• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The debate between essentialism and social construction.

Extracts from this document...


Rosa Luis Dugan Soc 208/GLB 9-26-03 The debate between essentialism and social construction is a very complicated one. Since both essentialists and social constructionists have different perspectives on matters, in order to be able to decide whether or not there was a presence of homosexual persons over time and place certain aspects have to be taken into consideration. Such as, was it biologically inherited, was it brought about with a preference on acts and desires or overtime influenced by religion, culture, beliefs, social norms, and acceptance has a define answer is a tough decision to make. Essentialists are stereotypical; they choose to have a set definition of a homosexual, whereas a social constructionist would have variations in their idea of what makes a homosexual. A social constructionist would disagree with whether the presence of homosexual persons over time and place have a set thought as to homosexuality was biologically inherited because they would feel that, that would be limiting the thought of other aspects influencing homosexuality. ...read more.


They are also treated differently in every aspect because of different influences such as births and weddings. Hijras are a religious group of men who dress and act like women either because they are men who are bisexual and gay, or because when they were young boys they were castrated because of religious beliefs. The Hijras that were castrated when the where young boys are neither men nor women and cannot reproduce so they are viewed as powerful, able to curse those who disrespect them, yet outsiders in their contribution to this India society. Considering gay, lesbian and bisexual lives are not accepted in this culture, would it be reasonable to say that these men who started this religious belief where gay or bisexual men are looking for a way to express there emotions in this non accepting society? This would be a social constructionist view because over time actions and desires have changed in this society because acceptance, beliefs, culture, etc have become more accepting and understanding of the true meaning behind this religious belief. ...read more.


Ancient Greece provides another example of how there has always been a presence of homosexuality with an influence from culture. There was presence of homosexuality then and still is today but it has been influenced throughout time by culture, acceptance, social norms etc..., because over time religion, cultures, etc have become more important and more needed for order to place people by the essentialists (Vance). Social constructionist views are more acceptable to differences and variations form the social norms of order and judging. They have shown that there has been a presence of a homosexual person over time and place but not just one type of homosexual person variations of unique homosexual persons. Social constructionism proves that there is not just one way to be but many ways and many categories we can all fit in not judging upon sexual orientation. Works Citied * Liahna Gordon E. and Abbott, Sharon A., The Social Constructionist's "Essential" guide to Sex * Nanda, Serena, The Hijras of India * Vance, Carlos S., "Social Construction Theory: Problems in the History of Sexuality" * Class discussion Tuesday September 23, 2003 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. The essay will begin by looking at what normality and social construction is and ...

    In this view, the 'problem' is not the disabled person, but the lack of appropriate goods and services. This approach is most often stated as seeing the category of disability as a social construct, explained with reference to medical and political agendas and emphasising the historical development of instituitional discriminatory practice ( Finkelstein, 1981).

  2. The Corporate Social Responsibility Debate

    CSR requires organisations to broaden their profit-maximising focus, incorporating financial, ecological and societal responsibility into their core business strategies, thus applying the concept of 'the triple bottom line' [Holliday, Schmidheiny &Watts, 2002]. Good reputation and positive brand image are important assets to a business.

  1. Assess the nature-nurture debate in relation to genders

    The basis of division of labour is clearly laid down in childhood. Women are expected to be physically weaker, emotional and have motherly instincts and not to have strong sexual drives. Whereas men are stronger, less emotional more aggressive as I mentioned earlier and have powerful sexual drives.

  2. Homophobia: a Definition

    She notes that lesbianism and feminism are both about women loving and supporting women and women revolting against male domination and patriarchal institutions that control women. She refers to the political theory that embodies and defines the connection between lesbianism and feminism as the key to understanding how to combat the oppression of women (and homosexuals, both male and female)

  1. Sociology of Sexuality - Lesbian Mothers

    Nevertheless, the political culture does effect lesbian parents in so far as it denies the non-biological mother any legal relations to her child. Non-biological parents who wish to be legally acknowledged as a mother must formally adopt the child. However the process for lesbian and gay parents to adopt is extremely difficult and is met with much legal negativity.

  2. What makes debate surrounding masculinity so contentious?

    This will be discussed further. What does it mean to be masculine, according to Patricia Sexton in "The Feminized Male"; "It is holding male values and following male behavioral norms" She further states that evidence suggest that male norms stress values such as "courage, inner direction, a considerable amount of toughness in mind and body" amongst others.

  1. "The 'social constructionism versus essentialism' debate cannot be avoided when we study gender and ...

    P.7). In medieval times, there was only one 'sex', as they believed there were two kinds of people, but one simply held their reproductive organs externally, and one internally. This is an indication that gender, the identity associated with sex, has been socially constructed, as in historical societies, it was not present.

  2. Who won their debate - Miliband or Poulantzas?

    In different contexts, individualism is contrasted to holism and collectivism. Metaphysical individualism claims that social objects like societies can be reduced to individuals. Methodological individualism does not make metaphysical claims, but it is the doctrine that all sociological explanations are reducible to the characteristics of the individuals.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work