Investigate various ways of increasing the rate of a chemical reaction and evaluate which has the greatest effect.

Authors Avatar

Chemistry Investigation          by Yasir Al-Wakeel

Aim:

    Our aim is to investigate various ways of increasing the rate of a chemical reaction and evaluate which has the greatest effect.

        Planning:

Introduction

    A chemical reaction is the process by which atoms or groups of atoms from a certain substance react with those of another resulting in a product/s which has a changed molecular composition.  A typical chemical reaction is of the form:

        A        +        B                        C        +        D

in which A and B are the reactants and C and D are the products.

    Rate is commonly described as a measure of the change that happens in a single unit of time.  The measure of rates is very important to the average person and is commonly used in everyday life.  The table below illustrates some everyday rates of change (figures provided are approximations):

Example                                        Rate

Travelling to school by car                           40 miles per hour

Travelling to school by foot                             4 miles per hour

Water coming out of upstairs tap                    70cm3 per second

Water coming out of downstairs tap                  90cm3 per second

Therefore if you were in a hurry to get to school you would be better off choosing the car if this option were available. Similarly if you were given a few minutes notice before your water was to be cut off you would be better off going downstairs to fill up containers for storage.  Faster and slower are the two main ways of describing rate.

    And thus, with regards to chemical reactions, the rate of a chemical reaction is a measure of how fast or how slow it takes place.  The unit for the rate of reaction is s-1  i.e. the reciprocal of time.  Some reactions can be extremely fast such as a detonation, an example of which being the oxidation of trinitrotoluene- commonly known as TNT.  On the other hand some reactions may take a very long time such as the common process of rusting.  The study of the rates of chemical reactions and their mechanisms is known as chemical kinetics.

        In industry reaction rates can be of great importance.  Many reactions need to be speeded up, such as the production of ammonia from nitrogen and hydrogen (Haber process), another example being the production of cheese from milk.  The obvious benefits of this, an attempt to obtain maximum product from the minimum amount of raw material, using minimum fuel in the minimum possible time, is to maximise efficiency.  Some reactions may also need to be slowed down as they may need to be controlled i.e. propane-1, 2, 3-triol (glycerine) is sometimes added to hydrogen peroxide as a negative-catalyst (inhibitor) in order to slow down its rate of decomposition.  Reaction kinetics is also useful for studying biological processes and to allow us to interpret them on a molecular level.  The analysis of the mechanisms of biological reactions such as photosynthesis, which was thought to be a one-stage reaction, has been made possible by advances in the field of reaction kinetics.  Reaction kinetics is also crucial for archaeological dating.

        There are various factors which may affect the rate at which reactions take place. Using the analogy of travelling to school by car, the rate can be affected by the amount of traffic, the speed limit, the driver, the car and so on.  With chemicals, there are several ways in which their reaction rates can be increased, some of these include:

  • Concentration of reactants in solution
  • Temperature of reactants
  • The presence of light
  • The presence of a catalyst
  • The surface area of the solid reactant

Yet how may one go about measuring the rate of a reaction? In the car, one may take readings of the distance that the car has covered and the time it takes to do so.  With chemical reactions one may find the rate by  measuring A) the amount of reactant used up per unit time or B) the amount of product produced per unit time.   Thus we may define reaction rate as the rate of change of amount or concentration of a particular reactant or product, as illustrated in the equation:

Reaction rate =  Change in amount (or concentration )of a substance

                                                time

Yet measuring change in reactant or product may pose some difficulty.  However, in a reaction where the product is in a different state, the time taken for a reactant to be used up or the time taken for the product to be formed may be measured relatively easily.  There are several main ways that this can be done.   However we shall limit our discussion to those methods that may be applicable to our reaction, they are as follows:

1) By observing a gaseous product.

This itself can be done in several main ways:          

The first method being to measure the volume of gas produced in a certain time.  The following reaction may be taken as an example:

        Reactive metal + acid                          Salt solution + Hydrogen gas        

The volume of hydrogen evolved may be worked out using the stoichiometric equation, and thus one would know when the reaction reached completion.  The apparatus needed for this is illustrated below:

The second method, provided that the gas is able to leave the container, can be done by observing a decrease of weight of the reactants as gas is lost.  This method would not be very suitable for the last reaction as it works best with reactions producing heavy gases, thus making the recording of the results easier(Hydrogen has a comparatively low relative atomic mass).  A reaction such as the type illustrated below may be suitable:

Metal carbonate + Acid                       Salt solution + Carbon dioxide

The apparatus required may be set up as follows:

2)By observing the reactants dissolve.

This can simply be done by measuring the time taken for  the solid reactant to dissolve in the solvent, an example of this being marble chips or calcium carbonate ‘dissolving’ in an acid.

One other useful method is conductmetric analysis .  Conductmetric analysis relies on the fact that reactions in solution involve changes in ions present.  As a result of this the electrical conductivity of the solution will thus change during the reaction and this may be monitored as shown:

In order to measure the rate of reaction we must therefore consider a specific reaction and evaluate which of the methods above would be of most use.

Reagents:

The reactants we shall use are as follows:

15cm3 of   .5mol/dm3,1mol/dm3, 2mol/dm3 and 5 mol/dm3 of Hydrochloric acid.

Distilled water (to make up different concentrations if necessary)

0.25grams of calcium carbonate / marble

Stoichiometric Equation:

CaCO3 (s)   +  2HCl (aq)                         CaCl2 (aq)    +    CO2 (g)    + H2O (l)

This reaction is known as a heterogeneous reaction, in which the two reactants are in different states.

Evaluation of the method to be used:

        We must now consider which method will be most suitable for determining the rate of the above reaction.  Since carbon dioxide gas is produced we may use the method of measuring the amount of carbon dioxide produced, which may be calculated, however, setting up the equipment may be inconvenient.  Recording the change in mass would be appropriate as carbon dioxide is quite a heavy gas.  However there is only one top-pan balance available for the whole class to use. Thus we are left with the method of observing a reactant dissolve.  In our experiment the calcium carbonate is dissolving in the hydrochloric acid, and so this would be suitable.  It is likely that there will be a change in electrical conductivity, however the equipment needed for conductmetric analysis is not available in our laboratory.  Therefore we are left with the somewhat less accurate but appropriate method of observing the calcium carbonate dissolve.  The reaction shall be timed by a stop-clock, accurate to one tenth of a second, which shall be started when the reactants are added to each other and stopped when the calcium carbonate has fully dissolved and all signs of reaction, such as effervescence due to the formation of carbon dioxide, have ceased.

Factors that shall be tested:

    Bearing in mind that we have limited time and shall be conducting our experiments in a laboratory, measuring things such as the effect of pressure or catalysis on the rate of reaction may be impractical.  We shall therefore limit our investigation to the effect of three things; concentration of hydrochloric acid, temperature and surface area of calcium carbonate.

        Variables:

   There are three main types of variable; Independent (input), control and dependent variables.

    An independent variable, or otherwise known as an input variable, is the variable that is to be tested by experiment and therefore deliberately changed.  The control variable is the variable that is kept constant in order to test the independent variable fairly.  The dependent variable is the one that depends on the control and independent variables.  Since the control is to be kept constant, any effect on the dependentvariable will therefore be due to the independent variable.

     Throughout our investigation the variables shall be:

Control variable:        Volume of Hydrochloric acid (15cm3) and mass of marble ( 0.25 grams - any more and the reaction would be too slow-except in surface area experiment).  Since the hydrochloric acid in all the reactions, regardless of concentration, is in excess of the calcium carbonate, the extent of reaction shall also remain relatively the same.  Thus the investigation shall be fair.

The reagents shall also remain the same.

Join now!

Independent variable: Concentration of Hydrochloric acid, temperature at which reaction takes place and surface area.-changing one at a time in order to attain reliable results.

Dependent variable: Duration of reaction, and therefore the rate of reaction.

        The complexity of our variables are as follows:

Temperature shall be a continuous variable as we shall begin with 220c (room temperature).  Concentration shall also be a continuous variable as we shall begin with ½ mol/litre solution.  The affect of surface area shall. also be continuous as we shall be calculating the surface area of our reactants rather than only using the categoric variables of ...

This is a preview of the whole essay