• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Historical Interpretation of Economic-Social Change

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

ASSIGNMENT 3 Historical Interpretation of Economic-Social Change The problem when looking at historical interpretations of economic-social change is that it is very difficult for the historian to comment without any of his or her personal political bias, it is for this reason that both sides of the standard of living debate must be looked at side by side. Historians commenting on the standard of living debate can be classified into two categories, the 'pessimists' who believe that the conditions for the working classes deteriorated, and the 'optimists' who hold the view that conditions improved with industrialisation. Historians when writing about the standard of living debate, attempt to explain the winners and losers of industrialisation by their own interpretation of evidence, as the study of the English working class has always been a politically biased subject. A pessimistic observer of Industrial Manchester was Friedrich Engels who wrote The Condition of the Working Class in England in 1844. This primary source is valuable, as Engels' father owned the factory in Manchester, which Engels had been sent to manage. Engels therefore had real experience of life in the city and his father's factory, and wrote with a social conscience. ...read more.

Middle

Clapham argues that welfare estimates are based on the earning of the principal breadwinner and that the Industrial revolution "provided opportunities for relatively considerable family earnings" (J.H. Clapham (1938) An Economic History of Britain). There is little reliable data that can be used to in evidence in the standard of living debate; birth and death rates are inaccurate as not all were registered. When using food consumption and diet statistics to debate the standard of living, R.M.Hartwell another optimistic historian uses wheat and bread prices as an argument for optimism as the prices fell after 1815 and were then relatively stable, he says that this suggests no long term shortage of wheat and flour. On the other hand though E.J.Hobsbawn a pessimist believes that wheat production and imports did not keep pace with population growth, illustrating the lack of firm evidence when debating the standard of living. Hartwell states that the wealth and opportunities created by industrialisation should not be ignored, and that there are misconceptions about agricultural life before the industrial revolution. He also notes that child labour was not a new concept and warns about "the myth of the golden age", when looking at the standard of living debate. ...read more.

Conclusion

He published Hard Times in 1854 and in this novel, comments on the conditions of the working class in an industrialised town. He illustrates the unfairness of the factory system, the hard working labourers who are little rewarded for their efforts whilst the factory manager lives in the lap of luxury. Whilst Elliot looks back at an earlier time of close knit village life contrasted with the new industrial town, Dickens uses his writing for a moral and social purpose. Elizabeth Gaskell published North and South, which is set in Industrial Manchester shortly after the publication of Hard Times. Unlike Elliot Gaskell recognises the ugliness of industrialisation but also recognises that in the agricultural village of Helstone, the inevitable changes that time has brought to the village force the reader to recognise that the unchanging idyllic memory of the village is reminiscence and not a reality in which people live. As with the novels written around the time of the Industrial Revolution, historical interpretations cannot be separated from the political viewpoint of the writer. Both sides of the debate, for their own cause, can interpret statistics used as evidence with a different approach. It is impossible for a writer to comment without his or her personal bias, experience or social background influencing their work. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. The cannabis debate

    It could also be seen that legalisation would be ethical as it would be moral and virtuous to prescribe cannabis as a medication rather than making medicinal users criminals. A more modern term is Neo-Aristotelianism, which says that virtue does indeed lead to happiness, but does not have the same conception of the character that exemplifies virtue.

  2. Assess the nature-nurture debate in relation to genders

    Freud's theory implies that rigid sex-typing even stereotyping is universally inevitable and unmodifiable. Whereas social learning theorist's treat the child as the passive recipient of environmental forces, society, parents, peers and the media all influence the child. Ruble (1987), argues that social learning theories are not able to account for

  1. The Emergence of the Working Class through The Industrial Revolution, 1750-1914, in Europe, UK ...

    Also the joy of seeing something one produced lovingly from scratch has now been lost and production line workers are unable to identify with the item they are producing and thus the factor of job satisfaction is reduced and replaced with an exploited, alienated workforce.

  2. Primary Sources and Social Change in the industrial revolution

    and but in the factory system workers were ruled by the dictates of the machinery and the factory owners. We can look at a primary source which shows the working hours and conditions for a child in a factory in the late 1700's.

  1. COMPARATIVE SOCIAL WELFARE

    Welfare in Sweden is an integrated part of public policies, which the state provides benefits and services for citizens outwith the market, unlike in the UK. Sweden as a Social Democratic State (Epsing Anderson)

  2. The Cherry Orchard is pessimistic in its analysis of social transition.

    Yasha ask someone else to run the errand for him, but he was also offended, asking "what's the use of asking ten times" (Chekhov, 42). He fails to understand that, as a servant, it is his duty to do what he is told without question - he reacts to Anya in a way that is not expected of a servant.

  1. Environmental Lessons From History.

    Two intertwined serpents are also portrayed one with an open mouth, probably blowing incense, above which are twin ears of maize. These symbols and designs have been interpreted as the serpent (symbol of rain) making an offering to the rain god (Lothrope 1924)

  2. Prostitution: Prohibit or Legalize? Both Sides of the Debate

    to an expensive restaurant, and spending an impressive amount of money, in return for which, he will hope for some kind of sexual reciprocity. Such payment is not required on the part of the second party, and should she not consent to sex, he could not demand it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work