• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically evaluate Marxist approaches to crime and deviance.

Extracts from this document...


Critically evaluate Marxist approaches to crime and deviance Marxism became increasingly influential in sociology during the 1970's, partly due to the failure of functionalism that promised to provide answers that functionalists failed to provide. Marxism sees society based on an economic infrastructure that incorporates the relations of production and means of production. The other aspects of society, known as the superstructure is based on top of this infrastructure and are determined by it. They see society containing basic contradictions, which means that they cannot survive in their existing form. (Which involves the exploitation of one social group by another.) They see this exploitation to disappear once a revolution occurs, where everyone will be liberated and will be free from oppression. Classical Marxism, being a structural approach, shares common assumptions with functionalists such as they accept official statistics and that the working class become criminals, but see capitalism as brutalising the working class and for this reason has changed them from the normal. Classical Marxists see crime as to be an automatic process and not problematic. Nor do they see agencies of social control as problematic, but automatically serving the ruling class. ...read more.


Their assumptions include the following: 1. If you want to understand crime, you have to look at the material base of society 2. If you look at capitalist societies, the fundamental characteristic is that of massive inequality of wealth and power 3. It supports the radical transformation of society to a more socialist society, which then developed into the FULL SOCIAL THEORY OF DEVIANCE. This saw: a) You have to understand how power and wealth are distributed in society b) Sociologists must consider the conditions surrounding individuals who chooses to commit a crime c) To consider the meaning behind the act d) To then look at the social reaction to the act e) Then link the social reaction to the wider society and explain it in terms of this f) Then the consequences of the label on the individual so labelled has to be looked at g) And finally, a full explanation of deviance requires a fusion of all six points. Jock young acknowledged points (c), (d) and (f), however failed to explain why the teenagers took the drugs in the first place. To answer this question, we have to refer to the other points. ...read more.


It only covers some deaths, and doesn't see such things as killing in wars as illegal. It can be seen that the new criminology can be credited in that it synthesises structure and action together. It focuses on moral panics and links this to the wider society. It also shows how we give consent to things we normally wouldn't such as the murder law. However, the new criminology is idealistic. It suggests that crime is socially constructed and that it doesn't exist, and trivialises everything that people DO actually experience in increased crimes. It also suggests that criminals are freedom fighters; that they are only rebelling against the powerful. Most crimes are committed against the powerless not the powerful, therefore doesn't consider the victims of the crime unless they are talking about the crimes of the powerful. Its policy as to how to solve crime isn't realistic. They say that in order for crime to disappear, they have to wait for the revelation, BUT this has never happened in any society, communist or not. Lastly, it focuses on male behaviour only and is male streamed. It renders women invisible, but women are more prevalent as victims. It is out of these criticisms that the realist criminology was developed whereby it argued against the idealism of new criminology. Rozina Shafi March 2003 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays


    The multi-national company, Union Carbide leaked deadly gases into the atmosphere killing thousands. Investigations since have revealed that the company set up this particular plant because pollution controls in India were less rigid than in the USA. In Snider's terms (1993), the Indian State supported such capitalist development in the interests of allowing profits to be made.

  2. Inventing Reality: Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment

    Aside from Raskolnikov, the character who is mostly associated with another kind of reality, at the boundary between the subconscious and the supernatural is Svidrigailov. As mentioned before, the fist time he actually appears in the novel, Raskolnikov believes he is a dream, so an embodiment of an inner reality rather than a real person.

  1. Critically evaluate the various sociological theories of crime and deviance including: Functionalist, Marxist, Labelling ...

    The majority is not involved in the law making process. The Marxist approach has been one of the most important approaches in explaining deviant behaviour. They mainly base their ideas and theories on how the powerful people control the society which influences how the society works today.

  2. The classical and positivist approaches to criminological theory

    The emergent response to criminal behaviour and how to deal with it is also notably different between the two approaches. The classical theory saw the function of the law as to 'furnish the requirements of a particular society',1 and thus focused primarily on limiting the use of punishment.

  1. Eugenics - good breeding.

    Humanae Vitae, the popular, yet controversial encyclical, restated the Church's vehement opposition to birth control and that it was immoral. Birth control is the tool suggested by Margaret Sanger to wipe out blacks and other minorities whom she deemed less fit than true Americans: "We do not want word to

  2. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    such systems as caste systems, did not exist in such strength in the occident. Chap 29, The Rational State Modern capism can survive only in the modern rational state. Characteristics of the Modern Rational State: 1) Expert officialdom and rational law.

  1. Outline and evaluate Marxist theories of crime.

    However, the simple claim that the law benefits the ruling class is a contentious one as there are several which benefit the wealthy in no way at all. For example unemployment benefits are no use to the ruling class as they obviously will not be claiming them or the NHS

  2. Critically Examine the Subcultural Approach to Crime and Deviance.

    deviance, based around the particular experience that the individual has of the social world. Merton argues that different social classes, social groups, sub-cultural groups etc. socialise their members in slightly different ways, depending upon their particular social circumstances. Whilst he does not explore this idea in any great depth, a classic distinction between working-class and middle class socialisation is made.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work