• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"People who do well at school are just more intelligent then people who do less well." Why are sociologists critical of this view?

Extracts from this document...


"People who do well at school are just more intelligent then people who do less well." Why are sociologists critical of this view? Many sociologists argue that there are many more factors that play a big part other then school. Intelligence is measured by intelligence tests which gives an individual's intelligence quotient or know as IQ. Many researchers argue that IQ tests are biased in favour of the middle class. There is an agreement that intelligence is due to both genetic and environmental factors. Environmental influences everything from diet to social class from housing. It is estimated that between 60% and 80% of intelligence is genetically based, this is why many sociologists are critical of this view. Identical twins raised in different environments show they have different IQ scores. Since the twins are genetically identical, it can be argued that the different IQ scores are caused by environments. "Working class culture leads working class children into underachievement" To what extent does evidence support this view? ...read more.


of a child's ability. Bad behaviour, for example, is taken to be indicative of a poor home background which is taken, in turn to be indicative of low ability. Working-class children are less successful in the education system. Sociologists have explained this by the facts that, the home background is often not as helpful for educational success as that of the middle class; the neighbourhood may also weaken the chances of the working-class child; and what happens inside the school, particularly the actions of the teachers and the peer group, can help the middle-class child and harm the working-class child. Hyman ("The Value Systems of Different Classes", 1967), argues that the value system of the working classes acts as a barrier to their educational advancement, in terms of the way they place a lower value on: * Educational success * High occupational status * Opportunities for personal advancement through education Despite the evidence put forward by the above witnesses, there is also a large number of contrary interpretations based mainly around the idea that the concept of class sub-cultures takes it ...read more.


Rather, children who succeed are those, regardless of their objective class background, whose parents socialise them into the norms and values of middle class life. Approaches were concerned to expose class differences in attitudes towards education. Working class attitudes were seen as a 'deficit system'. Douglas (1964) argued that working class parents offer less encouragement and support towards their children's education The effect of studies like that of Douglas was to 'blame the victim'; working class culture was seen as problematic. One result was the idea that certain students needed 'compensatory education' and gave rise to Educational Priority Areas as a result of the Plowden Report of 1967. In the USA there was a similar scheme called 'Operation Headstart'. "Sociology is the objective study of human behaviour in so far as it is affected by the fact that people live in groups". Sugarman ("Sociology", 1968) Sugarman claimed that many middle-class occupations provide an opportunity for continuous advancement in income and status. This encouraged planning for the future: for example, the investment of time, energy and money in training to meet requirements of higher-status jobs. (Aneil Patel) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Is working class underachievement better explained by factors inside or outside the school?

    Sugarman argues that the attitude of working classes has already been established and is a fixed part of their subculture. This attitude has been enhanced from their schooldays. Sugarman states that for these reasons, pupils from a working class background are placed at a disadvantage immediately within the educational system.

  2. To what extent do sociologists argue that the family is beneficial to society?

    Functionalists see the family as of equal benefit to all, where as Marxists feel that society is shaped by the capitalist economy's needs. Talcott Parsons does not consider the diversity of family types and the variations in society such as class, ethnicity and religion.

  1. In what way have contemporary philosophers and sociologists of science challenged the view that ...

    The significant factor here is that much of the same evidence was used to support the hypothesis of global warming that was used in support of global cooling. Interpretive sociologists believe that humans try to make sense of the world and act in light of their interpretations, this obviously includes the interpretations of scientists.

  2. Young people, class and gender

    1819 saw the introduction of the factory act that steadily controlled child labour. From 1841 to 1914 (the beginning of World War 1) a woman working was seen as a threat to men. The Mines Act which banned women from working in the mines (1852)

  1. To what extent do sociologists agree that different levels of educational attainment are affected ...

    Also, it will even include nutrition, for there is some evidence to suggest that severe malnutrition within the first few years can affect the development of the brain. Therefore, the differences between the environmental factors which affect the working class and middle class mean that they will seem to have a different level of intelligence.


    Most commonly identified classes are that of the upper class, middle class and working class, the latter with the least amount of income and wealth, and the former the most. Some sociologists and social theorists in recent years have also argued that capitalist societies (most evidently Britain and the USA)

  1. Some sociologists even speak of an 'educational revolution'

    Indeed, education became the most important channel of social mobility - and lack of education became thus the recipe for social exclusion. In many countries a social movement was born, a coalition of trade unions, students' organisations, political parties and others, to 'democratise' higher education, i.e.

  2. This critical assessment of the Canada's justice system it is important

    Now that it has been established that crime goes hand in hand with poverty, next those who are poor in Canada must be identified. Canadians take pride in being a multi-cultural nation, but are all races truly equal in the justice system?

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work