• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent, if at all, should conscience be ignored when making moral decisions?

Extracts from this document...


Siobhan Burrow 1081 To what extent, if at all, should conscience be ignored when making moral decisions? We cannot know what conscience is in absolute terms and various models of conscience have existed throughout Christian history. There are two main approaches to conscience there is the Intuitionist approach and the Rationalistic approach. The intuitionist approach is that our conscience is rooted in our intuitive or God given feelings of right and wrong. On the other hand rationalistic approaches claim that conscience is rooted in the power of reason. Many theologians have given their definition of conscience; St Augustine took an intuitionistic approach to conscience and claimed that conscience is "Gods voice whispering to us" (Considering Conscience David Torevell.) By contrast St Thomas Aquinas took a rationalistic approach to conscience claiming that conscience is synderesis or the repeated use of practical reason. Aquinas further stated that it is the solemn duty of all to follow what conscience dictates even if it leads us to err morally. St Augustine's approach to conscience simply reminds us that God should be present in all our moral decision-making. However Augustine fails to give any credit to our own power of reason in working out what is good our evil. For me I believe that conscience is not just a voice whispering in my ear or a feeling or instinct, it is my judgement to do the best thing in that situation. ...read more.


For example when conscience is defective. Enda Mc Douagh asserts that "conscience enables us to judge good and evil, reproaches us when we have done wrong and praises us when we do the right thing." (David Torevell quoted in considering conscience) This implies that conscience is an inner monitor or judge of moral behaviour and is in some sense involuntary. In many instances this reaction acts as an important guide: I do not kill because I know that it is wrong. This is because conscience is in one sense experienced as internalised moral law-giving rise to the voice of conscience. However if conscience is an internalised voice should I necessary regard this voice as authoritative in all cases? Augustine claims that God implants knowledge of "Right Conduct" in human beings and that you cannot act rightly without the grace of God directing your will in the appropriate way. He says, "to live well is nothing other than to love God with all ones heart, soul and mind." (Conscience in world religions Helen Costigane) Therefore Augustine directs us to thinking that two people could do a good a good act for example, giving up a seat for an old women, but only the person whose motive was for the love of God would have performed a morally right action. The other may have been acting out of guilt or for the recognition of those around them. ...read more.


Take another example, conscription in wartime. My conscience may lead me to believe that it is my duty to defend my country from a greater evil. Is it not better though to be a pacifist, even if organised violence appears to be the only effective means of limiting greater violence and evil tyrants such as Hitler? Pacifists still have a role to play perhaps Martin Luther King and Gandhi may also teach us that we are obliged to exhaust non-violent means of righting a wrong before resorting to other tactics. In conclusion I believe that it is always important to listen to our conscience. Whether we choose to use the information that it provides is a personal decision but it is better to know that we have listened to our conscience but choose not to act upon it for a good reason. Conscience no doubt plays a crucial role when we come to make moral decisions. Many theologians and philosophers have struggled to define it and how it operates. Faith points us to its central authoritative position as a guide. Also we need to educate the conscience in a reasonable way. The conscience is a gift from God that serves as a guide for moral and ethical decisions, but is not an absolute standard in itself. This inward warning system is a helper, but is subservient to the superior rules and laws handed down to us from God Himself in the Holy Scriptures. While following one's conscience most often can be a proper course of action, the conscience is not infallible. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ethics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ethics essays

  1. Discuss whether moral judgements are subjective or objective

    Subjectivists believe that they cannot say another persons morality is wrong only that it is different from their moral opinion. A persons moral decision may say a great deal about the person making the decision but not about what is universally right and wrong.

  2. Outline the main features of Jeremy Bentham's guide to making moral decisions.

    He believed that no one pleasure was better than another. For example going to Paris for a long weekend over going to the Caribbean for a week. He believed that as long as the individuals are maximising their own participation in pleasure it is good.

  1. Discuss whether moral judgments are subjective or objective

    Who is to judge what makes one individual happy? For example sadists seek their pleasure from experiencing and witnessing pain. This is not applicable to all humans - most of which find on happiness in this was at all. This in turn raises the question as to whether through this definition of happiness; utilitarianism excluded the minority of individuals from sharing the greatest happiness.

  2. Kantians believe promises should always be kept even if breaking brings about benefits because ...

    They are using her to get the son into medical school. Also the son is not respecting the job because if he did he will notice that he cannot become a surgeon because he will kill patients. Also, Kantian will see that by keeping his promise he is not respecting

  1. Explain how Aristotle and Alasdair Macintyre applied Virtue Theory to moral decision making?

    So in Aristotle's opinion the chosen end is eudaimonia, and the telos is to live a life of a Greek gentlemen philosopher. His main argument is that reason will entitle the individual to happiness and the ability to make moral decisions, and reach telos.

  2. "Miller's plays show is that happiness can only be achieved by making moral compromises" ...

    For example, they have a maid, and an extensive piece of narrative is used at the beginning of the play to describe their house - "two storeys high and has seven rooms". The only way the Keller family could have kept such a house through the Depression and lack of

  1. With reference to abortion, examine and comment on the view that the sanctity of ...

    Because human life isn't respected or valued. In short, to any teleological theory, murder could potentially be justified, and therefore proved to be the morally right thing to do. So, should the view of the sanctity of life be regarded as a moral absolute, and thus making abortion the morally right or wrong thing to do?

  2. How might a moral relativist respond to the claim that people should always tell ...

    Another form of ethical naturalism reduces all ethical statements to expressions of approval or disapproval, whether personal or general. So if I say 'Mother Theresa was good', I am not saying anything about the person herself but I am saying that 'I approved of Mother Theresa'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work