• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast 'Overcoat' By Ghulam Abbas and 'The Blue Donkey' By Suniti Namjoshi - Which Are about Societies Attitude to People Based Upon Their Appearances

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast 'Overcoat' By Ghulam Abbas and 'The Blue Donkey' By Suniti Namjoshi. Which Are about Societies Attitude to People Based Upon Their Appearances. The 'Overcoat' and 'The Blue Donkey' are about how people tend to stereotype people by their outward appearance; societies see the outer shell of people and immediately make a judgement without looking deeper. People are rejected because of their appearance; both stories are about how appearances can be misleading. The story 'Overcoat' is about a young man who dresses smartly, neatly and is well groomed in order to conform with the society. In contrast, 'The Blue Donkey' is about a blue donkey that lives in the neighbourhood of the Red Bridge Society, where she is rejected because of her bright blue skin. We can recognize 'Overcoat' is a fable since the characters in 'Overcoat' do not have names, only the names of the street are mentioned. For instance, 'Charing Cross, Lawrence Garden, Mc Leod Road' etc, are used to make it sound more like a true story. The young man is walking through some Asian city, we can recognize this by the people n the story such as, Tonga-wallas, Pan wallas etc and the money used in India and Pakistan is 'Anna'. ...read more.


The shoes and the socks had to come off now. The shoes were old but were polished clean. As for the socks, they were different in colour and pattern from each other. There were holes in the socks from which the filth could be seen. Before the clothes had been taken off, his face was toward the ceiling but slowly it had turned toward the wall as his clothes had been taken off as if in shame for what he really was under his mask. 'Was it perhaps for the shame of this dual nakedness of body and soul that now he dared not face his fellow beings?' The story ends pathetically with the few items in the young man's pocket, 'A small black comb, a handkerchief, six annas and a few pies, a half smoked cigarette, a little diary in which the names and addresses of a few people were noted, a list of gramophone records and a few handbills which distributors had thrust upon him during his evening promenade.' In contrast, 'The Blue Donkey' starts negatively and ends positively. Both parties first reject her. Her skin colour was different and so they rejected her. ...read more.


Societies should not judge people for what they look like on top without looking deeper, like the people in 'Overcoat' who judged the young man to be wealthy as in the end he was a pauper who just wore an overcoat so he could fit in with the society and so he would not be rejected. I think this story resembles the saying, 'All that glitters isn't gold' The young man in 'Overcoat' deceives himself by judging others by their outward appearance when he is covering his true self just like the society around him, 'It was their clothes rather than their faces that attracted his attention.' The donkey in the story represents old aged pensioners, disabled people, ethnic minorities, poor people, foreigners, coloured people as the story is about prejudice and the refusal to accept people for what they really are. In the end the blue donkey is accepted, she did not mind looking different from the society. She didn't do what the society said but she did what she thought was good for her. I think this story resembles the saying, 'Don't judge a book by its cover.' Like the red bridge society, we tend to jump to conclusions and stereotype. People are too quick to judge and reject anyone who is different. This discrimination and intolerance can easily lead to war. Asma ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Compare and contrast white collar crimes and street crimes, while understanding the definition of ...

    as a whole, while other may suggest the union and workers needed to be more involved. These are probably all true. By all means Bob Loughhead, according to the writings of Phillip Smith must hold significant responsibility for the misdoings.

  2. Theory and Practice of Work with Young People

    reality absorbs those within it and thereby acts to submerge human beings consciousness' (Freire, 1993:33). And as they struggle with meeting their most basic of needs I sometimes find it difficult to justify my continuing commitment to educate them about inequality when their overwhelming deprivation is viewed from my comfortable, middle class life style.

  1. Using the factual accounts of the sinking of the Titanic, compare and contrast how ...

    However in 'A night to Remember' he is shown to be in control even when the ship is sinking as he gives the orders and in 'Titanic' they are suggested to him by the crew. 'A Night to Remember' unlike 'Titanic', spends some time on the two other ships in

  2. 'The Simple Bard, unbroke by rules or Art'. (Burns epigraph to the Kilmarnockedition). How ...

    In this stanza there is the clear distinction between those who 'toil for warld's gear' and himself, with his 'jo', looking down over those who are out to 'catch-the-plack!' (p. 136). His pleasure grows from love, not from the gaining of the 'warld's gear'.

  1. Sexism is a form of prejudice.

    First I am going to discuss adverts from 20 years ago. An advert for tampax from 20 years ago shows a woman prancing around very elegantly looking into a mirror. This is probably to make sure she looks the same as she did, because she has been prancing around a field.

  2. On Your Shoes & The Parvenue

    The narrator in "The Parvenue" who is the mother is a young woman. She is middle aged. However, in "Your Shoes" the mother or the narrator is fairly old. "I locked the wardrobe on those rebellious shoes" This suggests that this quote is a metaphor and she is comparing her daughter to a pair of shoes.

  1. The origin and evolution of animal societies

    Advantages of a society * Defence: societies provide "safety in numbers", whereby you are protected by the sheer number of the society - it being enough to prevent attack from predators. Whether active or passive it is safer to face predators in a group than as an individual.

  2. The Glass Ceiling

    Many men have very subtle and low-key ways of showing their discrimination. These men know that it is unlawful to discriminate against women, so they do it ways that can have no reprimanding consequences. They will go out to lunch, dinner or drinks with the guys, claiming that it is just a time for male bonding.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work