• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"As researchers are also members of society it is impossible for them to be objective and value free in planning and conducting their research." To what extent do sociological arguments and evidence support this view?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"As researchers are also members of society it is impossible for them to be objective and value free in planning and conducting their research." To what extent do sociological arguments and evidence support this view? AS defined by Robert Bierstedt 'objectivity means that the conclusions arrived at as the result of inquiry and investigation are independent of the race, colour, religion, creed, occupation, nationality, moral preference and political predisposition of the investigator. If his research is truly objective, it is independent of any subjective elements, any personal desires that he may have.' The term value free means that the research is objective, therefore unbiased. In this essay, I am going to be assessing different viewpoints and trying to establish whether or not sociological research can ever be objective and value free. The methodological approach, anti-positivists, think that sociological research can never be objective and value free. They advocate the use of qualitative (data presented in words) methods. They try to explain the world in terms of individual meanings and motives and so take a micro (small-scale) approach. They believe that sociology cannot be scientific because it is subjective (biased). Therefore, they believe that sociological research cannot be value free. Contemporary sociologists, who support the methods used by anti-positivists, say that values inevitably enter into every stage of the research process. ...read more.

Middle

and take a macro (large) approach and so study large groups of people at a time. They believe that their scientific approach is objective (unbiased). Functionalists such as Comte and Durkheim use the methodology of positivists. They argue that objectivity is obtainable using scientific methodology. However, they have been accused of holding politically conservative views for assuming that existing social institutions serve a useful purpose. Another perspective, Marxism, also believe that sociology is objective and scientific. However, Marx carried out no research and so had no empirical evidence to back up his claims. He has been criticised in that few would claim that his sociology was free from his political and moral beliefs. Weber, a Symbolic Interactionist, recognised that values would influence the choice of topics for study. Researchers would choose to research topics that had relevance to society at the time. This approach appears more value free than that of Functionalists and Marxists, but there is some doubt that his personal values influenced his research. His writings on Bureaucracy are strongly influenced by his fear that bureaucratic organisations would stifle human freedom. Most agree that it is impossible for sociology to be value free. Recently, sociological views have changed, and the questions now really is 'should Sociology be value free?' ...read more.

Conclusion

The sixth feature is allowing women to reclaim their history from its appropriation by men. The final feature is collectivising experience, here, women must join together and cooperate in their struggle for liberation. However, even if these problems are solved, the strong thesis still advocates the exact opposite of value freedom and thinks that it can never exist. Some Feminists think that you can only experience something if you've been through it yourself. Feminists criticise other researchers for imposing their own values and beliefs on to their research. This makes the research subjective (biased) therefore it cannot be value free. In summary, anti-positivists such as Weber and Interpretivists believe that sociological research can be influenced by the researchers choice of topic, the researchers assumptions about society, the research methods that are used and how the data are interpreted. They believe that values influence the whole research process and this is highly subjective and so cannot be value free. Positivists believe that sociology can be value free due to the scientific approach that they advocate. In conclusion, some sociologists have tried to rectify the problem of value freedom within sociological research and have offered a solution with the formulation of a new question 'should sociology be value free?' However, Post modernists would criticise these people, as they believe that there is no such thing as validity (truth) so, in their view, value freedom cannot exist at all. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Assess the values on sociological research of value free sociology, value laden and committed ...

    3 star(s)

    They point to a number of issues to support their views. Gouldner has pointed out that value free sociology points to Max Weber as a sociologist who claimed that personal views never enter sociological research. However Gouldner suggests that his words must be placed into a historical context as he

  2. Religion can be both a conservative force and an initiator of social change.'To what ...

    Religion manages these tensions and recreates stability. Parsons wrote in the 1930s and 1940s that religion provides guidelines for human action in terms of 'core values' Religion helps to integrate people into a value consensus and allows them to make sense of their lives. There's also a Functionalist idea of civil religion, which is when secular symbols

  1. James Gilligan's Thesis on Violence

    James makes connections from poverty to violence, and discusses how class stratification has always had this effect. Structural violence also has a meaning towards the psychology of others that would inflict these causes for one to shame them self to resort to such violence; where James talks about reasoning behind this.

  2. Sociology Investigation

    when the teacher has already said that they are hopeless in that subject. Even if these students try to resist this label, they would find it hard to achieve as some teachers might deem it a waste of resources spending time trying to improve in that subject."

  1. "Marxism and other theories of social conflict are irrelevant to an understanding of modern ...

    Tawny believes that there must be equality within classes to have a fair life, BUT there must be inequality between classes so that the bourgeoisies can enjoy their rights. In 1930 Marx stated that "The separate individuals form a class only in so far as they have to carry on

  2. evaluation of methods

    In my sociological context I have said, this difference can arise for several factors; It could be because of 'assimilation'. The state of change in the teenagers mind could have made them to assimilate form the traditional Indian values to the Western British values.

  1. ASSESS THE SOCIOLOGICAL ARGUMENTS AND EVIDENCE THAT RELIGION IS A CONSERVATIVE FORCE IN SOCIETY ...

    Karl Marx' famous quote states that religion is the 'opium of the masses' as it dulls the working class' pain of exploitation. He claims that religion is a sedative, a narcotic, which dulls the people's experience of sensitivity to and understanding of the difficulty of their life situation.

  2. Evaluation of the difference between Positivist and Interpretivist methodologies

    Even within laboratory conditions people are influenced by those around them, as was proven at the Hawthorne Works in Chicago7, when Mayo showed that it was the appearance of a researcher that caused productivity to rise, rather than the changes in environmental conditions that were being experimented with.[19] The Phenomenologist's

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work