• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the lives of the two central characters in 'The Son's Veto' and 'The melancholy Hussar'. What is the authors treatment of women and class prejudice.

Extracts from this document...


Daniel Knott Compare the lives of the two central characters in 'The Son's Veto' and 'The melancholy Hussar'. What is the authors treatment of women and class prejudice. Introduction Having read and analysed these two short stories, written by Thomas Hardy in the 19th century, and considered the essay question I feel we must firstly consider the two main characters, Sophy and Phyllis. Both characters are not able to marry someone they love because they have to keep others happy. Firstly, Sophy has married someone in an upper class out of respect. Then after her husband died, she is left in an uncomfortable, patriarchal society. Her son then refuses her the right to re-marry because he wants to keep his social status. Phyllis, on the other hand, has a chance to be with the man she loves, but wanting to keep her father happy, stays. The Son's Veto Before she dies, Sophy is left feeling deserted due to her son's denial to her being allowed to re-marry to Sam Hobson, "taking her before a little cross that he had erected in his bedroom for his private devotions, there bade her kneel, and swear that she would not wed Samuel Hobson without his content." This quote is just one of many that shows Randolph has an extraordinary power over Sophy. This eventually drives Sophy to her death, lonely and depressed. This has been created by Hardy's patriarchal society and Randolph's superior education. ...read more.


In Sophy he shows a weak, badly- treated, dependent woman, quite normal in the 19th century's patriarchal society, "and she had done it her self, poor thing." In Randolph he shows a dominant, well- educated man/boy whom, although Sophy's son, has control over her. "His mother hastily adopted the correction, and did not resent his making it, or retaliate, as she might have done." In Mr. Twycott he represents a man who can abuse his position to get what he needs, "She hardly dared refuse a parsonage." In Sam he shows the person Sophy can't have because of her social boundaries, "Such a lady as you've been so long, you couldn't be a wife to a man like me." This suggests people who are pre- occupied with social class/reputation and doing the expected thing are just upper class people. This is wrong! Although it is not referred to in the story lower class people try to do the expected thing and Hardy has not shown this. I strongly disagree with this influence in this story. Upper class people, represented by Mr. Twycott and Randolph, are shown as self absorbed and socially conscious, "It will degrade me in the eyes of all the gentleman of England." Hardy's judgement of Sophy's fate is a strong and effective one as it shows just how stressful life can be as a lonely, upper class citizen. ...read more.


His language shows his attitude towards these themes. He uses more complex, meaningful words to put emphasis on certain points, for example he uses "cannot break faith" instead of "remain loyal". In each of the stories, Hardy's attitude towards women and class prejudice is that of a negative one. This is because both women have made sacrifices and have been pressured into marriage. But, as each became older, what seemed right to do at the time turned into regret. Hardy's attitude is that men have a superior dominating effect on society and that women can used and abused. This mainly shows in "The Melancholy Hussar" where Humphrey has dumped Phyllis. "The Son's Veto" puts across the same point and another one. In "The Son's Veto" the setting is Gaymead, a nice little town that reflects a happy life that Sophy lead before she married. In "The Melancholy Hussar", set in the countryside represents Phyllis's lonely, isolated life. The essay question asked us compare the lives of the two central characters in "The Son's Veto" and "The Melancholy Hussar". What is the author's treatment of women and class prejudice? In the two stories Hardy wants us to think about this. He wants us to think why were women mistreated and why was there so much class prejudice? Hardy seems to suggest that when somebody marries's up class there is going to be problems. In the short stories they are sometimes overreacted, but otherwise he has a very correct portrayal of 19th century society ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Analyse the relationship between the mother and her son in " The Son's Veto" ...

    When Sophy got back she wandered what it would be like to start a new life with Sam but thought not because if she was to marry Sam she would lose the money for her sons education and she would be marrying back into a low class family and she

  2. The Characters' Conformation to Social Restrictions in the stories The Gilded Six-Bits by Zora ...

    Nothing more. Joe wouldn't be coming home as usual. No need to fling open the front door and sweep off the porch, making it nice for Joe. Never no more breakfast to cook; no more washing and starching of Joe's jumper-jackets and pants. No more nothing, So why get-up?"

  1. What Impact did the War Have on the Role of Women in British Society ...

    working class women were forced back into domestic service, a menial job not requiring much skill or intelligence. Also, for the women who found themselves out of work, the role of housewife and mother became even more important than it was before the war.

  2. To What Extent Does Hardy Portray Sophy Twycott In The 'Son's Veto' As A ...

    Here is just basically saying that her age says that she is an adult but really, naturally she acts like a child. It can be argued that that these weaknesses in her character, contributed to her downfall. Society and Social expectations affected Sophy's life greatly.

  1. The ancient civilizations of Central and South America

    The basis of their society was the calpulli, or a group of families that all lived together. This huge family all came from a common ancestor and mostly lived together and in relative isolation from everyone else. They would conduct their affairs very efficiently as well.

  2. 'The Son's Veto': Is Sophy a victim of society?

    His cruel actions were sharply felt by Sophy, who spent her days 'pining her heart away' when she could have led such an 'idyllic life'. The verb 'pining' conveys vividly to the reader Sophy's great pain and desire. Although these actions can be seen to represent Randolph's natural character, Hardy

  1. The Sons Veto

    have felt that she couldn't then defy her son because she swore to him that she wouldn't. I do agree with the statement because the main reason that Sophy sacrifices everything is because the times she lived in. in those days, the upper-class society (portrayed by Randolph)

  2. How do the writers Thomas Hardy and Alice Walker use their protagonist's Roselily and ...

    To me this suggest that Phyllis has had problems going with her personal desires ever since childhood and to sit on top of the wall is as far as Phyllis could get. Although there is also reference to the fact that sitting upon this wall was normal routine for Phyllis

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work