• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using an examination of Act One, Scene Three (punishment) as a starting point, explore the varying ways in which Wertenbaker presents different attitudes to punishment in the play as a whole?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Saturday, 14 December 2002 Jad Salfiti A2 English Literature Using an examination of Act One, Scene Three (punishment) as a starting point, explore the varying ways in which Wertenbaker presents different attitudes to punishment in the play as a whole? 'Our Country's Good' is based on events that occurred in the first penal colony to be set up in Australia in 1789. The play deals with the prisoners in the colony, who were imprisoned for minor infractions, while still in Britain. It tells of the abuse they endured at the hands of their officers, in the world's most remote outpost. Some British convicts were dragged over from Britain for petty crimes such as stealing a morsel of food. These harsh laws were imposed in direct response to public opinion. This 'public' wanted severe punishment for those crimes committed against property (i.e. theft), and was less concerned with crimes against the self (i.e. murder). After a horrendously severe voyage at sea, and with rations becoming dangerously low, the Governor of the colony, Captain Arthur Phillip realizes that morale is at an all time low. In an effort to uplift the spirits of the convicts and officers, he suggests a stage play be presented. The convicts would take the parts in this comedy; 'The Recruiting Officer'. In Act One Scene Three, political conflict in shown in attitudes towards punishment: should prison act to rehabilitate or to punish. ...read more.

Middle

Phillip believes that a 'bad' person can reform his or her ways and for that reason Phillip and Ralph would be categorised as a liberal also. Ross refers to the play as "frippery frittering!" he clearly does not sympathise "the theatre leads to threatening theory and you, governor; you have His Majesty's omission..." Ross illustrates his bigoted nature throughout this scene showing how cynical, xenophobic, misogynistic, and plain opinionated he is. Ross thinks the point of prison is to punish and only to punish. Ross' Ideological position is best described as fascist or extreme right-wing. Watkin Tench, on the other hand best represents Hobbes's views. Tench argues that the criminal tendency is innate and definitive, "If you commit a crime, you are a criminal". Tench would be categorised as a Lockeian. Hobbes believed that criminals should enjoy no more rights than a slave; there is no room for redemption. Furthermore Locke had a materialist conception of human nature, and argued that no ideas are innate. Tench is convinced that sin is in the prisoner's "nature", this is parallel to Locke's view. Locke argued that all our thoughts result from impressions we receive through our five senses (and from the ideas we may then synthesize from these original, simple thoughts. Tench argues that the prisoners "have a habit of vice and crime" this shows conservative affiliation. Tench views morality as absolute, that it is, not dependent on society or situation. ...read more.

Conclusion

Ketch is abdicating responsibility for the deaths he has caused. His yearning for acceptance is overt; he has been made a social outcast and is victim of his job, paradoxically another victim of the enforcement of punishment. This scene acts as Ketch's confession, his testimony and evidently releases him for the torment he has received at the hands of the female convicts. Ketch like Harry appears to want Ralph to pardon him "it's the women they're without mercy- not like you and, Sire, men". Ketch wants forgiveness from the women who are constantly reminding him, and wants to be released from the humiliation and hurt in scene eleven 'The First rehearsal' the women all hiss and spit at Ketch. And he is not allowed to forget that he is the one that has hanged all their friends and acquaintances as Dabby points out "So we are Mr. Hangman". Ketch desires female love and affection. There is a curious mixture of the physical and spiritual permeated into Ketch's language, Catholicism is indoctrinated with his language "but it's God's judgment I'm frightened of. And the women's". Punishment emerges as a major theme within the play, the Officers articulate political views and the conflict between left and right wing politics: the usage of corporal and capital punishment. Many other forms of punishment emerge within the play including whether imprisonment should act to rehabilitate or punish convicts. Punishment is seen as a form of ostracism, alienation, polarisation as demonstrated by Ketch. Finally Harry is self-punishing for the death of, he feel he is responsible for the death of his sexual rival. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Capital Punishment section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Capital Punishment essays

  1. Capital Punishment Amendment Act 1868

    The second was taken from the belief that enlightenment and mental progression called for a more dignified death for the offender and that to witness it was not deemed civilised. As far back as the mid 1700's Henry Fielding is quoted as saying that public executions were 'poorly staged, too

  2. Capital Punishment is no longer practised in our society. Explain what differing Christian ...

    (God had the right to do so). Before the time of Noah, there was capital punishment, but it was up to the victim's relatives to avenge the murderer. In the covenant with Noah, God takes justice out of the hands of the families of the victims and puts it into the hands of HUMAN GOVERNMENT; therefore justice could be done more objectively.

  1. Capital punishment - One of the most controversial debates that rages constantly in this ...

    They say that, because it is impossible to ever be 100% sure about anything, the death penalty should not be used when someone might be innocent. This argument has been bolstered recently, as a significant number of prisoners presumed guilty of first-degree murder have been released from prison because of new evidence in their cases.

  2. Capital Punishment

    The deterrent argument is classically the lynchpin of utilitarianism and especially its founding Jeremy Bentham. In his Principles of Penal Law Bentham argued that: Punishment is unnecessary if the offence will not recur, also punishment is only appropriate to dissuade others from behaving in the same way and punishment is therefore to protect society for the future.

  1. Derek Bentley's Last Thoughts.

    How will people remember me? A fully-fledged criminal or an innocent 19 year old who was wrongly accused of murder and therefore hung? I believe the guards are coming in now. I can hear their footsteps. Shall I wait for them to enter? Shall I plan to retaliate as soon as they come in?

  2. Capital Punishment is no longer practised in our society. Explain what differing Christian ...

    However, many other Christians are opposed to capital punishment because they feel it is murder.

  1. Capital Punishment

    imposing the least severe of two possible punishments when everything else is equal. Italian political theorist Cesare Beccaria (1738-1794) argues this point in On Crimes and Punishment (1764), one of the first systematic critiques of capital punishment from the utilitarian point of view.

  2. Capital punishment is no longer practised in our society. Explain what differing Christian attitudes ...

    So by eliminating the person who has committed evil, you are fulfilling the Prayer. In Genesis it tells us that God created us in his own image, Christians believe that God values human lives greatly. So in situations as in murder, criminals should be punished, and made sure that they can't commit such a crime again.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work