Thistles by Ted Hughes. Question: Critically analyse the poem

Authors Avatar

Thistles by Ted Hughes

Question: Critically analyse the poem, paying attention to diction & imagery, showing how they are effective in describing thistles.

P  :  Thistles are described as if they were nature’s avengers.

Q  :  Thistles ‘spike’ ‘Against the rubber tongues of cows and the hoeing hands of man        & ‘…a revengeful burs of resurrection’        

R  :  Thistles inflict pain towards ‘the hoeing hands of men’ which gives readers the spa   image of men destroying the plants in the soil with a hoe, perhaps for the unnecessary

         need for urbanization and other recreational purposes. It seems that the thistles

         are punishing man  for destroying nature. Even though the ‘cows’ mentioned

somewhat destroy plants, or to be specific, grass for it is their staple food, they

         seem to not be a part of the ones punished for their rubber tongues’ gives the

         image of a lifeless tongue where it does not feel pain, having the qualities of

    rubber- lifeless and feeling nothing. Hence, the thistles are described as avengers

         for those who abuse and destroy nature for unnecessary wants. It seems as if

avenging is the purpose of the thistles’ existence and for their resurrection- the

phrase ‘a revengeful burst of resurrection seems to give the image of revenge,

     powering the process of resurrecting the thistles. Hence, the suggested reason for

   their existence and their behavior in punishing men describes them as if they are

         nature’s “avengers”.

P  :  Despite being described as “nature’s avengers”, they seem to have an evil side that is          abeing brought alive by what could be perceived as the evil present in the world as

        represented by – “underground stain of a Viking”.

Q  :  “From the underground stain of a decayed Viking”, “ the gutturals of dialects“ &                                                                                                                                space every one manages a plume of blood”.

Join now!

R  :  Readers get the impression that thistles are being brought to life ‘From the     spaceunderground stain of a decayed Viking’. Now, a Viking is a monstrous, wild and spaceevil legendary barbarian and the fact that its remnants are absorbed in the growth of spacethistles could suggest that evil is being transferred to them as seen from their evil spaceacts or purpose in trying to hurt innocent animals (‘cows’), men and even plague the space‘summer air’. Also, it seems as though the spirits of the dead Vikings are spacewhispering to the growing thistles with ‘the gutturals of dialects’ ...

This is a preview of the whole essay