Forces Acting on the Marble:-
There are two forces acting on the marble as it falls. Its weight, and Air resistance. Its weight is caused by gravity which also causes it to accelerate as it falls. Air resistance is caused my the air molecules it is pushing out of the way as it falls.
Diagram 1:-
This Diagram shows the forces which will be acting on the ball as it falls.
Acceleration
Small Gap means
the marble is not
traveling very fast
after 1 second
At the last gap the distance is wide, so the ball has accelerated and is traveling faster now.
Diagram 2:- This Diagram shows how the marble speeds up as it falls towards the ground. The Balls are shown at 1 second intervals. The higher you drop the ball from, the faster it is falling when it hits the sand.
Equipment List:-
- Clamp & Stand
- Meter Ruler
- Tray of Sand
- Marble
- Ruler to Measure Crater
Method:-
- Set up Equipment according to diagram
- Make Sure Sand is level
- Measure the Height and drop the marble in the centre of the tray
- Measure Distance across the crater with a ruler and record in table to the nearest mm
Diagram:-
Pre-Test:- I am going to do a pre-test to check that there are no flaws in my method, and that I can measure and record the results accurately.
Results of Pre-test:- From my pre-test I can see that:
- It is hard and not practical to drop the marble from a height of under 10cm.
- It is easier to have the equipment on the floor as when you get to higher heights; it is hard to drop the marble into the centre of the tray if you cannot see where you are dropping it from.
- Instead if measuring the crater directly from the sand, it is easier to put paper clips in the ridges and measure across; because if you try to measure directly across with a ruler, you have to remove the marble, which disturbs the sand.
Equipment List for Experiment:-
- Clamp & Stand
- Meter Ruler
- Tray of Sand
- Marble
- Two straightened out paper clips
- 15cm Ruler
Method for Experiment:-
- Set up Equipment according to diagram on the floor
- Make Sure Sand is level
- Measure the Height and drop the marble in the centre of the tray
- Insert paper clips into the top ridge of the sand
- Measure Distance across from paper clip to paper clip with a ruler and record in table to the nearest mm
With the above method I am now going to carry out my experiment. I am going to drop the marble at 10cm intervals starting at 10cm, going up to 100cm.
Results:-
Originally I dropped the marble at 10cm intervals up to a meter but when I looked at my results I could see big gaps between some of the intervals so for these intervals I re-tested it in between the two values.
I carried out each height test three times to check my results were accurate and from the whole test, I only had 2 anomalies which are marked in red in the table. These are for:
- The last test for 20cm
- The first test for 80cm
For both of these results however the other two from that height are constant and so I will not need to retest them.
I will now draw a graph to show my results using the average value from each height.
Averages:-
- 10cm = 30.3mm
- 15cm = 36.6 mm
- 20cm = 38.5mm
- 25cm = 40mm
- 30cm = 40.3mm
- 35cm = 43mm
- 40cm = 42.7mm
- 50cm = 46.3mm
- 60cm = 47mm
- 70cm = 47.3mm
- 80cm = 47.5mm
- 90cm = 48.3mm
- 100cm = 51mm
From these averages I can now draw a graph with a line of best fit.
Analysis of Graph:-
From my graph I can see that as the height gets higher, the width of the crater gets wider. I can also see that as the height gets higher the gradient of the graph gets lower, so the point have not got as bigger difference in them as the lower points have. This means that the ball does not accelerate much more after 50cm. This is because the air resistance balances out more the further it has to fall after a certain point. So eventually the marble will reach its terminal velocity.
Conclusion:-
My prediction was correct, but the marbles impact von the sand started to level out sooner than I had expected, I expected to see big changes in the width of the crater up to about 100cm, but the biggest changes happened in between 10cm and 50cm.
If I did the experiment again there are a few things I would change as to how the experiment was set up:-
- Firstly I would have a larger tray to fill with sand, as it was sometimes hard to get the marble into the centre of the sand. This would be easier as well if I was to go on and drop the marble from much higher heights such as 4 or 5 meters.
- I would drop the marble from higher heights to see if I could find out the terminal velocity of the marble.
From the experiment I can see that the higher you drop the marble from the more energy it gains so the bigger impact it has on the sand.