• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Have Social Democratic governments had to limit their ambitions to being mere managers of capitalism?

Extracts from this document...


Have Social Democratic governments had to limit their ambitions to being mere managers of capitalism? Before any political party could come to power as a 'social democratic' government the idea of social democracy had to be developed first. The unfolding of social democratic thought and doctrine that had to happen before the idea could be brought into government is an important pointer toward how these budding 'workers' parties' would act in any future position of rule. I will argue that the policies and practices of social democratic governments can be foreseen from their electoral tactics that were modified from their original purpose into one which would enable the party to be elected. I will also argue that once the history of social democracy in power began, it's various guises throughout western Europe could only hope to be mere interventionist, reformist managers of the capitalist world that they inherited. Firstly, what does social democracy mean? What policies did social democratic parties pursue? What electoral measures did they take to attempt to win the majority vote that would allow them to enter government? And what signs could we see at this stage that would give us an idea of the nature and role of any future social democratic ruling party? Briefly, social democracy developed due to a split in the socialist parties and their following. ...read more.


Thirdly, the acceptance and almost embracement of capitalist institutions such as the electoral process and the apparatus of the state. Lastly, but equally as important as the former points, was the fact that at the time of social democratic parties coming to power they were doing so in a western Europe that already was rooted and embedded in a capitalist structure of society. " Socialists had to govern in an essentially capitalist world." (Schumpeter 2000, p 364). All four of these factors point toward how social democratic rulers would rule. They all demonstrate a weakening of socialist ideals in the face of capitalism, through it's institutions, it's supporters, and the very fact that it was already cemented into the machinations of the economy, trade, markets and the social institutions and communities of western Europe. The means of pursuing power would be reflected in the ends of power. A reformist, interventionist party in opposition would be a reformist, interventionist party in government. The first time we can see this is in the coalition governments of Sweden and Norway of the 1930s. To be able to have a say in the governance of their respective countries, the social democratic parties had to deal and barter with their opponents in order to gain at least some footing in the ruling coalitions. Although this is not an example of outright, majority social democratic government, it reinforces the four pre-emptive factors of the nature this type of government would take. ...read more.


"The fundamental premise of social democracy is that nationalisation of the means of production is not necessary to overcome the irrationality of capitalism." (Przeworski 1992, p 132). Social democracy's apotheosis in the late 60s and early 70s still made no decisive change to the organisation of wealth and capital. For a political party to gain power through the ballot box it must win a majority of the vote. To do this, the majority of the electorate must be catered for in the policies of a party. In a society that is already predominately made up of capitalists, especially the more entrepreneurial middle-class, a victorious party will only be a reflection of this society. Thus, we see the eternal dilemma of social democracy - capitalism must be paid lip service to gain power in an already capitalist society. By doing this, the ends of social democracy change to ones of capitalist management, reform and intervention. In today's increasingly globalised economy social democratic governments can be seen as having to shift their policies and their practices even further toward a capitalist approach. As the seemingly only eternal principle of governments is to remain in power, all other principles become secondary. Throughout the history of social democracy capitalism has, at best, merely been diluted. From origins of socialism by revolution, through socialism by democracy, to reformist and interventionist governments, the future of social democracy can be predicted as one that finds itself forced to try and limit how far capitalism manages social democratic governments rather then the other way round. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Abolishing the Electoral College

    II. Plan - Our plan is to have the U.S. Government abolish the Electoral College as it stands. A. The most democratic and beneficial way to count votes for the Presidential Race is to amend the Constitution and establish rules that allow the popular vote of Americans to chose the President and Vice-President.

  2. Does Boxing have a future?

    lower socio-economic backgrounds it opens up many new possibilities for successful participants. The route from poverty is a key motivating factor. Cashmore 1996, has viewed the historical participation of sport in Britain as a culture where participation is/was dominated by white people, however, he sees the participation in boxing as the breaking of (the)

  1. What Civil Society Can Do to Develop Democracy

    - Do public associations presently support the work of the government at national and local levels? How? - What role do public associations play in providing public information? - Do any public policies make it difficult for public associations to communicate information?

  2. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    There have been three rationally satisfactory answers to questions about the basis of the incongruity between destiny and merit: Karma, dualism (from Zoroastrianism) and the predestination decree of the deus abscondidus (the absconded god; kind of a cool phrase). These solutions are rationally closed, and are found in pure form only as exceptions.


    As for long term care for older people, in 2000 the government produced the NHS plan nursing care provided free (paid by taxation) and personal care which is not. In addition, National Service Framework for Older People 2001 was outlined building upon more positive treatment in policy of later life,

  2. Environmental Lessons From History.

    Johnstone (1998) writes that a change of land use also affected the populations of the Lowlands of Scotland, England, the German states of Pomerania and Brandenburg, Denmark, Catalonia in Spain and the Low Countries. So perhaps the Scots and in particular the Highlanders are wrong to blame the English for the change in land use, as it was inevitable.

  1. The Hidden Curriculum; Hegemony and Capitalism.

    What is important about what students learn in school is not primarily the 'overt' curriculum of subjects like French and Biology, but values and beliefs such as conformity, knowing one's place, waiting one's turn, competitiveness, individual worth and obedience and respect of authority.

  2. Who Voted Nazi and Why?

    Those who did vote would have been in far smaller numbers than the farmers simply because there are so few rich people compared to poor working class farmers. Also people would only change parties in large numbers if they had good reason.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work