• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

THE MORAL ARGUMENT

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

THE MORAL ARGUMENT for the existence of God ************************ Immanuel Kant ----------------- Kant did NOT put forward a moral argument and anyone who said he does is wrong!!!! Kant rejected all attempts to argue from the world to God, he regarded such an exercise as impossible. However he thought that God was a POSTULATE of practical reason. If you share Kant's assumptions, then it becomes necessary to assume that there is a God. Kant's reasoning.... 1. All human beings desire and seek happiness 2. All human beings ought to be moral and do their duty 3. The universe is fair 4. The Summum Bonum (highest good) represents virtue and happiness 5. Everyone seeks the summum bonum (from (1) and (2)) 6. What is sought must be achievable because the universe is fair (see (3)) 7. The Summum Bonum is not achievable in this life 8. So it is necessary to POSTULATE a life after death in which the Summum Bonum can be achieved 9. AND it is necessary to POSTULATE a God to guarantee fairness. Note the emphasis on life after death and God as POSTULATES. Kant did not think that either of these could be proved. What he is claiming is that IF you hold the universe is fair and IF the Summum Bonum can be achieved then life after death and God are necessary postulates. ...read more.

Middle

The Forms are not created or creative and even Plato's God, the Demiurge, is responsible to them. If, therefore, one is a Platonist one could hold that there are absolute morals but these do not need a god to explain them. BERTRAND RUSSELL's disproof of God Bertrand Russell takes an opposing view to Lewis and Sorley, maintaining that it is possible to actually use morality to disprove God's existence. His argument proceeds as follows: 1. If there is a moral law it either stems from God or it does not 2. If the moral law comes from God it is arbitrary (because whatever God commands is our definition of goodness) 3. If it does not come from God then God is subject to it (this is one horn of the Euthyphro dilemma) 4. So either God is not essentially good (because he is arbitrary about what is right or wrong) OR God is subject to an independent moral standard. 5. Neither an arbitrary God nor a less than ultimate God is worthy of worship. 6. Therefore there is no God. This argument refers to Plato's EUTHYPHRO (the title of a book setting out a dialogue between Socrates and a young man, Euthyphro). This dilemma is due to there being two possibilities * Either there is a standard of morality independent of God (as Plato maintained was the case with the Forms) ...read more.

Conclusion

Freud ----- The influence of Freud has led to a dismissal by some of the whole idea of conscience on the basis of its perceived links with feelings of guilt which are considered to be unhealthy. Freud says: "The long period of childhood during which the growing human being lives in dependence on his parents leaves behind it a precipitate, which forms within his ego a special agency in which this parental influence is prolonged. It has received the name of 'super-ego'. The parents' influence naturally includes not only the personalities of the parents themselves but also the racial, national and family traditions handed on through them, as well as the demands of the immediate social milieu which they represent."2 Conscience, then, may be argued to be little more than the inherited traditions of the community and family in which one is brought up and which lives in one's super-ego for the rest of one's life. This, naturally, undermines any claim that there is a connection between God and human conscience. 1 J.H.Newman 'Difficulties of Anglicans' Vol. 2, London 1891 pp. 246-7 2 Sigmund Freud. Trans Strachey 'An outline of Psychoanalysis'. Hogarth Press: 1949 pps. 3-4 ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 Dialogue Education - The Moral Argument ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Living In a Plural Society.

    Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image. III. Thou shalt not take the name of the LORD thy God in vain. IV. Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. V. Honour thy father and thy mother.

  2. T H E C O S M O L O G ...

    If 'necessary being' means only 'imperishable being', then the universe itself may be necessary. This is similar to Russell's point in his debate with Copleston. IF one accepts (and Russell did not) that things in the world are contingent, why should not the Universe as a whole be necessary?

  1. Explain the Ontological argument.

    Kant what is effectively arguing 'If I experience the world of objective morality, what must I be accepting is true?' Kant concluded that there were three types of assumptions; freedom, immorality and God. Kant named these the postulates of morality.

  2. Unless we assume that everyone is free to make moral choices, we have no ...

    view by investigating the subconscious and looking for motivations for our actions. However, such studies may be rejected as "unscientific" and subsequently unreliable. They certainly provide little persuasive evidence in favour of determinism. Theistic determinists, such as J. Edwards, hold that God is the ultimate cause who determines all human actions, citing the Bible as proof.

  1. Religion and society - The Cosmology argument.

    * Created the sun, moon stars and planets. * Separated night form day. * Sent water to the Earth and created vegetation. * Created birds, fish and animals. * Created Adam, as the first human being. Adam was made, out of clay, into which God breathed life.

  2. If there were no God, would there be any morality

    There is perhaps an even more virtuous aspect to atheists who obey moral laws when they have little or no motivation, which for religious believers comes in the form of an afterlife.

  1. T H E D E S I G N A R ...

    world must be like the creator of a machine only far greater. Hume's criticisms aim to destroy the argument of Cleanthes by mockery. Philo then replies with two arguments: Philo's First Argument Like effects imply like causes - so we end of with a caricature of God, a God who

  2. Identify 3 novels, short stories or poems that would have special significance to the ...

    'It's twice as big as ever before. No, ten times, maybe a thousand.' 'This isn't like the first one or the dozen later ones. This is different. Nobody knows what it might do when it comes.' They waited on the porch in the smell of roses and cut grass.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work