• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Effect of Temperature on Beetroot Membrane Proteins

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Effect of Temperature on Beetroot Membrane Proteins Planning A - Independent Variable The independent variable in this experiment will be the temperature. I will control this factor using thermostatically controlled water baths, and a thermometer. The temperatures at which the beetroot cubes will be tested will be 0� (ice), 20�C (room temperature), 40�C, 60�C and 80�C. B - Dependent Variable The dependant variable is the result - this experiment will initially yield qualitative results. This is not desirable as it is only approximate and as it is not viable to use it to plot graphs of the results. Therefore, the results will be converted from qualitative to quantitative using a colorimeter, which will measure the percentage light transmission through the different temperatures after the beetroot has been left in the boiling tubes for 5 minutes. A blue filter will be used to measure the redness of the solutions, as it is a complimentary colour. The experiment will be repeated 3 times. This will make it possible to clearly identify errors or anomalous results by comparison, and to understand whether or not a mistake was made when carrying out the experiment. From the results of the original and repeat experiments, an average can be calculated for the percentage transmission of each temperature, giving more accurate results overall and providing values with which a graph can be plotted. ...read more.

Middle

This trend may be a result of damage to the cell membranes of the beetroot. Denaturation of the carrier proteins within the phospholipid bi-layer would be a result of high temperatures and would allow substances (red pigment) to leak from inside the cell. Damage could also have been done to the phospholipids due to high temperatures, allowing pigment to escape into the water. This is not as likely as it would be had the beetroot been heated in ethanol, in which phospholipids are soluble. At lower temperatures (3.5�C - 40�C), less damage is done to components of the fluid-mosaic model. This is shown by smaller amounts of pigment having entered the water, allowing more transmission of light through the solution. At 40�C to 60�C however, the graph shows a larger decrease in percentage transmission. There is more pigment in the water at these temperatures. This could be because a temperature higher than the optimum has denatured some of the proteins in the cell membranes of the beetroot. Over temperatures 60�C - 80�C the graph shows more of a decrease in percentage transmission. This indicates that most of the proteins in the cell membrane were destroyed at these temperatures, causing the most pigment to leak out. The graph implies that as the temperature rises, more pigment can leak out of the beetroot cell, and the lower the percentage transmission will be. ...read more.

Conclusion

Samples were taken from different parts of the beetroot, due to the assumption that the beetroot was the same the whole way through. It is possible that there was more red pigment in a certain part, or that cells in one part were damaged more easily by high temperatures than those in another. The outer cells may be more resilient in order to prevent damage to the main part of the beetroot. The boiling tubes were stirred using a stirring rod when they were removed from the water baths, but there could still have been some more concentrated red pigment left at the bottom of some the tubes when the solution was being poured into the cuvettes. The boiling tubes at lower temperatures also had more time than the higher as they were put in first. The time taken to remove lids of water baths, place boiling tubes into the test tube racks and replace the lids again was approximately 20 seconds, and timing was started once the last boiling tube was in place. The extra 20 seconds may have altered the results for the Ice (3.5�C) and Room (19�C) temperature results.The water levels in the water baths varied - meaning that some of the water in the test tubes may not have been fully submerged. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Green Plants as Organisms section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Response to the question

This piece of coursework answers the question well, analysing data collected to back up their conclusion. Scientific terms are used well to describe why the correlation occurs, but in my opinion it would've been better written a different way round. ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This piece of coursework answers the question well, analysing data collected to back up their conclusion. Scientific terms are used well to describe why the correlation occurs, but in my opinion it would've been better written a different way round. I tend to start with a hypothesis and explain the scientific concepts which led to this reasoning, then address how close the results were in the conclusion. I liked the strength of evaluation in this essay, and an improvement could be to suppose solutions to the limitations and then repeating the experiment again.

Level of analysis

The analysis in this piece is sound. The data is displayed clearly in a table, and some numerical calculations have been done to find the average of the repeats. I would note that when putting data in tables, you can be penalised if there are inconsistencies with the number of decimal places. Similarly, it doesn't make much sense to have the average being more precise than the results themselves. Further analysis could be done with the data, and I think a key skill which needs to be shown at GCSE is graph drawing. Being able to draw a graph with correct axes and then form a line of best fit (which people commonly think must be a line, but it can be a curve) will enable a piece of coursework to reach the top marks.

A key concept when looking at temperature is the amount of kinetic energy. I liked how this essay mention how as temperature increases, the kinetic energy increases and thus the vibrations become more vigorous. They speak about the fluid-mosaic model and denaturation strongly. I also liked their discussion of qualitative data not being useful, so posing a way of getting quantitative data from their experiment by using a colorimeter. Understanding terms such as these shows an able candidate!

Quality of writing

This experiment is written up very well. Technical terms are used when necessary, and grammar is used to emphasise the arguments.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by groat 07/02/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Green Plants as Organisms essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How does temperature affect the permeability of a cell membrane in a beetroot.

    4 star(s)

    When using a bunsen burner I must be careful not to burn myself on the flame and leave it on the safety flame or off when not using it. I must push the cork borer into the beetroot away from the body, holding the beetroot at an angle where the cork borer will not touch.

  2. Determine the water potential of potato tuber cell with the varying affect of solute ...

    Between this, the potatoes must be dried just enough, and then put on the balance. When doing this for one set of cylinders, writing down the results at the same time, while the other five sets are on the tissue paper, the water outside the potato tissue is going to vary.

  1. What is the effect on the rate of respiration of yeast cells with glucose ...

    Processing the evidence Calculating the mean volume of carbon dioxide collected in a set amount of time increases accuracy and reliability of the results, as the experiment is being replicated in the process. Nevertheless, one cannot ever place complete confidence in the accuracy of results achieved in this way as calculating the mean involves using even anomalous results.

  2. How Temperature Effects the Movement of Pigment Through Cell Membranes

    As a result of diffusion, molecules tend to reach an equilibrium situation where they are evenly spread within a given volume of space."3 By heating the molecules they gain more kinetic energy than they would at low temperatures this means they move around faster and thus diffusion takes place quicker.

  1. Investigating the effect of temperature on the rate of photosynthesis

    This means that light from lamps other than ours could have affected our experiment, as it means the chlorophyll received a higher intensity than was intended, therefore increasing the rate of photosynthesis. The light intensity meters were not digital, therefore did not give a definite reading.

  2. Investigation into the diffusion of pigment from the cell membrane of Beetroot.

    I will ensure my data is accurate by making sure that I make accurate cuts with the scalpel and follow how to control the factors in the table. Also things such as sing a thermometer to make sure all water starts at right temperature.

  1. How temperature affects the rate of photosynthesis.

    Therefore as an increased supply of ADP and Pi is available, the light stage uses them to from ATP at an equally higher rate, thereby increasing the rates of reactions like the photolysis of water (so more oxygen is released which is recorded as an increase in the average rate

  2. Investigating the abiotic factors that affect the size of Ivy leaves in shaded and ...

    The molecules of water in this column stick to one another. As the molecules at the top of the column are lost through transpiration, the entire column of water is pulled upward. This pulling force is strong enough to draw water to the tops of the tallest trees.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work