• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the possible reasons for higher mortality and morbidity rates among the working classes.

Extracts from this document...


DISCUSS THE POSSIBLE REASONS FOR HIGHER MORTALITY AND MORBIDITY RATES AMONG THE WORKING CLASSES. It has been acknowledged since the 19th Century that class relates to inequality. This essay will explore this area in more detail, considering the various explanations given for these differences. The most widely accepted, recent study of health inequalities and social class was the Black Report of 1980, which gathered information relating to the Standardised Mortality Rates (SMR) for different social classes in Britain, based on the Registrar General's categorization according to occupation The Black Report was clear in its conclusion: 'In the case of adults between the ages of 15 and 64, for virtually all causes of death there is a consistent inverse relationship between social class and mortality. That is, the higher the social class group, the lower its SMR, and conversely the lower the social class group, the higher its SMR.' (Black Report, 1980) The report also came up with four possible explanations: statistical artefact ( the differences reflect the differences in methodologies used in measurement of SMR and morbidity rates); social selection (the differences are because healthier people rise up through the social classes leaving the sick or disabled at the bottom); cultural explanations (the lower social classes lead unhealthier lifestyles than the higher classes, leading to more illness and ...read more.


Other researchers have argued that the opposite is in fact true, however: that those from poorer backgrounds face a wealth of economic, social and employment factors that contribute to ill health. Therefore they say that class position shapes health, and not vice versa. The third explanation is that of culture, and says that the lower classes engage in more unhealthy lifestyles: smoking, eating more fatty and sugary foods, and drinking more. All lead to higher morbidity levels and earlier deaths (HMSO, 1999). Blame for these statistics is therefore laid firmly at the individual's door, or with the social environment in which they live, and educational programmes are advocated. However critics argue that these behaviours are a rational response to the circumstances in which people live. For example, Graham & Blackburn (1993) found that mothers on Income Support smoke because they have lower 'psycho-social' health than the general population, and smoking provides a very real form of relief for them. It may be the only thing that they do for themselves in a day filled with childcare responsibilities, and may also be an economic necessity, in that the nicotine abates hunger so that food is not as necessary. A further explanation given for the class inequalities in health is the materialistic explanation, which traces the main influences on health to the structures of society and conditions of life for its members. ...read more.


hernias, gallstones, when compared with the amount of consultations made by patients (Chaturvedi & Ben-Shlomo, 1995) and often once a referral has been made a patient from a deprived area will be given lower priority and therefore wait longer for surgery than one from a better-off area (Pell et al, 2000). In conclusion, it has been shown that vast inequalities in health status, and also in health care provision, exist between the social classes, even in modern Britain, despite the popular conception of a 'classless society'. Despite improvements in medical knowledge, nutrition, housing, sanitation, employment conditions and the health services, people of a lower social class are still more likely to die before they reach one year of age, and, if they reach that milestone, are three times more likely to die before the age of 64 than somebody in a higher social class. Various explanations for these facts have been put forward, and criticised, but the theory that seems to have most support from the research available is that of the materialists. This links with the social model of health, which is gradually becoming more widely accepted. It will take huge effort on behalf of a government to reduce, and eventually eradicate, the inequalities in health experienced by those in the lowest social classes within Britain today, but that is not to say it is impossible given consistent and committed effort. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Book Review E. P. Thompson's "The Making of the English Working Class"

    which is certainly the case in 'The making of the English working class'. Of course, Thompson's bias and sympathy for the exploitation of the artisans prior to the Industrial Revolution, highlights his position as a Marxist historian. Karl Marx's most rudimentary observation was that labour set humans apart from the

  2. What effects did World War One have on social classes?

    Some European countries were still semi-feudal and relatively untouched by industrialization unlike Britain and Germany. The table in unit 3 page 107 gives five different classes, Tim Brooker AA312 R8413113 TMA 03 a)aristocracy or landed class/bourgeoisie/gentry b) Mittelstand, middle-class or lower middle-class c) peasants d) working-class e) riff-raff/underclass or residium.

  1. Critically examine the view that the health inequalities suffered by the working class can ...

    cigarettes and alcohol, would live on healthy vegetable casseroles, and would walk everywhere for exercise. The fact that some do not do this suggests a deficient culture and value system. Cultural explanations essentially place the blame on individuals themselves, in what are called 'victim-blaming' theories.9 Supporters of this explanation argue

  2. The essay will interpret inequalities in health among the sub-populations of socio-economic class position, ...

    (Black et al., 1982: 37) CLASS When analysing indicators of health, there can seen to be disproportionate amount of mortality and morbidity in the working class population in comparison with the middle class sector of British society. Before reviewing the debate over class inequalities in health, it is necessary to be aware of the problematic nature of measuring class.

  1. Construction of Childhood

    The government's strategy on eradicating poverty became prevalent in 1942 after the Beveridge report, which formed the bases of the welfare state on its aim to reduce poverty. In 1945 many polices were introduced, National Insurance and National Health Service are still prominent to this day.

  2. Compare & contrast the differences between the middle and peasant classes, village life and ...

    control over anything that had been her husband's beyond her modest personal income." Her own child would soon take over being the man of the house, "The completion of the boy's course at the public school, to be followed in due time by Oxford and ordination, has been all provisioned and arranged."

  1. It is the aim of this piece of work to investigate the claim that ...

    Becker appears to forget that people can also fight against labels. An example of such would be law abiding citizens not conforming to devious acts related to their particular area of abode e.g. the Hilltown in Dundee. Becker however succeeds in displaying that there is more to so called criminal types than initially described by the likes of (Lambroso,1876)

  2. In this section I will be comparing between the working class and the middle ...

    On the first floor there was a master bedroom, the bathroom and a nursery. In the attic lived the maid. This is because the Jones's were more important. Outside they had a privy that only the maid used and a coal shed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work