• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare Marxist and Functionalist theories of the role of religion

Extracts from this document...


Compare Marxist and Functionalist theories of the role of religion Religion is not easy to define therefore, as there are so many questions to consider when coming answering that question. However some sociologists have tried to define what is involved in religion. Glock and Stark identified '5 core dimensions' of religiosity, which they argue should influence the day-to-day action and interaction of individuals. Similarly Durkheim tries to define religion as being the scared as opposed to the profane. The sacred is something is something outside our normal lives; it includes a belief in a supernatural being or force, therefore treated in a ritualised way. For example for Muslims, going to mosque for special Friday prayers and mass for Roman Catholics is a ritual. Any object can be regarded as sacred as long as it treated like so. Surrogate religions develop from this treatment, for example many nationalists treat their national flags as sacred. Therefore from Durkheim's definition anything can be religion, as long as it is treated in a sacred way. Functionalists believe that religion is an important institution in promoting collective consciousness, social solidarity and harmony. They believe that religion is about beliefs and practices because beliefs affect how people behave socially. ...read more.


The actions of Father Torres show that even the ruling classes can join the proletariats to fight an oppressive and capitalist society. Therefore religion does play a great role in enabling society to join together when there is a crisis. Parsons, another functionalist sociologist believes human behaviour is directed and controlled by the norms of the social system. He says that religious beliefs provide guidelines for human action and standards against which peoples conduct can be evaluated. The Ten Commandments integrates religious beliefs with norms of the social system. For example the commandment " thou shalt not kill" is also used as a social norm. Therefore religion can be used to control people into acting in a way, which does not disturb society. It also promotes social consciousness as people see that killing is morally wrong and they would be punished in the afterlife for doing so, thus they would not do it. However Marxist sociologists believe that religious "laws" such as, "do not steal" are created to benefit the ruling classes, because as the proletariats follow these religions and everything they say, it allows the ruling classes to exploit them. Marxist would also say that religion is only a subtle, soft form of social control. As the ruling class recognises that force will cause subject classes to rebel. As Gramcsi said, "It (religion) ...read more.


Marxists say that the only role that religion plays in society is being a fantasy escape for proletariats from their oppressive positions, however all the promises of religion are false. Durkheim declares that religion is a expression and celebration of peoples solidarity, nevertheless a Marxist would say that it is a consolation for experiences which lack genuine solidarity of which are capable. What's more the promises of heavenly rewards in religion are an illusion, as true happiness occurs only when the exploited shake off the chains of oppression to seize and practice their freedom. The three perspectives: Functionalist, Marxists and Neo-Marxists say that religion plays a role in society. However they have different ideas about what this role is. The functionalists see religion as a tool to promoting social solidarity and a way of keeping society stable. Whilst Marxist see religion as a form of ideology which leads the masses in false directions, obscuring the nature of reality whilst the ruling classes use it to rule over them. And an institution, which maintains capitalist rule by dominion and oppression. On the other hand the neo-Marxists agree that religion and the church are used to shape the minds of the working classes to aide their exploitation, but they also give strong examples of times when religion works in the favour of the oppressed to support them in their struggle in oppression and for freedom. ?? ?? ?? ?? Sociology of Religion Zuhra Abukar ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Compare and contrast the Marxist and Functionalist explanations of the role of religion in ...

    place whose outcome are important but uncertain and uncontrollable, therefore creating anxiety. Malinowski uses an example from his study of the Trobriand Islands. Fishing in open seas requires many rituals as they fear storms and are uncertain about catches, however fishing in calm waters does not require any rituals as there is no danger.

  2. Compare and contrast the six main sociological theories of religion as well as examining ...

    Stark and Bainbridge recognise that religion might not actually provide people with eternal life, but what it does offer is a 'compensator'. A compensator is the belief that a reward will be obtained in the distant future or in some other context that cannot be verified.

  1. Outline Some Of The Key Tenets Of The Functionalist, Marxist and Interactionist Theories Of ...

    come to fill particular positions on the basis of achievement instead of their ascribed characteristics. However, although achievement is more important in society, social class, gender and ethnicity are also important in the sense that the quality of a person's educational achievement can be related to their ascribed characteristics.

  2. Discuss the Marxist and Functionalist Perspectives on the Family

    Without economy there would be no means to provide for the family. Without education there would be no culture and human society without culture could not function. Murdock appreciate than apart from this the family performed many more functions for society. Murdock critically claimed that the nuclear family was universal.

  1. This essay will explain the functionalist, Marxist and Social action theories of race and ...

    These two forms of discrimination have become popularly known as 'racism'. (Race - definitions Handout) Sheila Patterson's 1965 study of "Dark Strangers" was based on the first-generation of immigrants from the West Indies, entering Britain namely, Brixton in London throughout the 1950's.

  2. Evaluate Marxist and Functionalist Views of Religion.

    Problems that disrupt society fall into two categories. One of the categories is that individuals are hit by events they cannot foresee; an example of one of these events is death. Weber provided an alternative definition of religion. Weber moved away from the exclusive emphasis on the social grounding of religion, and highlights the meaning of religion for individuals.

  1. Compare and Contrast Functionalism and Marxist Theories of the Role of Religion These Two ...

    Social regulation is where rituals which reinforce collective conscience. By taking part in church services they renew their commitment to religion,moral beliefs and values.This means religion can control human behaviour. The second contributor is Bronislaw Malinowski. Malinowski studied the Trobriad Islands.In his analysis and evaluation he studied more on functions to a individuals rather than a whole community like Durkeim.

  2. The Influence and Role of Religion In Hopi Society.

    They are intertwined throughout every facet of Hopi life and dictate the social organization of the Hopi people. In Hopi Cosmology, an account of man's creation is provided in a story of four worlds. Mankind went through many trials and tribulations, progressing through three worlds before making it to the present world.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work