• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How successful was Durkheim in using the "Scientific method". In hindsight would you have conducted research on suicide in a different way?

Extracts from this document...


How successful was Durkheim in using the "Scientific method". In hindsight would you have conducted research on suicide in a different way? In this essay I will discuss some of the approaches to the study of suicide and its social causes described by Durkheim. I will then present a few alternative theories or critiques of Durkheim; and finally conclude with a Personal reflection on Durkheim`s analysis. Durkheim believed that society is a part of nature, and a science of society has to be based upon the same logical principles as those which obtain in natural science. Therefore Durkheim set out to prove that sociology was a science by applying his theory to the study of suicide. The study of suicide is seen as particularly important because it illustrates the wider theoretical and methodological debates in sociology. The study of suicide, by Durkheim was based on using statistics from several countries and looked for causes of suicide. This illustrates the positive approach. Later studies such as those by Atkinson and Douglas use interpretative and phenomenological approaches, which question the value of statistics and the idea of causes and try instead to understand how meanings are attached to actions. ...read more.


(O'Donnell, Page 315) Gibbs and Martin (1964) argued that, since Durkheim gave no clear definition of social integration, it was not possible to operationalise this idea. As an alternative, they proposed using the idea of 'status integration', in order to measure the extent to which an individual's different social statuses overlapped. The less the overlap between an individual's different statuses, the greater the likelihood of role conflict and, in this respect, there was less likelihood of support for an individual in times of social crisis/social dislocation. As an example of this idea, a man who has been married for a number of years before his wife suddenly dies is also confronted by a social crisis. His life may appear to lose it's meaning and the norms by which he has lived his life over a number of years suddenly become almost irrelevant and mundane. In this situation, such a person could be seen as being 'at risk' of committing suicide due to the anomic changes. For Gibbs and Martin, the greater the level of social support he is able to get from his other statuses in life he less he is to actually commit suicide. ...read more.


Some people do not want to die - they may be making a cry of help - while others gamble with their lives, taking a considerable risk but not knowing whether they mean to die or not (Taylor calls this 'Parasuicide'). The study of suicide then needs to be expanded to include risk taking, and understanding this requires looking at both meanings to individuals and the wider social structure. Taylor has also been associated with the argument that Durkheim's work, in seeing underlying forces guiding but not determining individual behaviour, is in fact more realist than positivist. The theoretical methodological issues raised by Durkheim's pioneering work remain unresolved. In conclusion, the research undertook by Durkheim was statistical and taken at face value he did not explore the reasons why suicide had taken place although he discussed some social factors his viewpoint may be seen to be bias. This view could be taken because Durkheim himself was a Catholic when he was discussing the role of values and morality within Catholicism as being superior. On the other hand Durkheim's approach has been useful in that other sociologists can learn from his methodology and the drawbacks in it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. A-Level Sociology Theory + Methods Revision.

    week of March 1946 --> tracked through the 16 years of their education --> compulsory education and IQ tests. Key Adv = Whereas other methods provide a "snap shot" of what is happening, longitudinal studies monitor social change. Disadv = Panel Conditioning - effect on people taking part.

  2. Write about the different sociological perspectives and different theories on suicide, family, and health ...

    I believe personally that family is important to get you through day to day activities, I feel that if I didn't have my family for love and support then I would feel weakly connected to society, this could lead to depression or suicide.

  1. In what way have contemporary philosophers and sociologists of science challenged the view that ...

    Not the proximity to the truth that explains the dominance of a system of knowledge but the methods its supporters use to promote it. His argument represented a major assault on the foundations upon which modernist theorising has been built, insisting that dominant paradigms exercise power and sustain dominance as 'dogma'.

  2. The following essay will use the ideas of Durkheim to construct my social biography ...

    To Emile Durkheim, the world's first official Sociologist, society is a complex structure in which each separate part is responsible for its own function for the benefit of the whole. According to Durkheim, society comes in two forms: internal and external.

  1. Should Sociology Be Scientific?

    to become working class, or being working class causes a person to commit crime. One problem with this part of the positivist scientific methodology is that some correlations found by researchers may just be by chance or indirect. This can happen where two social facts are found together but in actual fact don't have any direct connections to each other.

  2. Positivism: "Love, Order, Progress" - Auguste Comte (1795 - 1857) and Emile Durkheim (1858 ...

    There is no doubt that the nineteenth century in Europe was and was experienced as a particularly turbulent time, as turbulent and dramatic as the seventeenth century which had so unsettled and stimulated Thomas Hobbes. Very simply we can see two sorts of responses to these crises.

  1. Critically assess the concepts used by Emile Durkheim in his analysis of the social ...

    Thus, Durkheim believes that society stands apart from its members when being analysed. Furthermore, Durkheim tried to explain the social fact by seeking out its origin and the ingredients indispensable to its continual existence. He believes that 'The determining cause of a social fact should be sought among the social

  2. Philosophies of Social Science.

    But, finally, it needs to be stressed that the 'should' and the 'how' varieties of individualism cannot really be kept entirely separate.4 Hence, we find in the work of Hayek this example of 'how' methodological individualism: 'There is no other way toward an understanding of social phenomena but through our

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work