• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

As part of my GCSE Citizenship coursework I had to compare two newspaper articles ["Asylum meltdown" (the sun 20/01/03) with "The fight for tolerance" the (guardian 20/01/03)].

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

GCSE CITIZENSHIP COURSEWORK ASSIGNMENT: ASYLUM SEEKERS As part of my GCSE Citizenship coursework I had to compare two newspaper articles ["Asylum meltdown" (the sun 20/01/03) with "The fight for tolerance" the (guardian 20/01/03)] and discuss to an extent their point of views, their language, effectiveness, typographic techniques, and persuasiveness on the issue and then give my point of view, explaining clearly my ideas with references to evidence. The sun gives an angry report of the increasing number of asylum seekers and the immense irreversible damage this is causing our economic system shaking its very foundations. The article is completely one sided i.e. anti asylum seekers, labelling them all under one group - illegal immigrants who are causing terror and most are Muslims (Algerians, Ethiopians...) To get its point across it uses exaggerated facts and charts which will only help it get its readers angry and outraged. It used couched in vocabulary, designed to inflame anti- asylum seekers feelings. It describes asylum seekers with words or phrases such as 'illegal immigrants that swarm into Britain', 'claiming benefits at the expense of tax payers', 'taking advantage', 'using Britain as doormat ', 'asylum madness', etc. ...read more.

Middle

The guardian's "fight for tolerance" takes a different prospective on the issue. It say's that 'the panic over asylum seekers is only the first part of a war that will be waged against liberal values'. M. Bunting is saying that this problem over asylum seekers is not something that is new but has always been the case, that is, natural fear like at the time of the Nazis. The newspapers are making the situation worse (like the Sun) by exaggerating and interpreting the wrong ideas. One minute the Algerians were considered terrorist the next moment all the asylum seekers are classed as terrorist. Not just one but lots of newspapers are doing this which is causing unwarranted panic. It does not matter if an immigrant changes his name today, for he cannot escape the racial suspicions surrounding asylum seekers. Today there is a risk of interracial terrorism it does not matter which side of the political system a person stands. There are two sides to the problem, asylum seekers have the right to seek help and asylum but under the suspicion of terrorism. ...read more.

Conclusion

The poster is screaming out "What is the world coming to?" Both the sun and the guardian have a different target audience and are persuasive in their area. The sun is for the lower working class as already understood and thus it is stirring its readers just to believe what they read. The sun does not allow its readers to think for them selves and they will not think for themselves. The sun exaggerates and is unbiased. The guardian though is asking its readers to think and thus they both have a different point of view with different motives and aims. Therefore it is debateable as to which of them is more persuasive. I personally am a strong supporter of the guardian's article which argues that what we are doing is wrong. As a nation we need to consider our security and safety but we cannot class all asylum seekers as terrorists for they have rights over us and we need to understand their pain or suffering that have lead many genuine asylum seekers here, which we cannot understand sitting in a centrally heated house with all the basic luxuries and talking. Thus we need to "fight for tolerance". ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Sociology: Arranged Marriage Coursework

    Another respondent said that 'cultures were much stricter'. This could mean that culture is not seen as the main influence on marriage since it's not as strict anymore. The third aim of my coursework was to find reasons why arranged marriages might be either decreasing or increasing. I found out that most people under the age of 18 think that arranged marriage is decreasing.

  2. Free essay

    Sociology Coursework

    money they earn, so therefore those earning a little amount of money are those from the lower classes who are the poor. Life expectancy at birth: by social class and sex, 1997-99, England & Wales "Manual workers die earlier than others.

  1. Active Citizenship

    and costs. Finally, after all the details are agreed on by the group, the instructors have to make sure the route they would take out would be feasible, based on the factors of its distance, contours (up/down hill), or if the route is safe to undertake.

  2. Sociology coursework

    * This is an important issue in Britain because gender roles are different for boys, from parents, then girls as they are expected to achieve in education, due to tradition.

  1. What Is Terrorism?

    DIFFERENT KINDS OF TERRORISM IN DIFFERENT REGIONS There are different kinds of terrorism in different regions of the world i.e.

  2. My first fight.

    As my skills were not to the standard of the other children, I decided to have a peak at what the others were writing about. To my amazement, nobody actually seemed to be doing any work apart from Carl, who later spent the majority of the morning session at the toilet.

  1. Asylum Seekers

    This was partly because the labour market was less rigorously policed here than in other European countries. While there are immigration officers working at the ports and airports, he says there are just 500 working internally within the UK.

  2. Moral Panic.

    'not to be trusted' and as 'troublemakers', social isolation of the 'out-group' results, and they are categorised almost as a sub-culture. In turn those involved may gradually identify with this role, further increasing the likelihood of deviant behaviour. People generally hark back to what they perceive to be the 'good

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work