• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast two of the perspectives - Marx & Weber

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast two of the perspectives Marx & Weber Karl Marx is a German socialist who had strong views and ideas about class and society, his theory was what is called a macro theory. This is basically meaning that it has general theories for the masses and sees people working together, for a common goal. Max Weber also a German socialist on the other hand, separates people into small groups and individuals and is very much a 'dog eat dog' view of people and society. Weber believed that people competed against each other for resources, prestige and power in society. Marx theory is what is called a 'homogeneity' view, which sees everyone as the same and all being equal. Weber's theory however is called a 'heterogeneous' view in which everyone is different and people are not equal, there is a very clear divide between the 'working class' and 'middle class' exclusionary practices are common place, and it could be said that it is restrictive and aims to keep the rich rich and the poor poor. Marx believed that people needed to work together in order to get the basics of life e.g. food and material objects, by working together they enter social relationships or groups which are defined by the combination of 'forces of production' and 'means of production' the forces of production is the physical labour involved of production and the 'means of production' is the machinery and tools that are also required in the production. ...read more.

Middle

However Marx believed it was purely down to who owned the means of production and who didn't. Weber saw capitalism as making people richer and more prosperous due to the expanse of capitalist enterprises and the increase in demand of administration workers there became more 'white collar' or middle class. Marx however saw the polarization of the workers, as large companies expanded taking over small businesses and companies, which brought more white collar workers and less and less owners but more and more workers. Weber unlike Marx didn't believe in 'collective class' and saw no reason as why working class would attempt to organise each other and try to other throw capitalism so they could be a collective class and share the wealth. He did acknowledge it as a possibility as the 'common market' formed by the expanse of the capitalist enterprises would make it easier for working class to form groups, but saw it as nothing more than a possibility. Unlike Marx who thought political power should lie with economic power e.g. as the vast majority of society was working class they formed the economic power and therefore should have the political power as well, Marx saw it as unfair and unjust that the minority of wealthy classes had the majority of political power. ...read more.

Conclusion

religions, people who went to public schools mixing only with other public school families and reserving jobs only for people who also attended public school, an extreme example of status being restrictive is the Caste system in India. To a degree this contradicts Weber's theory of 'rewards' being handed to the 'superior' as there are other factors involved. In conclusion Weber seems to break down the barriers of class making people less 'class conscious' and weakening class solidarity. Because he sees people grouping themselves by their status it makes it less important. Whilst doing this he is still continuing the progression of the capitalist way of life. He seeked to bring people together by their attitudes, beliefs and values. Marx believed that being a member of a certain community defined by your wealth is what determines people's values and beliefs, he strived for social equality believing that class is the only element that forms social groups but his views can be seen as na�ve and basic. Weber sees people as being in control of their 'destiny' and 'rewards' not confined to the class they were born into. He believes society has a much more complex and diverse social structure than Marx's and believes the rewards should only be handed out to people who prove themselves to be superior and not given to groups just because they are the majority. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Karl Marx and Max Weber have different views upon social class in contemporary societies.

    RSPCA, trade unions or religious groups). Leaders and members in such organizations have different social power within a society. Weber suggested that the relationship between political groups and class and status groups are not always clear-cut. 'Weber argues that men do not only strive for power to enrich themselves.

  2. Comparisons and contrasts between the theories of Karl Marx and Max Weber on social ...

    However these classes are not, for Weber, located in the production process as they are in Marx's work. Rather Weber's classes are rooted in economic markets. Markets such as the labour markets, the commodity markets and the money markets. Therefore classes are the product of market relationships.

  1. Feminist Perspectives On Education.

    In addition, those working class women who did attempt to gain an education had to contend with the rhetoric and content of an education provided by their 'social superiors'. In addition to a class based education, working class women also had to contend with the working class men who began to take up aspects of the bourgeois ideology of domesticity.

  2. Compare and contrast white collar crimes and street crimes, while understanding the definition of ...

    Simply, this version of worker ownership sees workers as consumers and bases its appeal on financial incentives (primarily, stock ownership or some form of profit sharing) to bring labor and management together under one roof to improve productivity, quality and overall company performance.

  1. I will examine the social class theories of Karl Marx and Max Weber, and ...

    just education acquired skills, which allows them to substantially increase their market value beyond anything Marx would consider valuable. Therefore, their very high status in society is from their natural talents, which are usually highly respected, improves their lifestyle dramatically and in turn allows them to move up the social ladder.

  2. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    purely disinterested motives a) purely affectual, b) rational belief in absolute validity of an order as an expression of ultimate values, c) religious attitudes, through belief in need to follow order for salvation 2) entirely through self-interest based on ulterior motives Convention: system of order where infraction meets with sanctions of disapproval and orders are considered binding.

  1. Using examples describe a range of sociological perspectives and theories (including both classic and ...

    It celebrates all things female, whether these derive from social, class, or biological circumstances of women's lives. Difference feminists see many gender traits as biological, or at least deeply structured cultural, traits. They celebrate the differences between women and men, seeing feminine qualities as a source of personal strength and

  2. Max Weber (1864 - 1920)

    This has the effect of ripping the heart out of social discourse, allowing complex differentiation to occur but at the cost of social pathologies http://www.stefan-szczelkun.org.uk/phd404.htm In sociology, rationalisation is the process whereby an increasing number of social actions and interactions become based on considerations of efficiency or calculation rather than on motivations derived from custom, tradition, or emotion.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work