• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate Marxist explanations of deviance.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evaluate Marxist explanations of deviance (50 marks) Despite the fact that Karl Marx wrote very little about crime, the Marxist approach has been one of the most important approaches in explaining deviant behaviour. Marxists mainly base their ideas and theories upon how the ruling class control society. They say that the high rate of crime in western capitalist societies represents a protest against alienation and powerlessness. Capitalism is a competitive ideology; people are encouraged to become aggressive and hostile. In such a society, criminal behaviour is understandable. Steven Box argues for the Marxist approach to crime and control. Box agrees with more right wing writers in that it is release from social control that propels people into committing crime. However, his starting point is not that people are essentially bad, but that capitalist society controls and exploits workers for its own ends, or rather, for the benefit of the ruling class. When people are released on some way from the direct control, then they are much more likely to commit crime because they see the unfairness of the system. ...read more.

Middle

Young's study of 'Mass Media, Drugs and Deviance' argues that the mass media are always supportive of the status quo. Although united labour movements, such as trade unions, have gained the only concessions to working class people in legal rights, these come to be seen in a negative light. Strikers are portrayed as deviants. Young also noted a different level of social reaction to the use of drugs. 72 million tablets are used each year legally, but there is a widespread sense of disapproval about the use of certain drugs by teenagers etc. In 'The Drug Takers' he suggested that they come under police surveillance because those who reject the values of capitalist society are seen as a potential threat. The Marxists, Taylor, Walton and Young argue that capitalist society is characterised by great inequalities in wealth and power. Working-class youth commit crime because of their experience of these injustices. This can also be related to inequalities they found in the educational system. ...read more.

Conclusion

It is an overly deterministic view as it sees the law as operating solely for the benefit of the bourgeoisie and the focus is only on class, so it ignores other factors such as ethnicity. Marxists also support the information provided from the criminal statistics as it gives evidence to support their idea that working class people commit more crimes than middle class males. However, government statistics can be biased as not all crimes are reported, which means conclusions drawn from these statistics will have low validity. The theory also doesn't explain the presence of crime in socialist societies in which there is no private property and ownership of the means of production is communal. Nor does the theory easily explain the fact that there are middle-class offenders who are prosecuted. Functionalists criticise the Marxist idea that law is a reflection of the will of the powerful. Functionalists believe that law is a reflection of the will of people. Also, Left Functionalists such as Jock Young argue that most "Marxism" is little more than form of Functionalism that replaces the interests of "society" with "ruling class". ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Sociological Theory and Methodology - Crime and Deviance.

    Task 3 The Nature and Extent of Crime in Society. The Nature and extent of crime is documented by official statistics. These statistics are derived from two main sources of data. One of which is the amount of crime recorded by police, however, although it is possible to derive an

  2. Compare and contrast white collar crimes and street crimes, while understanding the definition of ...

    This cannot be anymore clear than the current happenings in Weirton Steel. The retirement fund is in government bailout, and the threat of closer is once again very real. When the simple outsider looks at what has gone on in Weirton Steel for the past 10years, it is difficult to put together a convincingly positive cost-benefit analysis.

  1. Critically evaluate the various sociological theories of crime and deviance including: Functionalist, Marxist, Labelling ...

    When particularly horrific crimes have been committed the shock and fear of members of society is mutual and so bonds them together, making the society stronger. Durkhiem acknowledges damaging effects of crime if it goes unchecked, but insists that crime is inevitable in any society.

  2. Critically evaluate Marxist approaches to crime and deviance.

    The positivist analysis in showing the correlation between crime and unemployment shows that as unemployment increases, so does crime along with it, therefore Bonger saw crime and deviance as a reaction to capitalist exploitation. These inherent contradictions such as unemployment, poverty and brutal working conditions are seen as a direct

  1. Gender advertising

    Not all those who can afford to will buy. But they can desire and aspire to possess them and thereby be like the new Indians the adverts project. A new normative Indian is being established. I find David Chaney's observation of interest where he tries to show how "the new

  2. statistical approaches to crime and deviance

    measure of the extent of victimisation and of National trends over time � Not affected by whether the public report crime or by changes to the way In which the police record crime POLICE RECORDED CRIME � Based on figures supplied by the police to the Home Office � Covers

  1. Critically Examine the Subcultural Approach to Crime and Deviance.

    such as hard work - were simply not sufficient enough to ensure that everyone could obtain the desirable goals they were socialised to want. In this respect, whilst American society placed a high social value upon "success" in all its forms, the means to gaining legitimate success were effectively closed

  2. Outline and evaluate Marxist theories of crime.

    In order to force the Africans to work colonial rulers put in place a tax which could only be paid by working on the plantations for wages. Non-payment of the tax was punished and the wages of the workers was kept low as a higher pay would have enabled the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work