• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Madness An Individual Attribute Or A Process Of Social Construction?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is Madness An Individual Attribute Or A Process Of Social Construction? Madness is a largely contentious issue for a variety of reasons, comprising of operational discrepancies and its implications for wider society. In a very rudimentary sense madness implies a state of insanity beyond the control or will of the person considered to be mad. This however presupposes the existence of madness as tangible or concrete phenomena and dismisses the possibility that 'madness' may simply be the product or expression of alternate truths or different expressions of reality. In other words one may question whether the behaviour of the individual is abnormal enough to be located outside the realm of normal human functioning and whether the reason behind this is truly 'madness'? These questions are ultimately philosophical and ultimately unanswerable. But asking such questions does not entirely unrewarding, since it is our societal understand which informs our treatment of the mad. Principal to this essay is an understanding of social representations of madness, which comprise of notions what is assumed to be normal within a society, wherein lies the danger of relegating the experiences of the mentally ill as abnormal and something to be rejected. Subsequently, in order to establish whether madness is an individual attribute or social construction, it is important to try to analyse the various differences in representations/ allocations of madness across time and across different perspectives. This essay will provide an insight into the problematic nature of madness, by assessing the contribution of psychiatrists and psychologists, against the criticisms and allegations of 'de-humanization' made against them by social constructionists such as Foucault and Goffman, in order to locate the origins of madness. Moscovici originally developed the 'social representations' theory to provide an understanding of the fluid processes through which historically and culturally specific beliefs, knowledge and practices develop and circulate. It describes how through conversation, practices and the media we as individuals and communities make sense of the world. ...read more.

Middle

It has been suggested that the clinical asylum/ institutionalisation is the birthplace of insanity as we understand it today, however it seems that this argument is far too simplistic and at times fatalistic, in that there are no distinctions made between types of madness, the active role of the 'patient' is not really considered and neither is there an appreciation of the possibilities in variation in psychiatric treatment which can offered. As a result this theory falls into the same trap of the stereotyped social representation of mental illness. This highlights an important consideration for the entirety of the essay, in that all researchers carry with them into their own work social representations of madness. Furthermore, all theorists appear to present a kind of causal relationship between merely 'odd' behaviour which may transgress beyond social norms, and the illegitimate labelling and subsequent treatment offered by psychiatrists at the expense of truly assessing some of the undeniable achievements psychiatrists have accomplished. Indeed there have been many disease in the past, like epilepsy, where it was unknown what caused them, however by arguing that all mental illnesses are social constructs, one is limiting the explanatory confines behind such behaviour. Moreover, there is considerable evidence, which suggests that organic diseases can affect cognition and mental diseases can affect bodily functioning. Furthermore, it seems that the premise of the critique readily condemns the role of psychiatrists in treating 'odd' behaviour without in certain circumstances the permission of the 'labelled' patient, and as a result infringing upon one's civil liberty. However if psychiatry were only to operate entirely voluntary places, this would give birth to a number of ethical considerations. For instance, in sensitive matters whereby the 'patient's sense of reality may be impaired, is it justifiable to intervene at the gain of saving one's life? Social constructionists may argue that there is no real identifiable 'mental illness' however if the patient is somehow driven to drastic measures, surely one must recognize that there is a problem, which needs to be addressed. ...read more.

Conclusion

This point is further validated by the fact that the DSMMD documented 106 mental illnesses in 1980 and this increased rapidly to 300 in 2000. This account shows a highly sensitive and at times ironic view of psychiatry, which is not necessarily compatible with certain criticisms made against it. In answering the question of whether madness is an individual attribute or process of social construction, we can essentially say tat it is both. In abstract terms, there really cannot be any such entity as 'madness' since all experience is subjective, and no-one individual can proclaim which experiences are valid and which are not. It is however reasonable to argue that before the emergence of society, given man in isolation, madness could not exist- this is of course due to its relative and interdependent nature. However, with the birth of society and the necessity to order things around us, the representation of madness is reified and come to exist as reality, and whilst it is more fluid/ dynamic than many of the other categories we create such as gender, it is not something which can be ignored. On the other hand, it is crucial to recognize the growing body of evidence which suggests that some mental illnesses can be attributed to biological defects in the brain, which I would argue can become more or less pronounced depending wider society's representation of madness. Critiques of mental healthcare, such s that of Foucalt, are specific to time and perhaps slightly outdated. The fact is that mental health practioners actually hold more positive representations of the mentally ill and it is they who are entering into the dialogue Foucault argued for. Additionally, it is the mental health practioners who appear to be deconstructing the traditional confines pf what constitutes and what 'ought' to constitute 'normal' behaviour. Undoubtedly, there is a greater level of understanding to be reached in this area, and for the most part it is the lay representations of the mentally ill, that prevent these individuals from becoming the valid and recognized members of a society that they deserve to be. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. The essay will begin by looking at what normality and social construction is and ...

    Language is a powerful means of construction; it is one of the most influential ways in which we gain knowledge. Language changes over time, not only in the way it is spoken but the words that are used. Historically words used to describe individuals with disabilities have been, spastic, dunce, moron, cripple, handicapped and lame.

  2. Comparisions of Emma and Clueless Conventions - Social Contexts

    Can be ungracious at times. Mr Elton - Has outwardly all the traits of a gentleman, a very agreeable man, good manners but not a strong personality. Tries too hard to be agreeable and well liked esp. by women, shallow A clergyman Good humored, cheerful, obliging and gentle.

  1. Homophobia: a Definition

    Since the functional target of homophobia is not specifically homosexuals, but the entire body of males, it must demand that real homosexuals remain invisible--since valid knowledge about real homosexuals would undermine the functional benefits of homophobia to men in general.

  2. How far is the gangster genre a creation of the necessity to promote civic ...

    This idea of promoting conformity can easily be observed when looking at Romantic Comedies such as, "Two Weeks Notice" in this film both of the main protagonists work in legitimate businesses which benefit society, and as such they are rewarded with money, love and good looks.

  1. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    If God presents to His elect a change for profit, he must pursue it: the Christian must follow the call by taking advantage of the opportunity. The acquisition of wealth in the performance of a calling is morally permissible and enjoined. -- Asceticism turned against the spontaneous enjoyment of life.

  2. "Judgements about dialects are often essentially judgements about the speakers of those dialects. Discuss."

    the traits of respective dialects, though these views are based not on linguistic merit - rather its emulation of the 'received' or 'standardised' variety of the language (the most revered British dialect utilised by various official establishments such as Government and the BBC).

  1. In the light of the teachings of the Qur'an discuss the moral and ethical ...

    In Quran (25:63) "And the servants of the Beneficent Allah are they who walk on the earth in humbleness, and when the ignorant address them, they say: Peace." 5. ISLAM......A POLITE & PEACEFUL RELIGION: Throughout Quran we find teachings of Peace, teachings about doing well to others and to talk politely with others.

  2. Discuss the extent to which public and social policies have impacted upon the theory ...

    there was an increasing sense of alienation within the community. This was because as Marx argued, increased capitalism was taking stock of peoples lives forcing people from the same communities to fight for jobs compete for bonuses and promotions within the work place which had a direct effect upon the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work