The boundaries between ethics and science are very controversial. Many scientists have the attitude that they are willing to do anything if it provides for a gain in knowledge.
Christine Long
05/09/03
IB Theory of Knowledge
Epps
The boundaries between ethics and science are very controversial. Many scientists have the attitude that they are willing to do anything if it provides for a gain in knowledge. Others have tried to impose a set of ethical values over the gaining of knowledge. They have attempted to make prior judgments as to what science should or should not do based on attempts to project into the future what the outcome and implications a given of scientific investigation will have for society. Can science function over these constraints? Can negative results that some scientific investigation has on society be avoided by exercising this restraint? Or does science to be conducted properly have to be free to seek knowledge freely, leaving society to deal with consequences only after the fact? Can science be honest and ethical and objective all at the same time?
In the film Trinity and Beyond: The Atomic Bomb Movie, Dr. Edward Teller says of the Hydrogen bomb: “…others didn’t want to do it, but I didn’t care. I was interested in knowledge, knowledge, and more knowledge.” With this, Teller didn’t care about the affects of the H-bomb; he only cared about the knowledge that he gains from this experimentation. Why is he so apt to gaining knowledge? What usually motivates people to desire the gain of knowledge? Is it all for one’s self-achievement? I surely would think not. What would be the point in gaining knowledge only for you? The objective of science is to further the knowledge of mankind; to understand more how the world works? Why would someone be so apt to gain knowledge about the H-bomb, with the goal of advancing the knowledge of mankind, and at the same time not care about the affects it has on mankind? By the result of some people becoming more knowledgeable, other people are killed and/or suffer severe chronic side affects.