A Charity Helping Poverty

    The banks were charging to higher loan interest rates. There income was �28 million. In the eighties there was a campaign to make the big banks reduce or cancel the third world debt. Total income was over �31 million. Christian Aids main aim is to make people live on there own 2 feet.

  1. Explain how Aristotle and Alasdair Macintyre applied Virtue Theory to moral decision making?

    This is the strength of virtue ethics as an ethical guideline for happiness. Virtue ethics recognizes that good people can be put into difficult situations where any outcome has bad consequences. Acting in such a situation, however, would not necessarily make someone a bad person, though repeatedly doing so almost certainly would.

  2. With the growth of the Internet, concerns have arisen over the legal and ethical ...

    If they fail to do so, they will "suffer the consequences that all companies suffer.

  1. What are the main features of Utilitarianism as an ethical theory? Examine and consider ...

    He also realised that circumstances could occur where sadism or masochism could be determined as pleasurable, and therefore a majority could enforce this upon a minority. The most recognised example of this is of the 'Sadistic Guards' scenario, where a group of prison guards enjoy torturing a prisoner.

  2. How Successful is The Co-operative Banks Ethical policy?

    involved in several areas of business, some of which include; insurance, food retailing, farm care, food services, property and development, funeral services, and manufacturing. The bank itself was established in one form in 1872. It is now a large bank with well over a hundred stores nation wide; it is now also involved in Internet banking with www.smile.co.uk.

  1. If an action is done as a result of affection, rather than as a ...

    A person who understands the nature of this obligation and acts upon it is moral; otherwise they are not. Kant's moral theory explains the many different ways in why we do these actions. The first: obligation. An obligation is one, which we ought to do despite inclinations to do otherwise.

  2. "Medical research in the U.K. is being suffocated by excessive governance and ethical review".

    Various legislative reforms continue to occur including the 2004 clinical trial regulations.17 The "Warner Report" In view of these continuing changes in policy and burdensome nature of research ethics committees, Lord Warner, in late 2004 a junior health minister arranged for an independent ad hoc advisory review of all NHS

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work