• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What are the strengths of the design argument? Comment on some of the criticisms raised against this argument

Extracts from this document...


The Design Argument What are the strengths of the design argument? Comment on some of the criticisms raised against this argument. The design argument has been argued by many philosophers over hundreds of years. The design argument suggests that the world displays elements of design, with things being adapted towards some overall end or purpose and such design suggests that the world is the work of a designer - God. Two of the main philosophers to argue this point were Aquinas and Paley but many others since have tried to back these up with there own approaches for example Swinburne with the argument from probability. With all arguments there have been criticisms raised against it with Hume being the main one but others include the Epicurean Hypothesis, Darwin and Dawkins. The main strengths are that it is a solid argument, based on experience that people can relate to, there being a huge chance that things were designed is a probable outcome, its logical, it makes sense and it is believable. ...read more.


But then people have argued that suffering is there for a reason and its part of 'the test'. Next he argued that God is too different to us and transcends human understanding and by using the design argument you lesson God as we are finite and God in infinite. This was a fair point as it's hard for a finite being to grasp infinity, but we are rational beings and should try to grasp ungraspable. Lastly he says that it is not a good analogy as the universe is more like an animal or vegetable than a machine, because it grows of its own accord. A cabbage may be a better analogy, but machines grow too and plants themselves are like machines. The Epicurean Hypothesis is another criticism of the design argument. The first premise of this syllogism states that at the time of creation, the universe was made up of particles in random motion. This was a state of chaos. ...read more.


He argued that natural selection gives the appearance of design, which leads to a mistaken belief in a designer. He wrote a book called 'The Blind Watchmaker' which argued that variations in the world are caused by random mistakes in DNA. He also produced a computer model which showed how intelligent life could evolve naturally. The problem with his argument is that someone had to write the programme and set the parameters which suggest a designer and experience shows that we can breed features into species by selecting the ones with the desired characteristics and then breeding them over a few generations. It has also been argued that we choose our mate on a genetic basis, which could mean programming. I conclude that the design argument does not prove the God of Classical Theism but then again the criticisms do not disprove it. If both sides of the argument are examined then it is really down to the person whether they believe that the universe was created by a designer and that designer being God as there are strong points made for and against the argument and neither can be logically false. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Outline the Design Argument for the Existence of God

    Again, this challenges the design argument to a huge extent, as it poses a question to followers of the teleological which they cannot possibly answer. His final main point is purely explaining that the world cannot be compared to anything else of a similar form, so to say that it

  2. David Hume is the main opponent of the design argument. Provide a summary of ...

    What are the differences between the argument to design and the argument from design? The argument from design is formally given in these three ways: * Objects in nature are analogous to non-made machines. * Man-made machines are the result of intelligent design. * Analogous effects will have analogous causes.

  1. Free essay

    Comment on The Design Argument

    Paley refers to the rotation of the planets in the solar system. They all orbit the sun in the same way and are held in this orbit by gravity. If gravity were too much than the planets would be brought towards the sun and if gravity were too little, than

  2. What are the key features of the design argument for the existence of God? ...

    Brown argues that this could not be due to an evolutionary process but of a plan made by a creator. It is interesting that Brown refers to an evolutionary process; Brown wrote this argument in 1943, which came after the theory of evolution4.

  1. Discuss two criticisms of the argument from religious experience. To what extent is the ...

    Whilst Marx did identify there has been a somewhat avaricious relationship between Church and State, his rejection does not undermine personal experiences of God merely the principle of testimony. Another objection is that with different religions claiming that these occurrences prove their interpretation of the supernatural, only one at the most is ultimately correct.

  2. 'Darwin's theory of Evolution undermined the Argument from Design'. Is this true?

    or the other: "The watch may have been made with the aid of some blind screwdrivers (or even a blind watchmaking machine), but they were guided by a watchmaker with some very clear sight". (Is there a God?, p.63) It seems unfair for Dawkins to discount Paley as 'gloriously wrong'.

  1. Outline and Critically Evaluate the design Argument

    Another, more obvious place to find support of the design argument can be seen in the Bible. Genesis shows evidence of Regularity and Purpose as well as design. "Lights...to put light upon the earth...and the evening and the morning..." Although some people may not believe the teachings of the Bible,

  2. Examine the design argument for the existence of God.

    has no complexity, does not change, is not in constant motion, and seems to have no purpose; therefore, it is acceptable to presume that the stone had existed forever. The second part of the argument for the existence of God is design qua regularity - Paley used evidence from astronomy

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work