• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The novel is important to the history of women's search for a public voice" (Jane Spencer): Discuss this statement in relation to two of the texts you have studied so far on the unit.

Extracts from this document...


"The novel is important to the history of women's search for a public voice" (Jane Spencer): Discuss this statement in relation to two of the texts you have studied so far on the unit. Shell Woodward The aim of this essay is to discover whether the 18th century novel aided women of that period onwards with their search for a public voice as stated by Jane Spencer. I plan to do this by looking at two of the most influential novels to be written in this period that have women as their main characters. The novels I will look at in depth are Daniel Defoe's Moll Flanders and Samuel Richardson's Pamela. I chose these two novels for many reasons but the main ones being that both the heroines are unique and quiet remarkable, particularly for this context. And the fact that men created them. My intentions when choosing to study male authors is to discover whether their idea of the female voice differs to that of a woman's idea of the voice she would like to be made public. I hope to gain an understanding as to whether Defoe and Richardson created realistic characters or simply characters that depicted how men believed women should be perceived. Realism is one of the main conventions of the newly emerged 18th century novel. The form grew from a desire to break away from other prose genres that had been previously popular, particularly the Romance. The Romance genre was made up of many distinguishable characteristics such as the use of elaborate language and far-off settings that depicted themes like impossible love and quests. The characters were usually knights and princesses so it is safe to say that this form had a great lack of probability and this is mainly where romances and novels differ. Historicists believe that the novel emerged due to the cultural and historical changes that occurred in this period. One of the main factors was the introduction of new technology for printing and distribution. ...read more.


For someone who is supposed to be looking back at her life and reflecting on her struggles before she repented her tone through flippant discourse does not reflect this. And you must remember that Defoe's journalism skills enabled him to report realism rather than create fiction. Through Moll Defoe has created a strong feminine voice that shows no shame in claiming that it is society that has made her behave the way she did. "There is no moral discovery to be made in Moll Flanders for all the moral talk", (Arnold Kettle, page 53, An introduction to the English novel). By using the first person narrative in this picaresque novel it is left to the reader to decide whether it is Moll or Defoe's opinion but either way a feminine public voice has been heard through using the novel as a medium. From this I agree with Jane Spencer that the novel was important to the history of a woman's search for a public voice. Richardson also created a powerful feminine voice from a low class status but his character, Pamela, differed hugely from that of Moll, just as Richardson differed from Defoe. But yet like Moll, Pamela was unique and outspoken. Richardson decided to use the epistolary form for his novel and this gave the reader an insight into Pamela's innermost thoughts and feelings. For me this makes Pamela less credible than Moll. This is mainly due to the fact that she is so restrictive on her thoughts. She makes her character appear perfect but as we know humans are flawed, and showing your flaws helps one human relate to one another and this is why Moll appears to be more realistic than Pamela. Richardson followed the tradition of the conduct book and seems to have created the 'perfect' example of how a woman should behave. What makes Pamela unique though is the fact that she believes herself to be equal to the higher classes. ...read more.


Moll sees material gain as a means of survival. The more she has the more she craves, thus making her into an accomplished thief. This could also be Defoe's way of sniping at society about women's struggles as well-paid women's jobs were few and far between and many had no alternative but to steal for survival. I do not believe Defoe was condoning this activity but rather showing society that improvements needed to be made for women's rights in order to create better options for women. Through this it is plain to see just how good the novel was for voicing a woman's perspective. In conclusion I agree with Jane Spencer's statement that the novel is important to the history of a woman's public voice. By looking at two very different novels that portray women I have shown how their voices and issues have been made public. The most interesting factor I have discovered is how Daniel Defoe thought for women's rights. It could easily be said that he was one of the pioneering feminists and to be honest I did not expect to discover this in an 18th century successful male. Richardson, on the other hand, seemed to me to be trying to please all the classes. He created the perfect roll model for conduct but along the way he managed to feed hope to the underdogs by creating such a powerful identity belonging to a servant girl. By doing this both Authors have aided women in their struggle and thrown into their society many issues for debate. It was a very good start for women and through an unusual source, one of prose fiction. My findings also show that the female voices that these men created were quite realistic. Defoe's was the most realistic as Moll said things as they were whereas Pamela seemed more interested in protecting her image and Richardson seemed more interested in preaching conduct but nevertheless both authors had created believable characters within the novel genre. Shell Woodward 2,519 words excluding extracts and quotations ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Approaches to History: Sociology and History

    Sociology then is co-extensive with modern industrial society. Just when modern societies emerge so too does sociology. Sociology is the scientific study of human social activity. In the effort to study human social activity sociologists break it down into objects of analysis.

  2. "Age is a social construct". How far do you agree with this statement?

    The body will decline, involves decrease in muscle tone, reflexes, physical strength and energy. There is also the slow lose of vision, hearing, and other senses; fertility and potency; baldness, hair colour, and the smoothness of skin and the efficiency of the immune system..

  1. "The 'social constructionism versus essentialism' debate cannot be avoided when we study gender and ...

    Sara Delamont identified that hospitals also keep pink and blue blankets for girl and boy children respectively, again reinforcing their gender identity label. This then continues through child hood, one only needs to browse a children's clothing section in shops to notice that the girls' section has pretty, brightly coloured

  2. Consider how the portrayal of the female characters in "Hobson's Choice" relates to the ...

    They do not do very much work. Instead, Vickey spends her work time reading and Alice spends it knitting. They also arrange for their boyfriends, Albert Prosser and Freddie Beenstock, to come into the shop and meet with them. As with Maggie, they are not paid, they get their keep, and they also get clothing.

  1. Ray Bradbury's novel Fahrenheit 451 - review

    Montag accepts this world without question, never stopping to think that there might be more to life than his job and the various entertainment that society feeds him (McKey) The use of symbols in the text is another powerful technique.

  2. Assess the nature-nurture debate in relation to genders

    Bleier (1984) refers to studies, which show that rhesus mothers treat their offspring from an early age according to their sex. The behaviour of the monkeys could therefore have resulted from them being treated as males because of their appearance.

  1. Peggy Orenstein's Schoolgirls: Young Women, Self-Esteem and the Confidence Gap - review

    She maintains a strong sense of personal a familial importance and feels that her loyalty lies at home, in taking care of her mother and her siblings. Although she is very bright and very capable of succeeding, school becomes less and less important to her since it is an obstacle to her survival and to the well-being of her family.

  2. Wider Reading - Cider with Rosie and Cranford.

    those times the women had to wait to be asked by the man. In the chapter 'A love affair of long ago' we hear of Miss Pole's cousin Mr. Holbrook who offered to Miss Matty long ago. From then on the whole chapter revolves around the ladies gossiping about why Miss Matty did not accept his offer.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work