How does the social context effect the questions and results of the scientific enterprise?

Authors Avatar

Sabrina Siddiqui        Theory of Knowledge        May 12, 2003

        

How does the social context effect the questions and results of the scientific enterprise?

        Social context has quite a significant effect on the questions and results of the scientific enterprise. This is because scientific research has always been largely affected by society, as it is society that often controls what is researched in science. A lot of what is researched depends on what people want to know, and what they believe in. There have often been restraints on what is researched due to social factors such as religion, government, and even the general public.

        One factor that has always had a large effect on the questions and results of the scientific enterprise is religion. Throughout history, there has always been an ongoing conflict between religion and science. Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution, for example, came into direct conflict with several religions, namely those of Christianity and Islam. This was, of course, because of the challenge Darwin’s theory of evolution proposed to the Creation stories in both religions. Scientists tend to disagree with the Tower of Babel story in the Biblical book of Genesis that describes precisely how humanity abandoned a single language and separated into many different cultures, consisting of various languages – this disagreement has, in the past, angered the conservative wing of Christianity. There are many similar disagreements between science and religion, but the cause of such disagreements remains somewhat the same. Science revolves around the study of nature, its processes, forces, and development. Most importantly, however, it is based on the analysis of evidence and assumes that processes and events happen due to natural causes, and not through divine intervention. Religion, on the other hand, deals with matters of faith. The majority of the faith groups believe in the existence of one or more deities who created the universe and continue to play a crucial role in managing it, often doing so by bypassing the laws of nature in order to create miracles. Such vast differences between the faiths of religions as opposed to the teachings of sciences have often put a strain on scientific research, and continue to do so even today. One such example of the past would be the role of the Church in Italy – because the Church, at a certain time period, had a large effect on what Italian society was exposed to, scientific research would often be censored to fit the teachings of the Church. Any research that would challenge the teachings of the Church would be banned. Even today, there are many countries where scientific research is kept at a reserved level due to religion. This particularly occurs in countries that are deeply affected by religious organizations. There are many areas in which modern scientific research is not even allowed if it will challenge the religious beliefs of the region – usually these regions are largely populated or controlled by religious extremist organizations.

Join now!

        Politics and the government also affect the kind of research carried out by the scientific enterprise. In countries that are still running under some sort of authoritarian/dictatorial regime, society is kept hidden from much of the scientific research that takes place. This way, the dictatorship in question can maintain its authority over the public. Even non-dictatorial governments have a significant effect on scientific research. The government’s permission is usually required when carrying out and publicizing the scientific research that is currently taking place. The government often bans research that it feels can harm the public or is too ‘revolutionary’. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay