• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To What Extent Is the Welfare State Responsible For Creating a Culture of Dependency?

Extracts from this document...


TO WHAT EXTENT IS THE WELFARE STATE RESPONSIBLE FOR CREATING A CULTURE OF DEPENDENCY? STUDENT NAME: Lisa Murphy TUTOR NAME: Eddie McKeever SUBJECT: Sociology (DIFS) SUBMISSION DATE: 16th March 2005 TO WHAT EXTENT IS THE WELFARE STATE RESPONSIBLE FOR CREATING A CULTURE OF DEPENDENCY? In this essay I want to be able to determine to what extent the welfare state is responsible for creating 'a culture of dependency.' I will be using several different resources to gather my information, such as the internet and books. The causes of poverty There are two differing types of explanations for the causes of poverty: > Dependency > Exclusion Dependency explanations These approaches argue that people are poor because of some deficiency in themselves or which is passed on in the group to which they belong in society. Within this overall approach to explaining the causes of poverty, we can distinguish approaches which have different emphases. These are: > the underclass > culture of poverty The Underclass This argument was first developed by an American man called Charles Murray who claims that an underclass exists of people who are lazy and make no effort to work or look after themselves. They have come to believe that it is their right to receive benefits from the government and not have to work. ...read more.


Although changes have been introduced in the system since it was initiated between 1945-50, it remains fundamentally the same. However, from 1979 to 1997 the Conservative government showed that it would like to see the system, partially dismantled in favour of a two-tier scheme. For instance, in the sphere of medicine, it would like to have seen more people paying for private health care whilst only those who could not afford to pay would go to the National Health Service. The reasons why the Labour Government introduced a Welfare State have to be seen against: > The background of twenty hears of mass unemployment before the Second World War, when there was little help given to alleviate poverty. > The previous measures introduced by the Liberal government were found to be totally inadequate. > The wartime destruction of British cities gave the drive for the construction of new, better-built houses in well planned environments. > There was an overwhelming desire shared by the mass of the British people never to return to pre-war conditions. Advantages of the Welfare State > It has eliminated the worst excesses of poverty > It helps people who through no fault of their own (such as a physical disability) are unable to work, and without financial aid would be reduced to begging or voluntary charity. ...read more.


Those who are on this benefit do not have to pay council tax, or prescription and dental charges amongst others. If this benefit did not exist families may be better off on unemployment benefit. Dean and Taylor-Gobby have also criticised the dependency theory. They argue that the idea that the Welfare State has created a population who are content not to work, is a myth. Dean and Taylor-Gobby carried out an investigation which involved conducting eighty five in depth interviews of benefit claimants. They found that all but four of their sample had not lost the desire to work. However, they did find that some of their sample were reluctant to come off welfare benefits to take low paid work, thus, supporting the work of Jordan. Therefore it can be argued that rather than welfare benefits creating a burden of dependency, it has created a reluctant population of dependants. In conclusion, it would appear that if sociologists and politicians wish to understand the reasons why individuals do not give up a life on welfare for a job, the world of work needs to be examined. The government however, are doing very little to tempt people back into the workforce, therefore it could be said that the government are somewhat contributing to this dependency. It would then seem that in this instance that the government wants to have its cake and eat it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Charities, Poverty and Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Charities, Poverty and Development essays

  1. To what extent do the practices of charitable organisations comply with charity laws and ...

    4.2 Financial reporting Like for-profit organizations, charities are subjected to reporting requirements particularly in the financial area to the government and other charity regulatory bodies. Through these reports, a charity's performance and probity can be evaluated with regards to income and expenditure.

  2. Wealth and poverty essay

    The north part of the world has more economically developed countries (MEDCS) and the south part of the world has less economically developed countries (LEDCS) These third world countries remain undeveloped for a number of reasons, natural disasters are common in LEDCS earthquakes (Tsunami, Asian Earth Quake)

  1. Outline and assess sociological explanations for the increase in poverty when living standards for ...

    Not only did poor people suffer from low incomes, they were also lively to live in seriously substandard housing, they often had poor diets, their children went to a primary school which lacked modern amenities and they lived in an area which could be best described as a slum.

  2. The State of the World Today

    However, there are those people who would consider the role of man on natural suffering e.g. poverty as a result of drought in Africa. I acquiesce that whilst humanity can not be blamed for this suffering, most of us (humanity)

  1. Livable Wages to American Citizens

    Without a livable-wage income, people suffer a lack of dignity and a variety of social and health problems. The livable-wage income indicator is defined as the percent of the population living in households with a total income that is less than twice the poverty level, as defined by the federal government.

  2. The thorny issue of social exclusion is once again in the headlines.

    Mo Mowlam described the initiative as a "new drive to close the poverty gap." She said that she recognised "that there are still too many communities, too many families, not sharing in our rising prosperity.

  1. Health in London between 1850 and 1910 - source based work.

    of the poverty which is also important as result in this source. Linking this source-to-source f, which has a connective because poverty is the cause of poor health. In this source it shows that not enough houses for the poor.

  2. The origins of social security lie much further back in our social history than ...

    Indoor relief was provided in the shape of workhouses, but conditions inside the workhouse were made to be undesirable for example, families were separated, to make it as unappealing as possible. The legislation also introduced 'less eligibility'; this labelled the able-bodied poor less than the lowest paid worker.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work