• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically examine the view that the health inequalities suffered by the working class can be explained in terms of inappropriate behaviours and attitudes.

Extracts from this document...


Sociology of Health Critically examine the view that the health inequalities suffered by the working class can be explained in terms of inappropriate behaviours and attitudes. The well documented growth of inequality and wealth coupled with persistent inequalities in health found in the United Kingdom and elsewhere, have refocused attention on social class as a key determinate of health outcomes.1 Whilst the correlation between social class and health status has long been recognised by government organisations and academic communities, agreements as to the mechanisms driving this inequality are still lacking. The ageing process and our genetic inheritance do have important influences on our health, though health education awareness, access to health, leisure and social services and a range of other social factors have an impact on how effectively we can cope with them.2 This paper will give thought to the relationship between social class and inequalities in health and illnesses and whether there is a convincing link between the working class members of society not being equally served by the health care system. Whilst the focus will be on the exploration of the relation between health and social class, a discussion of this paper will also illustrate to four fundamental models of explanations, which have been put forward by sociologists, along their strengths and limitations, which the essay will go on to explain in relation to the title essay. There remain significant differences and inequalities in health and health care particularly with respect to class. ...read more.


heart disease and lung cancer, in research on Whitehall civil servants by Marmot (1884).13 They found that even with non-smokers the risk of these diseases was still strongly associated with the grade of job held, thereby pointing to the inability of this model to fully explain most health inequalities, as cultural and behavioural differences only accounted for approximately 25% of all social class inequalities.14 The artefact explanation, on the other hand suggests there are real problems of measurement and the statistics themselves may not be reliable indicators.15 This explanation suggests that class inequalities in health do not really exist; they only appear to exist because of the way class is constructed. There are four important points to consider when looking at this explanation: Firstly, the number of people in the lower class groups, especially unskilled manual workers, is in decline, so statistics on health inequalities among the poorer classes are based on fewer people. Secondly, the few workers reaming in lower-class jobs are still experiencing better health than in the past. Thirdly, these suggested figures tend to mask the higher levels of collapse disease among (especially) middle-class women - Alzheimer's - as women and middle-class people live longer, and finally, this explanation also criticises the classification of people by occupation.16 However, the authors of The Black Report argue that this explanation is not particularly convincing, as working class groups do not have as much contact that is often supposed, while poor health affects all manual workers, not just those classified as 'unskilled'. ...read more.


Many sociologists such as Whitehead (1987) argue that this theory does not substantiate the claim, as it is illustrated even when studies are able to control for factors like smoking and drinking, a sizeable proportion of the health gap still remains and factors related to the general living conditions and environment of the poor are indicated. All in all, the link between class and inequality seems evident as there is widespread agreement among sociologists using evidence from the research of Black, Acheson and The Joseph Rowntree Trust that structural and cultural factors are the main contributors to health differentials between classes, and that in reality these factors are interrelated, with the artefact and selectionist explanations playing some part in the reported differences. In this context there is also a growing number of evidence that material and structural factors, such as housing and income can in fact affect health. Most importantly, several studies have shown that unfavourable social conditions can limit the choice of an individuals life style and it is this set of studies which illustrates most clearly to many sociologists that behaviour and attitudes cannot be separated from its social environment. As social and economic life have major influences on the patterns of illness and death, many sociologists argue that as long as inequalities of wealth, income, education, occupation and social privilege continue, so will inequalities in health. It is for all these reasons that sociologists have generally given more emphasis to material, social and economic explanations rather than cultural ones for social class inequalities in health, as supposed to the title essay. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Changing attitudes to marriage

    The reasons why it is not were that people get tired of each other soon; sometimes they have problems that they can't deal with; people change over period of time etc. Other youngsters thought that if you truly love someone you won't want to get divorced; that the marriage is

  2. Free essay

    Discuss the view that health inequalities can be explained by lifestyle choices made by ...

    the report found that 'the higher the social class group, the lower it's SMR and conversely the lower the social class group, the higher it's SMR'. Another important finding, which is still true today, was that the gap between the two classes was widening but an over-all increase in health all-round.

  1. A-Level Sociology Theory + Methods Revision.

    view you in a different way others see you Significant Other I = selfish Cooley - "The looking glass self" Me = you want to know what other people think of you We need feedback from others. Herb Blumer - Reiterates Mead.

  2. The influence of social class on health and healthcare.

    Local studies have shows that access to women practitioners can also be a barrier to Asian women from taking attending cervical screening, access to female practitioners is poorer in areas with high concentrations of Asian residents and that practices with a female nurse are more likely to reach certain group.

  1. Is working class underachievement better explained by factors inside or outside the school?

    Barry Sugarman (1970) provided his explanation stating that working classes use "immediate gratification" alongside fatalism, present time orientation and collectivism. Thus, by not looking ahead and concentrating on the immediate future this will enhance early departure from the educational system.

  2. Choose a group which faces barriers in terms of participation in sport and leisure ...

    The current participation rate reflects past centuries of discrimination and torment. What I have mentioned here are key factors which have slowed the process of women's sport, the attitudes (of biological determinism) and the misconceptions of science, and moral standings of many, that women are supposed to be the homemakers,

  1. The essay will interpret inequalities in health among the sub-populations of socio-economic class position, ...

    Those writers discussing class inequalities in standards of health usually use the 'Registrar Generals', five-tier classification. It is based on a man or single women's occupation and so a married women, is classified according to her husbands occupation, meaning the term has an inherent gender inaccuracy.

  2. Discuss the possible reasons for higher mortality and morbidity rates among the working classes.

    (In 1998 there were less people in class V than in 1970, so to try to account for this, Acheson combined the top two classes and the bottom two. However this still showed that in the 1970s a person in classes IV & V had a 53% higher chance of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work