• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Show how the theodicies of Irenaeus and Augustine account for natural evil.

Extracts from this document...


Romi Verstappen (a) Show how the theodicies of Irenaeus and Augustine account for natural evil. The problem of evil concerns the challenge of how an all-powerful and all-loving God can allow his creation to suffer, without helping then and putting an end to their suffering. This challenge is an often quoted reason for being unable to believe in God for it is argued, either God does not exist or, if he does then he is not a God worthy of out worship. St Augustine (AD354-430) tried to solve this problem and based his arguments on the Bible, especially the stories of the creation and the fall in Genesis. For Augustine, God is the source of everything, which he believed had been created out of nothing - 'ex nihilo'. As a result everything in the world is created good and therefore the world is perfect and free from faults. As far as Augustine was concerned all creation is good and it expresses the perfection of God's creativity and goodness, 'God saw all that he had made, and it was very good'. This implies that suffering and evil were unknown within this world. He argued that as God is perfect he could not be blamed for the fact that evil does exist within the world, and that any evil that is found is purely deprivation, not a substance - evil and unhappiness is the cause of lack of good and happiness. ...read more.


In our lives we have choices and it is through these life choices that we develop into 'good' creatures and into the 'likeness' of God. In order for us to develop morally toward God we had to be created and exist at a distance from him, therefore there had to be evil in the world. Natural evil (for example famine) had a divine purpose which was for us to develop qualities such as compassion. Therefore unlike Augustine, Irenaeus believes that God is partly responsible for evil. Irenaeus saw evil as a necessary part of life, something that will eventually make us into better people. Irenaeus sees the world as being unfinished and that we are moving towards a perfect world without evil but we have not reached it yet. God's purpose was not to create a paradise where the world was free of pain and suffering, but as a place where we can develop our souls and where we can become children of God'. God wants us to develop through our free will to become 'children'. The only way we can achieve this, we must be epistemically distanced from God in order to give us the perfect environment to develop both spiritually and morally into 'good' individuals. ...read more.


Another is that in this world we must live in a way that improves our soul and allows us to get in to heaven, so to act in a good way, evil has to exist. A third response is that God is the most highly intelligent and knowledgeable being in the universe so he may have reasons that the human mind cannot comprehend. A fourth response is that suffering is a punishment from God, suffering is a use for God to test us and that suffering stops people from straying away from their belief in God. The 18th century philosopher David Hume used the idea of a triangle, on which to base his argument. One side says, 'God is all powerful', the other says 'God is all powerful' and the third side says 'evil does not exist'. Hume stated that only 2 of the 3 can exist, and the existence of evil and suffering cannot be denied. Therefore one of the other statements about God is not true. Either God is all-powerful, but does not care for the world, or God loves the world, yet is not powerful enough to do anything about the evil and suffering. Either way it is looked at this means that the religious believer is lead to have doubts about God. They may question whether God is actually as powerful or as loving as is said. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. What is the problem of evil?

    Irenaeus concluded that at first, humans were made in God's image and only later would develop into his likeness. For Irenaeus, being in God's image involved having intelligence, morality and personality, yet it lacked completion. Completion would only be gained upon transformation into God's likeness.

  2. Judaism: Good and Evil - Describe what followers of the religion you are studying ...

    God may have been punishing their race for not apologising. * The suffering in the Holocaust may be a test to see whether we deserve heaven. * God is not responsible for evil. But he was there at the Holocaust to prevent more suffering.

  1. Explain how natural evil may be seen as a challenge to belief in God ...

    So his/her belief is less than rational, and there is no reason why an atheist should share it. However, for your own personal faith it doesn't really matter if you don't know the answer to why evil exists if God is all-loving and powerful, because you'll still have faith in God and believe.

  2. Good and Evil

    did the definitive good and subsequently Christians do not doubt the fact that they must follow Jesus' ways to show thankfulness for him dying for us. However Roman Catholics believe that when someone has been good all their lives, but not good enough, they will go to a place called

  1. Critically Discuss D.Z. Phillips Conception of Immortality.

    Again this would not my soul but the soul and, as such, any talk of my soul being immortal would seem rather meaningless. Both believers and non-believers may make a further objection. Believers may argue that Phillips's alternative picture of immortality may be all well and good but that is not their picture of immortality.

  2. Explain how the theodicy of Irenaeus differs from that of Augustine.

    God is a perfect and omnibenevolent being and Augustine stated that evil could not logically stem from something perfect. Augustine believed that Adam and Eve were created faultless and were the first human beings given free choice. When they subsequently abused this choice, the idea that the whole human

  1. What do religious believers mean by the 'problem of suffering?' Select any two ...

    Augustine continues to explain that God gave all humans and angels free will and therefore evil came from a deliberate choice to disobey God. Love demands a free response and so God had to take the risk that human beings would inflict suffering.

  2. Research on St Augustine Theodicy.

    self in desire from the highest Good, which is God himself, to some lesser good' (Hick p.60). However, it is not the act itself which makes a being evil but the premeditated desire to do wrong (motive). When Adam took and ate the fruit from the tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil (Genesis 3)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work