• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Plato's "The Republic" Critically discuss the simile of the cave in relation to the role of the philosopher

Extracts from this document...


Philosophy Plato's "The Republic" Critically discuss the simile of the cave in relation to the role of the philosopher ruler. In the simile of the cave We are asked to picture a group of people sitting inside a dark cave, their hands and feet are bound in such a way that they can only look at the back wall of the cave. Behind the chained prisoners a fire is burning, and between them and this fire a path runs along which men carry figures, the shadows of these figures are projected onto the back wall of the cave. The prisoners experience is based solely on the shadows, which form their world. They have been sitting in this position since they were born so they believe that all they can see is all that there is. Within this illustration one of the prisoners is set free and confronted with the real world and the sun, a painful experience. At first he cannot see anything due to the bright sunlight, but after a while, for the first time in his life, he sees colours and shapes. One point that Plato is making in this simile is the relationship between the darkness of the cave and the world beyond, corresponding to the relationship between the empirical world and the world of ideas and forms. ...read more.


Therefore the person who has accessed true understanding of the form of good will be unwilling to involve himself in everyday life and those members of society who have not understood truth. Yet these are the people Plato sees fit to rule. In order to rule the philosopher rulers must take part in everyday life. There seems to be a problem with the willingness of the philosophers for the lack of it may mean they are unfit after all. However Plato says these individuals are obliged to do so, even though, as part of their character trait they would love philosophy and wish to persue it above the ruling of the society, the philosophers will be educated to know this his duty. Relating to this point Plato emphasises the need for the philosophers above any other members of society to rule, for he suggests that if ruling is assigned to those who want to rule, then this will not be a success and bad government will be the result, power and position will become the objective and not the good of the society. Therefore Plato says that the philosophers' unwillingness will be an advantage to the governing of the society, as the good of the society will be the only objective for which they are concerned within this job role as rulers. ...read more.


Throughout the republic Plato considers the philosopher rulers to be social hierarchy, however given the previous discussion, it would appear not to be the case in reality, for usually we would consider someone's social ranking dependent on the view of the majority. When analysing Plato's the republic, particularly his ideal state, the immense difficulties in creating a flawlessly run society come to light, for it is not easily done. His simile of the cave attracts a great deal of critics because of its problems when applied to society, but because it is an analogy of the way in which Plato views society it does not appear to work well. Plato does not take account of human nature, One cannot ignore this; in order for the philosopher rulers to govern as Plato wished, the people of the society must be the equivalent of robotic. In reality, people, particularly in the 21st century are extremely individualistic, opinionated, and possessive by nature, it is human nature to label. It is implausible to believe that strict early education can change this. However that is not to say that philosophers would not make good rulers, perhaps the knowledge philosophers have can help politics, even in the 21st century. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Port Sunlight

    Bounded by a tidal inlet which flowed to the river on one side and the main Birkenhead/London railway line on the other. It was far from being what is now termed, 'prime building material' - some of the land being marshy and crossed by ravines which would need to be filled in.

  2. Assess the nature-nurture debate in relation to genders

    importance in Freud's theory of sexual development whereby the child must identify with the same sex parent. Thus, the process of forming a gender identity and becoming sex typed, begins with the child's discovery of the genital differences between the sexes and ends with the child identification with the same sex parent.

  1. Determining the Elite within Politics and the Judiciary.

    By examining the substance of decisions, they can control the powers given to ministers and authorities by Parliamentary acts, and where EU law is concerned they can even alter rules created by Parliament (Budge et al 2001 p498). In recent years, the political elite has extended the supervisory and decision-making powers of the courts into new areas.

  2. Why did Plato think women could be legitimate political guardians?

    As mentioned above Plato believed that every person had a place within his society, and this of course had to include women, they too had their own role to fulfill within Plato's Republic and it wasn't just to breed for future generations, although they were obviously used for this as well.

  1. Plato and the Republic.

    A timocratic person is, therefore, someone who is more concerned with defending an idea of honor and obligation than looking at all other alternatives and truly choosing what is best. Even more disastrous is a democratic government. This type of government promises equality for all of its citizens by allowing

  2. Juxtaposing the Dark and Light.

    here is able to make Hester the very goddess of love, similar to the flood of sunshine which now pours into the forest is another outer manifestation of the same inner divinity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work