• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Marx, Durkhiem and Weber had a distinctive perception of the development of society from pre-modern to modernity, the problems

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Marx, Durkhiem and Weber had a distinctive perception of the development of society from pre-modern to modernity, the problems that would be faced and their predictions as to the future. Outline and evaluate these differing perspectives. 1,495 words. 1,521 inc. references. Sociological perspective has benefited from Marx, Durkhiem and Weber's theories, regarding human nature and the development of their societies. Each one had their differing characteristics. Marx saw class conflict and Capitalism central to his theory, whereas Durkhiem concentrated on Industrialism and the division of labour and Weber rationalization and bureaucracy. Marx had three major features in his analysis, mainly how goods and services are organized; the conflicts which arise and how it motivates change from one system to another. Although Auguste Comte established sociology and some of the original disciplines Emile Durkhiem is responsible for turning the subject into a more academic discipline. One of Durkhiems main principles was to consider 'facts as things' and his 'Organismic analogy' idea maintains that societies are like living organisms. He believed that the only way one can analyze the complete picture, is to look at all the parts and its contribution. ...read more.

Middle

The study also highlighted that one social group was more likely than another to commit suicide so the suicide rate was not a reliable answer. In his rules of sociological method he emphasized the importance of social facts by distinguishing between their causes and their social functions. He believed that "the study of any social fact's functions must be different from the study of its causes". Central to Durkhiems work is morality which also represents a 'social fact'; to understand how social order can be achieved Durkhiem assumes that morality helps to regulate societies. As morality is external to individuals as well as constraining it serves two purposes. Social order is threatened when individual's constantly demand more of everything; therefore it can never be satisfied. Morality helps to restrict these desires. He believed that social order, solidarity, and happiness could only be achieved if individuals adhered to the same shared morality, this was termed as the 'conscience collective'. In Durkhiems first work "The division of labour in society" he explains how societies have changed, from smaller communities where the population would have been largely the small illiterate type, to larger more complicated industrial types. ...read more.

Conclusion

The workers {Proletariat} do not own the means of production therefore are exploited by selling their labour power, and it is this situation which causes the most tensions and conflicts. Marx believed that the end of capitalism would come, because profit seeking would always be unstable, the division between rich and poor would produce too many tensions and a revolution would follow, which would lead to a classless society. Marx relied too much on historical events and put to much importance on external factors carving out people's destinies in a definite way; instead individuals have freedom of choice to alter their own destinies. The economic issues surrounding the superstructure of ideas and culture do not fully explain the modern cultural conflicts of gender, nationalism and ethnicity. The prediction of a more polarized division of class, central to Marx's theory has developed into a middle class emerging instead, with everyone enjoying a higher standard of living, with the acceptance of capitalism. Instead of a false ideology at work, society enjoys more civil liberties, material progress and stronger democracies than most other systems. Sociology in Focus. Paul Taylor et. al. Causeway Press Ltd. Pg 33-34. Pg 657-660. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 Student number. 0465802/1 Assignment number. SOB 2019 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. A-Level Sociology Theory + Methods Revision.

    Yet Germany has one of the highest rates - is this dependant on German nationality. In Bavaria the rate is lower (a Catholic are substantiates the importance of variable of Religion. I.V.'s = Age, Religion, Marital Status, Gender, Nationality D.V.'s = Suicide Rate Disadv = Available data may not make it possible to isolate variables precisely i.e.

  2. Response to Fritjof Capra's "The Turning Point"

    Things can only get so small. Science will never stop. What else can it do but start looking at the big stuff? Okay, we zoomed in; now let's zoom out. Capra's critique of the biomedical model is a pleasure to read.

  1. Compare and contrast two of the perspectives - Marx & Weber

    These ranks are formed from the struggle for economic resources as well as prestige and political power. He believed that people should compete to gain advantage of these resources and that each class is defined by the resources or rewards that they receive.

  2. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    ''Power, as well as honor, may be guaranteed by the legal order, but... [the legal order] is not their primary source. The legal order is rather an additional factor that enhances the chance to hold power or honor; but it cannot always secure them'' (926-7).

  1. Assess the Impact of the Development of the Railways On Victorian Society and the ...

    Although railways provided an additional method of transport, for most of the century they appeared to run along side the existing systems. They did reduce the number of trips being made by profitable long distance road haulage, as goods travelling long distances overland could be moved much cheaper on the railways.

  2. Marx, Weber and Durkheim have significantly advanced our understanding of industrial capitalist societies. ...

    In other words, he would explain that people's values, ambitions and ideas are related directly to their economic position, i.e. their function in capitalist society. Marx found that "conflict between economic groups is the major engine of change" (Macionis & Plummer, p.79).

  1. The development of Spartan society.

    council played a relatively inconspicuous part.'7 The democratic assembly or 'ekklesia' as Plutarch alludes to, was the 'major organ of the Spartan state (for) every full citizen over the age of thirty had the right to its membership.'8 Such allowances possibly broadened the scope and dynamics of political involvement within the Spartiate community.

  2. Max Weber (1864 - 1920)

    The Exploding Cinema collective is clearly in the language camp and keeps itself distanced from state 'media'. The point is that for Exploding Cinema to be understood as part of this area of 'language' it needs to be seen as part of oral culture rather than the literary culture of formal written discourse.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work