• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

An Investigation into Carmody's 'Obernewtyn', and its Defiance of the Values of Modern Social Institutions.

Extracts from this document...


An Investigation into Carmody's 'Obernewtyn', and its Defiance of the Values of Modern Social Insti tutions. Name: Suzanne Poulgrain Teacher: Ms. Wall Class: 12D Word Count: 1547 INTRODUCTION: Isobelle Carmody's "Obernewtyn," promotes ideologies starkly contradictory to those promoted by modern social institutions. Set in the future, the book implies that the values of present society will lead to the eventual destruction of the human race. As well as this, there are general anti-Christian and anti-authoritarian messages embedded in the text; a promotion of complete child independence and adult corruption, and the portrayal of social seclusion as an admirable quality. The book has been a success worldwide selling more than 150,000 copies and winning six awards. (Australian Council, 2004) Children have cherished this book since it was first published; yet the values promoted undermine those of modern social organizations. REWARDS and PUNISHMENTS The rewards and punishments within the text demonstrate the unconventional values the text promotes. During the climax of the story when Elspeth is afraid Rushton may die, she is "filled with rage," as a result of this intense hatred "something inside [her] head cracked violently." (237) The solution to the climax's problem lies in Elspeth embracing her hatred. ...read more.


The characters and setting of Carmody's "Obernewtyn" enhance hatred of adult society and endorse emotional isolation, the fantasy genre shields this content from literal interpretation. ANTI-CHRISTIAN IDEOLOGY: This text promotes a heavy anti-Christian ideology by portraying the church as a corrupt organisation and ridiculing their aspirations. Modern children relish "Obernewtyn",' despite, or because of, its obvious anti-Christian and anti-authoritarian ideology. Post Holocaust society's religious body is known as 'the Herder Faction' and closely resembles the modern Christian church. The Herder Faction perform all ceremonial rites, recite prayers and believe themselves to be in direct connection with God, like Christian priests. Both groups believe in God, but where the beforetimers named this figure 'the Lord,' post holocaust society name him 'the Lud.' (50) Having established that the 'Herder Faction' is in fact Christianity veiled by a thin veneer of language, its ridiculed and evil portrayal seems sacrilegious. Priests of the Faction are described as 'corrupt and evil' (47) and are seen sacrificing their religion for personal advantage. It is a Herder that ignores blasphemous remarks because, "he has been warned that the youth is necessary." (5) The entire organization is described as "a fanatical order," (back cover) happy to burn any one appearing abnormal. ...read more.


This can be interpreted as a message suggesting anyone in power should not be trusted and those without deserve power as well as a person's actions are the result of what they are, rather than the reverse. This book oversimplifies the relationship between power and goodness and on this basis promotes anti-authoritarian attitudes. CONCLUSION: "Obernewtyn" promotes ideologies that challenge many current social practices. Messages of hatred, violence and subjective categorisation of people can be perceived through the rewards and punishments in the story. These ideologies oppose those of the church and government so defy the norm. The text endorses hatred of adult society and emotional isolation through the character's defining qualities of vulnerability and disobedience. By allying the good with the socially unacceptable, the text naturalises disobedience and ridicules power structures. Carmody's book blatantly criticises the Christian Church and portrays it as a blood thirsty, power-hungry institution whose sole motivation is power. This depiction undermines the power of the modern Christian church by showing an alternate negative reading of their role in society. The combination of the hero's hatred and the Council's evil actions, firmly establishes an antiauthoritarian ideology within the text. This undermines present social obedience and can be seen as an attack on the present social structure, and indeed all power holding institutions. The controversial ideologies establish Carmody's "Obernewtyn" to be an immense challenge to present social practices by undermining the values they promote. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Sociology Investigation

    He had found out that pupils in the top bands were from higher social classes. Teacher had higher expectations of them and they were taught in different ways. Keddie fount out that teachers allowed pupils in the top steams access to higher levels of knowledge.

  2. Sociology Content and Analisis

    look after herself again and began to enjoy life and was more happy. This proves to me how divorce can affect people positively as well as negatively, depending on the situation and the person. Sam didn't have much to say in this part of the interview, he said that the

  1. Aborigines in Australia.

    aid to only the "full-bloods" and "half-castes" hence all non-full bloods below 34 year old were expelled and left to fend for themselves in mainstream society while those that can afford 20 pounds re-admission fee were allowed to return, which was most unlikely (Tatz 24).

  2. The Representation of Young Offenders institutions is always negative in order to support the ...

    young offenders institution had been represented could not be justified as 'legitimate' social comment. This was because the BBC believed the representation of the institution should have been slightly more reformed and should show that in-mates respect the legitimate authority rather than revolt from it.

  1. Hypothesis: Children are born to succeed or fail

    ideas about correct form of behaviour, which stress on how we ought to behave in general terms. I also believe these factors as having a role in bringing about the success or failure of an individual. This assignment will indulge in focusing on how and why these factors affect an individuals life chances.

  2. Civil Disobedience

    Many gave us cautious looks, but none stopped to watch or talk to us until a pair of middle-aged men informed us we were 'disturbing the peace'. I kept up my act, asking why it should be considered wrong to question the law, and pointing out that we live in a 'culture of silence' already.

  1. "Are Children Born to Succeed or Fail".

    The boy who was raised by the dog only had the dog as a role model (which means he wanted to emulate the dog) and sadly enough he only had the dog as a parental like figure. However, for more "normal" situation with children thing like media, school, friends also affect a child as well.

  2. How do the two stories 'Smoke' and 'The First Party' show the conflict between ...

    This continual movement, however, doesn't build up a sense of excitement or liveliness, as in 'The First Party', but rather a feeling of forced labour. Up until now we as readers do not know that Shubha's restlessness is linked to tradition and family.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work