• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Medieval era is so easily generalized into the three orders of those who fight, those who work, and those who pray, or even simply divided into the privileged and unprivileged.

Extracts from this document...


Ann McMillin History 27 Barbara Harris 1 November 2001 The Medieval era is so easily generalized into the three orders of those who fight, those who work, and those who pray, or even simply divided into the privileged and unprivileged. These distinctions are important, for the ability of the church and manor to influence a peasant's actions and to take a peasant's earnings was obviously a central component of a peasant's life. However, when peasants constituted such a sizable majority of the population (over 90 percent), it is also important to recognize the distinctions among them. Some peasants were free and some were serfs. Some peasants were well off and some were barely subsisting. Some peasants held manorial offices and some did not. Some peasant women lost their identity behind a husband and others maintained it by never marrying. In this sense, Judith M. Bennett's portrayal of peasant life in A Medieval Life: Cecilia Penifader of Brigstock, c. 1295-1344 is a nuanced perspective. She not only analyzes the affect of the powerful institutions of church and manor on peasants, but she also recognizes that they were affected differently depending on their position within peasant society. ...read more.


Along the same lines, Cecilia's other actions or inactions can easily be misinterpreted without knowing her motivations. As stated earlier, peasants are often placed into one huge group because they are so economically and socially different from the clerical and manorial elite. The basis of this social stratification could be that all peasants are subject to the influence of the manorial lords and ladies and church clergy and must abide by their courts, taxes, and other customs. Bennett recognizes the power and influence of the manor and parish over the peasantry. "Well off within her community, Cecilia was just another peasant to the many different sorts of people who sought to profit from her life and labor," she writes (41). Cecilia, like all other peasants, had to pay rents and other taxes and had to complete her obligatory labor for the demesne. She also had to follow the customs and laws established by the manor and enforced by the manorial court, like all peasants. The church also influenced peasants equally in the sense that it influenced their beliefs, which in turn influenced their behavior. Peasants attended the rituals on various holy days throughout the year. ...read more.


However, marriage gave women "social approval and support; greater economic security; full independence from their parents; and the protection of husbands more publicly powerful than they," (125) and in this sense, it was a desirable position. When observing the variations based on economic welfare, social status, and gender in peasant society, it becomes harder to view peasants in one group. Although they were all part of a working class, their lives differed in considerable ways. Prior to reading Bennett's book, I was victim to stereotyping peasant society in medieval England into an uneducated mob, toiling under the hardships of a feudal hierarchy. Bennett's detailed description of the life of Cecilia Penifader and the village of Brigstock show that each peasant had a life of their own, complete with personal successes and failures. She provides more nuance than the traditional medieval historian, who often focuses on the monarch or church. While still emphasizing the significant control that the aristocratic elite and Catholic Church had on the peasantry, Bennett succeeds in describing how peasants could control their own lives through their relationships with kin and community. Cecilia Penifader might not be the average peasant, and Brigstock might not have been the average village, but by recognizing their distinctiveness Judith Bennett has shown me medieval society in an entirely new light. 1 McMillin ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Comparison between 'Woman Work' and 'Overheard in County Sligo'

    She thinks she ought to feel a happy woman because in society's eyes she has the idyllic and perfect life; she is a married woman, with a large house, and is rich. At the start of the poem, the woman in Overheard in County Sligo' mentioned living at the back of beyond.

  2. ‘Gender Identity is not simply a matter of biology’

    Many sociologists support this position, but not all. Some believe it is 'natural' for men and women to act differently, this is supported by many scientists, some psychologists and sociologists. Some scientists believe male and female s behave differently and perform different social roles through their differences between hormones and brain activity.

  1. Determining the Elite within Politics and the Judiciary.

    (Budge et al 2001 p667) Yet for the most part, Labour has accepted much of the Thatcherite agenda. It has not returned to nationalisation or to the previous level of spending on public services, education and housing, nor has it re-established its close political alliance with the unions.

  2. Theory and Practice of Work with Young People

    The need to 'improve' and 'socialise' young people has continued to be a recurring theme throughout the 20th century within government policy. The Education Act of 1918 gave Local Education Authorities the power to spend money on the 'social training of young people' (Smith, 1988:34).

  1. Compare & contrast the differences between the middle and peasant classes, village life and ...

    side to the story about how lower class people are strong believers. This also shows that Mr. Twycott really cares for Sophy, as marrying someone from a lower class is like, "Social suicide." Sophy and Mr. Twycott move to London where people would not know of their sin, Mr.

  2. How was Martin Luther's Message Misinterpreted, and what was the Significance of the Peasants ...

    Luther's Theology was well received by the peasants because it was interpreted to mean that serfdom was contrary to the freedom of Christians. For example his central belief of Solafide, and the stress he laid on the bible and not on traditional church institutions was gladly interpreted to mean that

  1. Systems of Sociology Theory based in the French Revolution era when Napoleon was defeated ...

    - Morality of highly specialized societies are reflected in these laws - The stronghold of religion is severely weakened and the concept of conscience collective becomes an abstraction. It is replaced by HUMANISM. * Humanism focuses on individualization but it is not based on selfish self interest but on mutual respect for others since each benefits from the other.

  2. The Three States of Matter.

    Using the particle model to explain the properties of a Solid * Solids have the greatest density ('heaviest') because the particles are closest together. * Solids cannot flow freely like gases or liquids because the particles are strongly held in fixed positions.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work