• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using information from the items and elsewhere, assess the usefulness of 'individualistic' theories of the causes of poverty.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Using information from the Items and elsewhere, assess the usefulness of 'individualistic' theories of the causes of poverty. An individualistic (cultural) perspective suggests that poverty comes as a result of behaviour and lifestyle more likely to result in poverty. This perspective is often referred to as 'victim-blaming'. They are said to be 'work shy', preferring instead to live on state welfare benefits. This explanation of poverty argues that the poor' subculture may be so pervasive that these deviant attitudes are reproduced from one generation to another by parents who act as 'deviant role-models' to their children. In this way the poor are said to be a part of a subculture, which is somewhat antagonistic to the mainstream culture of society. The main groups considered to be leading these impoverished subcultures are the disabled, women, ethnic groups, elderly, working class and people from northern regions. The minority of disabled have: - -An inability to work which -Limitations on physical and/or mental abilities. ...read more.

Middle

Arguments directly against Lewis's study come from the anthropologist, Mangrins (1968), who researched slums in Peru and found the poor were far from apathetic or resigned and also had remarkable organising powers. Coates and Silburn (1970) studied a slum in Nottingham called St Annes. They did find helpless poor but they argued this was a consequence (see later explanations) and not a cause. Rutter and Madge (1977) suggested there was "little documentation of my communities in this country which might correspond with the descriptions of a culture of poverty given by Lewis. Interestingly, Rutter and Madge did a separate study arguing there is a 'Cycle of deprivation'. A Situational perspective argues directly against this suggesting that poverty is due to a through no fault of their own but argue there are many social, economic and environmental factors which prevent poor from improving their position. It argues that behaviour is a reaction to this social situation but not a cause. ...read more.

Conclusion

Finally 'Dependency Culture' is a New Right idea, which is slightly similar to the individualistic theories stating poor are lazy and fatalistic but it goes further into the issue and suggests (like other theories) a reason. The reason being that people are poor because of their dependency on the state and that they are caught in a 'dependency trap' instead of just having 'foolish' behaviour. Marsland (1989) believes people are happier collecting money from benefits rather than working for similar amounts. He suggests that state provisions should be given to the needy poor instead of the idle. Murray (1990) USA and Anderson (1990) UK argue a new underclass is emerging due to welfare benefits Individualistic theories (like most of the earliest theories), is rather simple. Indeed, it may be true that some, possibly the majority of those in poverty, have apathetical behaviours, but whether it answers the causes of poverty is questionable. The problem with this theory is that it does not give reasons for these lifestyles but rather looks at the direct causes of poverty. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Charities, Poverty and Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Charities, Poverty and Development essays

  1. How far were changing attitudes towards the poor between 1834 – 1900 due to ...

    This period is marked with great state intervention, for example a compulsory Public Health Act, the 1870 Forster's Education Act, and in 1880 there was a compulsory Education Act. However, taking the Permissive 1848 Public Health act and comparing it to the 1875 Compulsory Public one can assume that there

  2. To What Extent Is the Welfare State Responsible For Creating a Culture of Dependency?

    Marginalisation According to this approach some groups of people lose out in complex industrial societies through no fault of their own. They are the casualties of industrial and social change. The victims include those such as the physically and mentally disabled, lone parents, the less skilled, older people and so on.

  1. Outline and assess sociological explanations for the increase in poverty when living standards for ...

    Not only did poor people suffer from low incomes, they were also lively to live in seriously substandard housing, they often had poor diets, their children went to a primary school which lacked modern amenities and they lived in an area which could be best described as a slum.

  2. Inequality is the main reason for the persistence of poverty - Discuss.

    The overall effect is shown whereby the wage for the landless to be able and willing to work is high. It is relatively low fro smaller landowners because they do have some non-wage income. It is high for large landowners because they have a high reservation wage.

  1. Identify four causes of the increase in poverty and vagrancy in the Tudor period.

    Legislation such as the 1495 vagrancy law and the 1547 vagrancy law was very punitive. However, from the 1560's onwards policy towards the poor and vagrants was largely more enlightened. By 1598 all the small acts of the 1590's had been codified under the act for the relief of the poor.

  2. wealth and poverty

    This would thus give the poorer countries a bigger part in world trade and would enable them to again work out of poverty themselves. Christian Teaching On Poverty As said previously, the 'rich' North has better income than the south, but how can there be 86% of the worlds profit

  1. CRITICALLY EXAMINE THE CULTURAL EXPLANATIONS OF POVERTY

    For the majority of them, family is the only institution in which they directly participate (Haralambos, 2000, p. 320). In Lewis point of view, this culture is a way of life which is passed on from generation to generation, perpetuating poverty.

  2. Singer's Practical Ethics: Poverty

    Therefore, to fix world poverty, the excess possessions of the rich ought to be distributed throughout the poor. He says that the rich have a moral obligation to assist others who are unable to survive on their own before improving their own lives of luxury.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work