• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does Making Schools Compete For Pupils Bring More Benefit or Harm?

Extracts from this document...


Does Making Schools Compete For Pupils Bring More Benefit or Harm? I do not presume to answer the above question with a definitive answer but I will show you, the reader, a clear outline of the options and their possibilities and how the changes have progressed into today's educational system. The education reform act of 1988 set out to give parents the right to 'express a preference' to which school they felt it best to send their children. One implication that derived from the act was that schools were expected to take pupils up to a historically pre determined limit (their 1979 level of intake). This in turn brings to an end the catchment areas that had been the previous method of selection. A positive outcome that could come from the changes was that parents did not necessarily have to send their children to the nearest school. These choices were outlined to parents in the Parents Charter (DES 1991, DFE 1994) a copy of which went out to every household in Britain. Reasoning behind the charter was to work in tune with the consumer society we live in. One reason for this was as Sharon Gewirtz said in unit 3 some members of the government had "derided the comprehensive system from its 'dull conformity'" "'Real' choice, it was said, requires real diversity." It was felt that this was helped with the 1993 legislation that set up City Technology Colleges (CTCs) and grant-maintained (GM) ...read more.


Such a policy would presumably allow the school to produce better public examination results, by increasing the ability of its intake, but without actually improving its teaching.... A policy of improvement through selection of intake may make sense for a school in the market, but it is only cosmetic, not making any school more effective." Legislation seems to be offering the parents more choice and greater freedom in the education 'market' but the installation of performance league tables tells the parents the indicators that are important. The government still has ultimate control over the labelling of 'good' and 'bad' schools. They are in control of the criteria from which the performance is compared. Again, it is the affluent of society that can afford to move nearer to 'good' schools or to allow children that are accepted out of area to travel to them. Critics put forward the notion that the 'bad' schools would inevitably fail and possibly close, as all the better pupils would apply to the 'good' schools. This was outlined in the television programme A Hard Act to Follow which showed an area of Manchester where one secondary school had been very proficient in its marketing achievement and, as a direct result had been part of the cause that meant the opposite happening in a nearby school. Another factor is how the school is managed. "There is a strong interaction between values and management, for the choice of values will have important ramifications for the kinds of management adopted, just as the kind of management chosen will affect the implementation of those values held as most suitable or desirable." ...read more.


choices, there is little hope of getting your child into any of the schools you have chosen due to high population and low school places. This is true of the Weston area at present. I do realise the problem I have encountered is not nationwide however. In some areas, for example, they do have good example of parental choice and it has thrown up a very different perspective and argument. There seems to be a problem of "yuppie Land Rover brigade" of middle class parents ferrying their children miles to the best state schools it seems the teachers feel the rules for allocation are unfair and they want a return to the old system. Another objection raised was that league tables in England were potentially harmful due to the comparisons they illustrated. Brenda Wilson who is Head teacher of a primary school in Cambridge felt that parental choices meant unpopular schools could eventually become sink schools . All the arguments point to, in my opinion, a need for a middle ground between the two. Parents should have some say, teaching staff should have some say and most importantly of all the needs of the pupil should hold sway in the choices made. There needs to be an equality of provision that is not determined by league tables of sats results but of 'value added' learning. Perhaps if the government needs a league table then this is what it should be showing because only then will you have genuine guide to the best 'taught' schools and not just the school with the brightest students. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Assessment of Mill's 'Harm Principle'

    OBJECTIONS TO DEVLIN: (i) If a moral code is shared anyway by a very large majority of citizens then it is unnecessary to enforce it using the law, particularly as public disapproval of code-breakers will be in itself a strong deterrent.

  2. Gender advertising

    Adverts both depict new trends and accelerate them. Adverts also obliterate other trends. This raises the contentious question of the relationship between "reality" and "representation." A central debate among feminist media scholars concerns the "distortion" theme; that the media does not represent the "real" picture of women.

  1. Our Choice

    I gave up the opportunity for going into the athletic school. I gave up the interest that I have. For now, I regretted sometimes that I did not follow what I like. I regretted that I did not make the choice for myself.

  2. Free essay

    Independent schools are better than state schools

    As well as parents choosing to send their children to independent schools, some parents may choose to keep their children attending state schools; this is because they believe that there are disadvantages to independent schools. One such disadvantage of independent schools is that children do not learn to get on with others.

  1. Hypothesis: Children are born to succeed or fail

    The following is a table of results comparing the grades from pupils of different social backgrounds but of similar high ability. Upper Middle class Lower middle class Upper working class Lower working class %Gaining good GCE's 77 60 53 37 (Reference All Our future, 1968, J.W.B.Douglas)

  2. Should cosmetic surgery be freely available on the NHS?

    Rather than take self-esteem courses or go for counseling to help us learn to love those bits of our body that we don't like, we opt to go under the knife. We see many actresses and models in the papers, which undergo major breast enlargement surgery and are soon planning their next clinic visit.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work