• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Far Do These Sources help us understand whether Chartism was a Social, Political, or Economic Movement?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How Far Do These Sources help us understand weather Chartism was a Social, Political, or Economic Movement? By Joe Wreford. I am aiming to find out how far these sources help to understand what kind of movement Chartism was. I will be deciding if it was social, political, or economic. To do this I will be analysing each source in turn. J.R Stephens wrote the first source (Source A) in September 1838. From looking at this source I could see that he believes that Chartism was an economic movement that had some social meaning. I can see that it is economic because Stephens writes. "As much wages for that work as would keep him in plenty." This is saying that money is very important for every man. Even tough Stephens was middle-class he still wanted the working class to be cared for. He also writes. "Every working man." This is suggesting that the working classes are part of society. ...read more.

Middle

This shows a social and economic view to the chartist movement. Cole's evidence comes from Stephens and Gammage. He also wrote this source in 1941. As it was written during wartime his views may have altered. This may explain why he is more concerned with humanity. He was not an eyewitness as he wrote this source around one hundred years after the events. This all means that the source is not very reliable. In source D Briggs says that Chartism was a movement made up of local grievances put together to give them national expression. The source shows a mixture of social, economic and political ideas. Briggs mentions the "Onset of business depression." This is suggesting an economic motivation from the chartists. As there were economic difficulties for the working class at that time. The sources reliability has to be questioned as it was written over one hundred years after the chartist movement ended. ...read more.

Conclusion

this would lead me to believe that the arguments are both valid. Source G again written by Dorothy Thompson talks about an socio-economic movement. According to Thompson chartist stemmed from lower society needing a movement that would allow them to have a fair part of the economy. This source is in agreement with sources E and F about the social reasons for the movement. Even tough it was written in 1984 it could still be seen as a good source as it is linked in with sources E and F. From looking at the evidence in sources A to G I believe that chartist was a complicated movement with many aspects to its beginning. The sources were mainly social with strong political and economic parts to it. From the arguments given by Gammage in source B I believe that the movement was political but was done to solve the social problems. The economy also plays an important part. In source C G.D.H.Cole writes that the social problems were started by the bad economy for the working class. My final decision is that chartist was a social movement. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Analyze how Far From Heaven employ mechanisms of cinematic identification.

    Raymond and the maid are mostly in their working uniforms or tacky clothes which reinforces their role in society. Raymond is not in control of his identity. He is reduced to a black man whom everyone knows as Cathy's gardener.

  2. Evaluate the Significance of Socilogy To Understand Social Work Practice.

    Marxism is based on the ideas of Karl Marx. It is a perspective that is based on a class system, split into two categories, the worker, which he called the proletariat, and the bosses, or employers as the bourgeoisie. He called the bourgeoisie the ruling class.

  1. Suffrage movement during the progressive era.

    - Prentice, Bourne, Cuthbert Brandt, Light, Mitchinson, Black They were unable to hold even some of the most unwanted jobs such as janitors and delivery persons.

  2. Disucss the conention that weak leadership, rather than any economic or political factor was ...

    effects of that belief were, to slap the loyalty of the working men, to make them dislike the country of their birth, to broad over their wrongs, to cherish feelings of revenge, and to hate the rich of the land" 1 Samuel Kydd was in no means wrong with his

  1. 'How far do these sources support the historian Vincent Crimon's view that the witches ...

    The language it uses is slightly hard to understand but keeps on referring to the witch as "she" and so it can be argued that the author is assuming that all witches are female. Source F is an illustration depicting the Devil being paid homage to by his loyal followers, one of them by kissing him on the buttocks.

  2. Outline Weber's account of hierarchical authority. In what ways does it help us to ...

    Every night the father came home from work and the family sat around the dinner table together talking about their days and the latest news. The father would then go read the newspaper, while the wife cleaned up dinner, and the children did their homework.

  1. How far do the main protagonists in Girl, Interrupted and Prozac Nation attribute their ...

    hospital as her own personal protest, "My ambition was to negate" Sleeping when she should be awake, silent when she should be speaking, she is really rebelling against a society that committed her to an institution because she was different.

  2. The Origins of Chartism.

    Appeared as an extension of government interface without any gains for the workers. E) Introduction of police forces in the localities. Which many workers regarded as part of the government policy of repression. F) Collapse of the Grand National Consolidated Trades Unions (1834.)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work