• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Shared Traits of the Christian, Islamic and Jewish Interpretations of Their Common God, and the Logical Testing of the Validity of His Existence By That Definition

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

SHARED TRAITS OF THE CHRISTIAN, ISLAMIC AND JEWISH INTERPRETATIONS OF THEIR COMMON GOD, AND THE LOGICAL TESTING OF THE VALIDITY OF HIS EXISTENCE BY THAT DEFINITION Is there a God? Well, that depends. Which god are you talking about? Zeus? Odin? Isis? Jehovah? Allah? Yahweh? The Trinity? The last four are in fact the same God, worshipped by four different groups. Jehovah and the Trinity are both worshipped by Christian sects, Allah by Muslims, and Yahweh by Jews. Each group disagrees with each other group about the particulars concerning their God, but all agree on the basics. The following is a breakdown of the definition of God which all three monotheistic (only one god exists) religions. Since these are the Big Three religions of the world, and they all look to the same God, I will try to logically deduce whether this God can indeed exist. The other three gods are by and large no longer worshipped, so I can save an analysis of their existence for another day. As for the hundreds of other gods worshipped throughout the world, there is not space enough here to consider them. ...read more.

Middle

Their existence would be pointless. Further still, God need not instill free will upon his servants. They need only be automations. They need not even be self-aware. Why would they be granted self-awareness, then? Why would they be granted the ability to disobey? Does god require some means to alleviate boredom, so he grants us an ability to be unpredictable? If God is omniscient, there is no such thing as unpredictability. Also, a perfect god would need no alleviation from boredom. Does God want his creations to entertain him with their conflicts? That again suggests a desire, and also adds maliciousness to Gods personality, which suggests a fault. A perfect being has no faults. Thus, we have disproved the first supposition in the definition of God. The being cannot be both perfect and the creator. Since we have disproved a part of the definition, the whole definition is at fault. The being described cannot exist. God cannot exist. Summary * It is impossible that a perfect God would bother with creating or interfering with the Universe. * It is impossible for God to be both perfect and creator. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is contrary to the idea of omnipotence. While he would still be vastly powerful, especially to the eyes of a human, he is not all-powerful. Gods definition has thus been whittled away even further. Again we can declare God a fictional being, or we can continue to refine the definition and attempt to save him. Sorry. Three strikes. Gods out. Summary * It is impossible for God to be omnipotent. Conclusion It is impossible for the monotheistic God worshipped by Christians, Jews and Muslims to exist. We are left with three possibilities; another god exists which we have yet to define, multiple gods (defined or undefined) exist, no gods exist. The most probable of these, if we are to follow Ockhams Razor (do not multiply entities unnecessarily / take the simplest explanation possible, but no simpler an explanation), is that there are no gods. And what of the God we have debunked? He is best described as the ultimate imaginary friend, a delusional source of security for a people who find it difficult to deal with the hardship of everyday life. Yet like the child who must relinquish his fantasy friend and face the real world in order to truly mature, so to must the human race face reality if it is to mature into a truly advanced species. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Explain the Christian idea of God. How is this idea of God reflected in ...

    The seventh, eighth, ninth and tenth commandments are written in the following "Do not commit adultery", "Do not steal", "Do not accuse anyone falsely", "Do not desire to take another man's possessions" these are social related commandments. They create a more morally aware society.

  2. Arguments about god.

    often extremely hard to explain, almost as if the human language isn't enough to describe the extremity of the emotions involved. It also seems to be unique to each viewer so no one else understands. Often the onlooker describes the experience as a window to another, better world.

  1. Examine the differences which may exist between a religious and scientific interpretation of the ...

    The Creation Story can be found at the very start of Genesis, the very first book of the Bible, indeed "the beginning" of the Bible is that "God created the Heavens and the Earth". The creation story is famous for the fashion, and the time-scale in which "God created" the

  2. Good and Evil

    Other Christians to this would say that the answer is found in the first few chapters of Genesis. God created everything perfect and beautiful, when Adam and Eve sinned, a curse was placed on the earth and everything became broken and degraded.

  1. The Nature of God Religious Studies Coursework. I am going to explain, discuss and ...

    ever be observed by us and therefore a non-conscious being, in this case God, must have been present to have created it and eventually us. Paley also used the analogy of the rock in a field. By this he meant that if you were to find a rock in a

  2. Does God Exist?

    Many philosophers and theologians have provided varying ideas about how to prove the existence of God, the ontological and Cosmological arguments are two different arguments which attempt to prove that god is necesary The ontological argument, is one of the argument that attempts to prove that God is necessary, The

  1. A Big Bang Cosmological Argument for God's Nonexistence

    If somebody says, 'it does not matter to God whether the universe he creates is animate or inanimate,' this person is operating with a concept of God that is at odds with classical theism. I think it would be granted by virtually all contemporary theists in the analytic tradition (M.

  2. T H E C O S M O L O G ...

    It is in this sense that the Cosmological argument is sometimes held to depend on the Ontological, as the Ontological argument starts from the definition that God is the most perfect possible being. Ockham's point might be re-stated by claiming that this position is needed by Christianity but cannot be established by the Cosmological argument.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work