• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does the research method of participant observation (P. O.) reveal more about the society observed or about the cultural preoccupations of the observer?

Extracts from this document...


Block 1: Observation Does the research method of participant observation (P. O.) reveal more about the society observed or about the cultural preoccupations of the observer? Introduction Within this report I will be looking at whether participant observation is a valid research method by looking at whether the results actually depict the reality. By doing this I will look at the replicability of the ethnography and also seeing if another researcher can get the same results. If replicating the results is difficult then factors such as the ethnicity, personality, age and sex of the researcher may have an affect on the results collected. By doing this I will look at Margaret Mead and Derek Freeman's work to demonstrate the differences in ethnographic interpretation. I will also use some ethnographic examples to demonstrate the usefulness of participant observation. I will first try to define what participant observation is, and following this I will give an example of participant observation using what we did in class and the exercise we took part in outside class. Participant observation seeks to find the real meaning and help to understanding the behavior of others. Participant observation aims to gain greater depth by being accepted by the participants he or she is observing and becoming not an outsider but "one of them" and blending into the "norm" participant observation involves the researcher to "become part of a daily round, learning languages and meanings, rules of impersonal, relations... ...read more.


This was a religious event completely new to me, which changed my preconceptions or stereotypes which are given to me by the media. When I first entered the mosque I was nervous and unsure but many people especially my participant put me at ease and introduced me to Muslim ritual in a very welcoming way. Before entering the mosque I thought that maybe my presence would upset or disturb some who pray but I got completely the opposite reaction. My participant was very enthusiastic about teaching me the Islamic way of life. It was very calm and peaceful place. We talked about mosques being places where terrorism evolved and she said that people like that who call themselves Muslims are not, and that Allah (their God) would not approve. She also said that she has never experiences anybody talking of terrorism in a mosque, and she also stated that many Muslims are very happy to teach the west of their beliefs and that they are not what the media projects. I realized that they were extremists, but not in the way painted by the media. They were extreme in a way they followed the Koran precisely in their everyday lives. My participant explained to me how she lives a very religious life and that everything she does revolves around whether it will be accepted by Allah in order to be a good person, and not the negative extremist I see through the media. ...read more.


Their difference in age, gender and personality may be just some of the reasons why such contrasting results were found. Maybe this is a good example to demonstrate that participant observation does in fact reveal more about the researcher's cultural pre occupations? Conclusion Throughout this report I have demonstrated that participant observation can both show the truth about a society for example by forming trusting relationships you can gain more in-depth and representative data using Peter Just work in the Dou Donggo. I have also shown that the cultural pre occupations can affect the observer's findings using Mead and Freeman's work Samoa. However a conclusion cannot be made. I believe that participant observation is one of the best ways of collecting data, which enables us to look back at our history and learn about different cultures. Although some say its from the individuals point of view. I think that it is far more effective that questionnaires, surveys or the artificial setting of the laboratory. Observing a culture in its natural setting, gaining good relationships with your subjects is a great way of collecting data. However I do not believe that this can be done by anyone, you must be experienced, patient and live the same way as them in every way possible to gain truthful results. For this report I carried out my first participant observation exercise and found it daunting but exiting. I realised the experience that is needed and found that the more time you spend with your subjects the more you learn about the particular culture. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Assess the usefulness of participant observation in sociological research

    And one by Barker on the Moonies and another by Lord Humphrey on homosexuality. The main advantages of participant observation are that it allows the observer to obtain a deeper and more experienced insight on the activities that the individuals of a society perform hopefully with a minimum of disturbance.


    They have many of the advantages of questioners. In addition to these advantages, an Interpretive social scientist sees than in interviews, words are clarified and researcher is less likely to impose his ideas. Also the researcher does not limit the responses to fixed choices and so new hypotheses and theories, which the researcher would have not originally thought of, may be produced.

  1. evaluation of methods

    live in UK or India, and I can find out the reason why they think this. 'How much importance is placed on weddings in India?' This question is necessary to my topic as it is possible for me to see from their experience how much importance a wedding is in India.

  2. McNeill, P (1990) Research Methods, Routledge, and Bryman, A (2001) Social Research Methods, Oxford ...

    is being written and also feeling comfortable and confident enough to carry on. It is liked that McNeill has made reading the book interactive by giving the reader a number of 'activities' to complete at the end of each chapter.

  1. Compare & contrast the differences between the middle and peasant classes, village life and ...

    In the Son's Veto, lower class people seem to care more about others than themselves. Sophy marries Mr. Twycott, her master, she does not really love this man but the reason she accepts his proposal is that she thought it would be an insult to reject him, "...Sophy did not

  2. Participant Observation.

    This therefore means by under-going participant observation you can achieve research of a high face validity whist also gaining the experience of that culture. On the other hand, there are the ethical issues facing Participant Observation. Is it right to invade some-ones privacy?

  1. Fashion: A Cultural Context

    Much of the late sixties was, for many spent in a haze of drug induced euphoria. The use of LSD was a powerful influence on ideas and dress. People experimented with their lifestyles in the belief that they were somehow on the road to a greater awareness and under standing,

  2. To attain an in depth knowledge of cultural diversity and commonality within the Vietnamese ...

    It is commonly believed that hasty words and slips of tongue are as devastating as hasty actions and bad deeds. Reserved, non-responsive and non assertive by Australian standards, this is particularly true with the behavior of Vietnamese children in school in which they rarely volunteer an answer for fear of being mistaken as trying to 'show off'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work