• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine the different ways in which the writers of your 2 texts have presented the role of women in the societies in which the women live.

Extracts from this document...


Examine the different ways in which the writers of your 2 texts have presented the role of women in the societies in which the women live. In this novel we see many the role of women transcendent from one class to another and some of the roles are still adhered to in today's world. Women during the Victorian era were usually associated with modesty, reputation, as well as pride and elegance for the middle/higher class women. From a 21st century perspective, such associations may seem rather far fetched, however it can be questioned to what extent the role of women in societies has changed. Considering the current ongoing topic of women in society, perhaps this is one of many aspects which has altered very slightly over the centuries. In the two novels there are many roles women take, differentiating with class and position. One of these is the role of work. Work greatly varied between the lower and upper class and 'ladies' in the upper class societies occupied themselves with needless 'work' such as sketching, evident in 'North and South' we see Margaret fretting over cottages which have been 'reproaching me for ...read more.


Unlike Margaret her mother is not as strong, and is not looked up to for advice and help which Margaret and Louisa often are. In the household Margaret seems to be the main caregiver excluding Dixon. Carrying on with the subjects of home, working class women who were able to work did not spend much of their time at home. If they were able to they would work to help support the family and would spend much of their lives in the factories working alongside some of their family members, which is the case with Mr Higgins and his daughter. Even though Rachel is alone in Hard Times she is still forced upon work to survive. In an upper/middle class society women were mostly at home, such as in Louisa's case who follows an inhibited lifestyle. In North and South Gaskell presents a more charitable and outgoing woman who, in Milton and Helstone regularly visits the poor to bring baskets. Being the daughter of a clergyman this was not frowned upon or seen as unusual as her charitable work was supported by her family, as well as her religion. ...read more.


This shows the importance of women and their role for being pure and untouched in the Victorian era, and this is brought out much in Gaskells novel where as in Dickens it is not entirely present. Gender relations are also present in both novels and we see many relationships between men and women of both classes. The role of father daughter both Louisa and Margaret are taken under and Margaret is supportive of her father where as even though Louisa accepts the marriage proposal brought upon her by her father she is not entirely satisfied in her relationship with her father. Mr Thornton has a similar sort of relationship with her mother who is her sons support and caregiver, and even though Thornton is presented as a strong independent gentleman he still requires the comfort of her mother and this is the role her mother takes on. As we can see in both novels women play a very important role in the societies in which they live in and their roles of caregivers is more present in the upper class societies than in lower class where the women spend their time working and contributing to the family financially. Mohsin Sharif - 1 - ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Free essay

    The changinf role of women in society

    women getting the vote in 1910 as its reflects a wider range of people's attitudes, also you can sense there maybe some unreliable facts used in source D, which in turn makes source E more reliable.

  2. Discuss the concept of 'Double Colonization'; how do postcolonial women writers contest both patriarchy ...

    For the Brahmin upper caste women the alignment was temporary. With the onset of middle age, the woman attained power. She no longer had to work as hard. She would exercise considerable power over the new generation of women. Patriarchy thus operated through far more complicated trajectories with criss-crossings of power lines.

  1. Compare & contrast the differences between the middle and peasant classes, village life and ...

    Sophy loves and wishes to wed a man named Sam Hobson, who is a lower class grocer; Randolph, however is totally against the marriage because of their social differences. When Sam proposes Sophy answers "...Sam, if I could, I would marry you some day."

  2. Discuss the relationship between literacy, orality and sacred texts with particular reference to South ...

    She argued further that context-dependent speech is tied up with context-dependent thought, which is the opposite of abstract thought. Other studies include Bernstein's (1971) studies of working-class children in Britain, who, he concluded, showed signs of 'verbal deprivation'. When presented with a picture of an event, they would refer to

  1. Has the restructuring of gender relations and employment led to a restructuring of European ...

    Mostly they were channelled into the lower end of a 'dual labour market' in which there is lower pay, work conditions, entitlements, and security. This theory helps to account for much of the gender segregation and pay differentials, but fails to recognise that many women have been gradually entering, succeeding

  2. A Disgrace to Canadian Women

    All Leah is concerned with is her right to buy "wicked shoes" and her right to "get drunk". Feminists generally do not apologize to all men for being unappreciative, they do not endorse mindless stereotypes, and they do not disparage the poor.

  1. Compare the ways in which crime is presented in Moll Flanders and Roxana?Assess how ...

    domestic duties, instead they distance themselves from the morals of society and beautify their lives by either using men or stealing valuable objects to fulfil their needs. The novels are written in an autobiographical format, where the protagonist gives a chronological sequence of events in their life.

  2. Why were Witches women?

    Within Exodus 22:18 it orders, "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live". It is then this mixture of Church and theological backing that gave the people of Europe the authority to act upon the 'witches' within society, and to destroy anyone suspected of witchcraft.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work