• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Aim and background knowledge: - To investigate how different concentrations of sugar solutions affect the osmosis and equilibrium happening in potatoes.

Free essay example:

Aim and background knowledge:

−        To investigate how different concentrations of sugar solutions affect the osmosis and equilibrium happening in potatoes.

Osmosis is the net movement/diffusion of water molecules from high (hypertonic) to low concentration (hypotonic) across a partially permeable membrane.

Equilibrium is when the concentrations on each side of the selectively permeable membrane are equal, and therefore, there is no net change over time and there is equal movement in both directions.

Method:

1.        First, I cut the potatoes into as similar as possible shapes using a potato chipper and a knife and measured the mass of each, picking the shapes which weighed the most similar.

2.        Next, I made the various sugar solutions. This was done by calculating the appropriate proportions in relation to the solution tables. Measuring cylinders were used to carry out this step.

3.        Then, I placed the potato shapes with certain sugar solutions into test tubes.

4.        The test tubes were left for approximately two hours so that osmosis could take place.

5.        The masses of the potato shapes were measured after drying off water residues; this data was recorded in a table.

The variable that was changed was the concentrations of sugar solutions.

Preliminary work and justifications of plan:

The first preliminary work completed was using raisins to obtain a broader understanding of osmosis and equilibrium. We measured the masses of raisins before and after osmosis took place, and chose similar weighing raisins to make sure that the results would be more valid. After osmosis happened, we measured the mass of each raisin again (after drying off water residues) and recorded this information in a table. From completing this work, I have learnt that not only the mass is important when making investigations such as these fair tests, but also the surface areas of the samples used should be taken into consideration. This is because, when the surface area is larger, the diffusion of water molecules through the plant cells increases, and so osmosis increases. However, the surface area of raisins is not directly proportional to its mass. Additionally there is not a very accurate method to measure the surface area of raisins, as their shapes are very irregular (with numerous grooves and ridges) These grooves and ridges mean that water remains in the gaps even after drying the raisins (in order to measure the masses accurately after osmosis has happened).

During the main preliminary work, I used two different vegetables (potato and carrot) and a couple of different sugar solutions. At first, I found it hard to comprehend the ideas behind osmosis and equilibrium, and apply these to completing an investigation. But after completing the graph (included in coursework) to illustrate the results, I understood the mistakes that I had made and knew that I would be able to correct these in the actual investigation. From observing that a small range of concentrations of sugar solutions made the results not very useful, weak and inconclusive,  I realised that by increasing this, I would be able to conclude a more valid and coherent conclusion. Furthermore, I learnt that by using sugar to make a solution was more plausible than salt as one would obtain a greater range of results and osmosis effects would become more noticeable and measurable.

During the actual investigation, the variable changed was the concentration of sugar solution. The range used was from 0 mol/dm3 – 0.8 mol/dm3 of sugar solution. As sugar was chosen in contrast to salt, these concentrations deemed more plausible as higher concentrations would not dissolve all the sugar completely in the water.

The equipment chosen had an effect on the results by making them more valid. For example, a potato chipper machine was used as it is more accurate and easier than other methods. After using this, a knife was used to neaten up the potato shapes as (from the preliminary work), we learnt that the surface areas needed to be as similar as possible because this would make diffusion at a similar level for each potato shape. To add, the weighing scales which were used measured objects to two decimal places. Therefore, the measurements would be more accurate and so the conclusion made would be more precise also.

Control variables:

Various variables had to be controlled to ensure that the investigation was a fair test. Examples of these were:

−        Temperature: During the time when osmosis was taking place, the test tubes were kept in the same place, which made sure that the temperature was the most stable possible in the circumstances. Temperature can affect the results because by increasing the temperature, the particles will have more kinetic energy and so they will cover more surface area of the membrane in a given time. Therefore, the probability that the water molecules enter a gap in the membrane increases. And in turn, this means that equilibrium will be reached faster.

−        The surface areas of the potato shapes: This was needed to be controlled because when the surface area of a potato shape is larger, more and faster diffusion will take place as there is more space for it to do so. In turn, the rate of osmosis increases. To control this variable, I used a potato chipper machine to first cut the shapes equally, but after I also used a knife to neaten the edges, this would ensure a similar enough surface area of each potato shape.

−         Type of potato: Different potatoes contain different amounts of water. This means that their weight could go up or down (with the same concentration of external sugar solution) depending on the different type of potato. The same type of potato, from the same packet of potatoes was used to guarantee that this variable would be controlled.

−        Furthermore, it was important to completely submerge each potato shape in the water as otherwise some shapes would receive more contact with the external solution than others. If this happened, osmosis would occur more in certain test tubes.

−        Additionally, the volumes of the external solutions were measured accurately using a measuring cylinder in order to be equal enough in each test tube.

−        Each potato shape was placed into their individual test tube as close as possible to the same moment. Similarly, they were removed from the external solutions at the same time. By some potato shapes remaining in their external solutions longer than others, more osmosis would happen (meaning possibly larger mass changes) and equilibrium will be reached faster in certain test tubes.

 In some cases, it can be difficult to be precise in controlling variables. As an example, it is virtually impossible for two potato shapes to have exactly the same mass or surface area. Also, external heat sources could have been used nearby, this could have altered the results as temperature has an effect on osmosis. Similarly, it would not have been possible to precisely ensure that the test tubes were not exposed to domestic devices such as fans or other external heat sources other than natural and artificial light. This is because, as the investigation was completed in school, the investigators wouldn’t have remained there constantly to monitor the external temperature.

Therefore, the independent variable that I changed was the concentration of the sugar solution, and the dependent variable was the mass of the potato shape.

Recording of data:

Concentration of external sugar solution

0 mol/dm3

0.2  mol/dm3

0.4  mol/dm3

0.6  mol/dm3

0.8  mol/dm3

1st Sample

Mass Before (g)

3.86

3.56

3.69

3.79

3.72

Mass After (g)

4.53

3.71

3.48

3.19

3.00

Change in mass (g)

0.67

0.15

-0.21

-0.60

-0.72

Percentage change in mass (%)

17.36

4.21

-5.69

-15.83

-19.35

2nd Sample

Mass Before (g)

3.62

3.90

4.01

3.92

3.49

Mass After (g)

4.32

4.11

3.74

3.34

2.84

Change in mass (g)

0.70

0.21

-0.27

-0.58

-0.65

Percentage change in mass (%)

19.34

5.38

-6.73

-14.80

-18.62

3rd Sample

Mass Before (g)

3.67

4.15

3.82

3.78

3.80

Mass After (g)

4.26

4.34

3.66

3.16

3.22

Change in mass (g)

0.59

0.19

-0.16

-0.62

-0.58

Percentage change in mass (%)

16.08

4.58

-4.19

-16.40

-15.26

Explain the conclusion using biological knowledge and ideas:

When the potato chip is placed into the test tube, osmosis starts to take place. As osmosis is, in simple terms, the net movement of water molecules from high concentration to low concentration, in this case water molecules will move from the external sugar solution through the selectively permeable membranes into the potato cells, so the potato cells become turgid.

Whereas, when there is a higher concentration of water molecules in the potato shape than the external sugar solution itself, osmosis will take place in the opposite direction (as water molecules move from high to low concentration), and in turn the potato cells become flaccid.

When a concentration of less than 0.3 mol/dm3 was used. Here, the osmosis occurred from the external sugar solution to the potato shape, because the external sugar solution had the higher concentration in this case (it was hypertonic). Therefore, when the concentration of the sugar solution was less than 0.3 mol/dm3, the potato gained mass to become turgid (deplasmolysis) and so the mass change percentages here were all positive. This also happens vice versa (. When the concentration of the external sugar solution is higher than 0.3 mol/dm3, the overall mass change in percentage is negative. This is because the potato shapes’ water concentration would clearly be higher than the water concentration in the sugar solution (hypotonic), and so the water molecules would move from high to low concentration and in turn the potato shapes would lose mass (plasmolysis). This was all true to this particular investigation. However, it could be different in others because of factors such as a different variety of potatoes, which contain different water concentrations to this example.

−        We could have used a larger array of vegetables to experiment with. Then produce graphs from the data and compare these with each other.

−        If similar methods were carried out (validly), and they all supported the same conclusion. This should increase one’s confidence in the conclusion. This is because, as with anything, when more data confirms a theory or hypothesis, it becomes more likely to be valid.

Reliability of evidence:

The final data which I collected I am fairly confident about. One can conclude a viable conclusion from the data. Although, some of the range bars could be considered quite wide and therefore too vague and inaccurate. There was only one outlier, and so by this I can say that the data overall wasn’t too inaccurate. I dealt with this outlier by highlighting this in the data table and excluding it from the averages and graph. The first range bar (0 mol/dm3 of sugar) is the largest of all in the graph. It ranges from 16.1 to 19.3% mass change (a 3.2% difference). The second range bar (from the concentration of the external sugar solution of 0.2 mol/dm3) is significantly shorter (ranging from 4.2 to 5.4% mass change – a 1.2% difference). The third ranges from -4.2 to -6.7% (a 2.5% difference).  The range of the concentration 0.6 mol/dm3 was from -14.8 to -16.4% (a 1.6% difference). Finally, the shortest range bar was the last for 0.8 mol/dm3 whichranged from -18.6 to -19.4% (a 0.8% difference). I suspect that the narrowness of this range bar was due to an anomaly being removed. Otherwise, the range would have been from -15.3 to -19.4% (a 4.1% difference).

Most of the data lies very close to the line of best fit, only the last average did not continue the previous line. The reason for this is because of plasmolysis:

As the cell membrane is selectively permeable, osmosis will occur between the plant cell and the external solution. (As explained previously), when the external solution has a lower concentration than the cell, osmosis happens in the direction of the cell – external solution, so that the cell loses mass to become flaccid, if the cell keeps losing more mass then the cell will also become plasmolyzed (shrunken). Soon, the cell (including vacuole) will no longer have any water molecules left to diffuse out from the cell. In turn, this explains how the  gradient of mass change changes substantially (as the mass change difference will be less than previously.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Life Processes & Cells section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related GCSE Science Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related GCSE Life Processes & Cells essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    An experiment to investigate how the effect of varying concentrations of salt solutions play ...

    4 star(s)

    mass reading before being placed in the solution in the McCarthy bottle, thus with this information compiled together, I will be able to analyse what has really happened with the help of what I have learnt before on the topic of osmosis.

  2. Investigate Osmosis in potato cell using different concentrations of sugar solutions.

    In the beaker with pure water I think the potato strip will become turgid. This is because in pure water there is a high concentration of water molecules. So when a potato strip is placed in the beaker the molecules will try to evenly distribute on either side of the

  1. Osmosis Experiment Aim: To investigate the factors which affect osmosis in potatoes and ...

    * The type of the potato may have an effect on the rate of osmosis. * Concentration of the solution - the greater the difference in concentration between the sugar solution inside the cell and the solution outside the cell the greater the net movement of water molecules.

  2. Osmosis is defined as 'the movement of water molecules from an area of high ...

    This will be done by adding varying amounts of distilled water to varying amounts of sucrose solution. Sections of potato will be cut using a scalpel and will be measured using a ruler. This part of the preparation must be done very accurately as a change in the surface area may allow more or less osmosis to occur.

  1. Osmosis, Aim: Investigate the movement of osmosis through a selectively permeable membrane, in ...

    The reason for the minus results for 1 molar concentration is that the solution has a lower concentration of water to that of the potato, and so, by osmosis water moves from the potato to the solution, causing the weight to decrease. Graph 2 shows the average change in length.

  2. The aim of this experiment is to work out if potatoes lose or gain ...

    Final length of chip (cm) Change in the length of chip (- or + cm) A Distilled water 4 4.5 0.5 B Weak sugar solution 4 4 0.0 C Strong sugar solution 4 3.8 -0.2 I discovered that the potato in distilled water had increased in mass and the one in sucrose had decreased in mass.

  1. In this coursework I am going to investigate the factor how different concentrations of ...

    As a result of this, water molecules will osmose out of the chip and into the solution i.e. the potato chip will lose mass and decrease in length. The potato tissues, being surrounded by a weak solution, will be most likely to swell up and become turgid, taking in all the water it possibly can.

  2. Osmosis, My aim for this experiment is to see the results of potato tissue's ...

    2: Use the same potato. This is because many factors due to the potato may affect the experiment. For example the age and sizes might be different, which means one potato might have more water in them then another. 3: Stop the evaporation of any of the molar solution.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work