• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12

This essay proposes to discuss different accounts of the welfare state by both mainstream theorists and the main tenants of feminist thought using examples to help the understanding of gender relations in the welfare state to become a more clear issue.

Extracts from this document...


This essay proposes to discuss different accounts of the welfare state by both mainstream theorists and the main tenants of feminist thought using examples to help the understanding of gender relations in the welfare state to become a more clear issue. In order to understand how feminism contributes to understanding gender relations in the welfare state it must first be clearly defined what the welfare state and gender are. Gender is defined as something that draws our attention to the social construction of differences between men and women. (Lecture (2) 30-1-02) This essay attempts to discover what exactly the welfare state is and how gender relations are portrayed. Esping-Anderson's (1990) theory of stratification of welfare states incorporated with T.H Marshall's (1950) theory on citizenship and social class will provide the basis for feminist thought which in turn will criticise mainstream theories for lack of material on gender relations and differences in the welfare state. Marshalls theory will be criticized by socialist feminists like Pascall for not including reproductive rights in his defintion of social rights and feminists such as Mc Laughlin and Glendinning (1994) will criticise Esping-Anderson's theory of de-comodification and parallel it with their theory of de-familisation. Esping-Anderson's theory will also come under attack from Lewis (1992), who paralled Esping-Anderson's study of de-commodification with breadwinner links. Examples of gender relations in the welfare state will primarily be Mc Laughlin and Glendinnings work on informal care were Titmuss (1950) is criticised by theorists such as Ungerson (1987) for his lack of understanding of gender issues in relation to community care. Another prime example of gender issues in the welfare state will be taken account of by Zoe Irving's (2001) work on male part-time workers, (taking into account future issues such as low pensions and poverty for women) backed up, by recent figures from the Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC) of Northern Ireland. One well-known study of what the welfare state is and how it works lies in the hands of Gosta-Esping-Anderson (1990). ...read more.


Titmuss in his essay 'Community Care! Fact or Fiction?' (1968) did not refer at all to informal carers or to women. He had an image of community care as, " ..........a sense of warmth and human kindness, essentially personal and comforting." (Titmuss, 1968: 104) It was feminist contributions such as the latter, which enable us to see who and what is involved in community care and the gender issues relating to the welfare state which comply with it. Finch and Groves (1977) argue that policies for community care were, within a context of public expenditure cuts, and were fundamentally incompatible with policies for equal opportunities for women. They claimed that in practice community care equals care by the family, and in practice care by the family equals care by women. (Ungerson, 1987: 494) Because of feminist contributions and increased knowledge of community care the Equal Opportunities Commission commissioned a study of carers and for the first time a serious effort had been made to plot the incidence of caring and to discover the sex ratio. The results found, " Out of the 116 carers, 87 (75%) were women and 29 (25%) were men." (Equal Opportunities Commission, 1982b, 3) The 'Equal Opportunities Commission' then published a set of recommendations for the support of carers, in terms of services, financial benefits and employment rights. The Equal Opportunities Commission also stated, " The carers visible to government statistics are married men aged less than 64 years old caring for their disabled wives and single people caring for infirm parents. Carers are only visible to policy makers when they receive some kind of state benefit, yet many welfare benefits exclude married women...." (Equal Opportunities Commission, 1982b: 3) From this came Nissel and Bonnerjea's study (1982). The purpose of this study was to examine the extent to which caring functions of the family operate as a constraint on women's participation in the community on an equal footing with men's. ...read more.


(Pages 1-2) She claims policies should allow women to be either home-centred, adaptive or work-centred and that policies should support lifestyles and diversity. (Lecture (8) 20-2-02) Hakim and feminist's like her have all given a good contribution on gender relations in the welfare state, Hakim has taken a step further and suggests through preference theory how things should be. In Conclusion there have been a lot of different impact from different strands of feminism in an attempt to understand gender relations in the welfare state. This feminist thought has mainly come in retaliation to mainstream theories such as Esping-Anderson (1990) and Marshall (1950), who according to theorists such as Pascall and Mc Laughlin and Glendinning (1994), have not been sufficient in their arguments as they have failed to study gender differences/inequalities between men and women with relation to welfare state. Policies inefficiencies such as community care, lack of child care facilities, unpaid informal care, low pensions for low contributors which are primarily women in part-time employment and many other issues have been brought to light by feminist research. Feminists in their criticisms of mainstream theorists and the welfare state have given an invaluable contribution to understanding gender relations in the welfare state, which otherwise would not have been known. The feminist perspective has enabled us to see that gender relations in the welfare state are riddled with inequalities with women being at the heart of the disadvantage. Because of feminist movements like those mentioned so far, the inequality in gender relations has been realised and to a certain extent addressed by policies implemented, such as the Human Rights Legislation in Northern Ireland that affirms, " The right to equal opportunities in all social and economic activity, regardless of class, creed, disability, gender or ethnicity." (Good Friday Agreement, 1998: 314) Other changes made have been the new 'Statutory Equality Commission' and the incorporation of the 'European Commission of Human Rights' into Northern Ireland law. (Good Friday Agreement, 1998: 314-315) The following website also tells us that changes have been made to the 'Fair Employment Commission', regarding gender issues also. (http://www.caj.org.uk/key/docs/FairEmploymentflier.htm ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Assess the contribution of functionalism to our understanding of the family.

    4 star(s)

    Carby have criticised white feminists for failing to consider the significance of racism alongside patriarchy as a form of domination.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    outline and evaluate feminist contributions to our understanding of gender

    4 star(s)

    Feminists also introduced different methods in carrying out sociological research. Previously sociological research was very 'malestream' and all research was done by male sociologists, on men and applied to society as a whole. No research had been done on the family, childbirth, household labour or money decisions which are all major parts of society.

  1. Machiavelli's Theory Of The State.

    Vitelli who called off the attack the Florentines called Vitelli a traitor and he was executed and as a result Machiavelli believed that mercenary troops should not be trusted and that all states should be self sufficient and protected by their own army.

  2. Assess The Feminist View That Conventional Malestream Theories Are Inadequate For An Understanding Of ...

    Male crime is often more violent. Therefore, women's crime is largely ignored because it is seen as no real social threat. In addition, official figures show a marked difference between male and female crime. Because women's crime figures are significantly lower than men's they are often ignored.

  1. Examine the extent to which T H Marshall's concept of citizenship has relevance for ...

    In addition, Marshall's initial three classes of rights have been supplemented by Turner (1993) with three more, all of which accentuate the "social" element of Marshall's analysis. Firstly, Turner puts forward the idea of welfare rights, which go beyond Marshall's notion of a modicum of economic welfare and security; Turner

  2. How Can Crime Be Related To Social Inequality? Discuss In Relation To Inequalities of ...

    Another thesis is related to opportunity. Women are reaching social positions similar to men, and it is suggested that their criminality will reach the same levels, with the nature of their criminality being relative to their social position. However, women do not have the same opportunities as men due to the metaphorical "glass ceiling".

  1. Sociology Essay - The History of Welfare and the Problem of Poverty in England.

    At the beginning of the 19th century Britain was suffering from high food prices and low wages due to wars in France. Furthermore many people believed that new farm machinery were taking away their jobs, this resulted in the swing riots in the 1820's and early 1830's.

  2. "The 'social constructionism versus essentialism' debate cannot be avoided when we study gender and ...

    Freud has one of the most well-known arguments for social constructionism, claiming that, as humans are born prematurely, compared to most other animals, heterosexuality is not programmed into them and this is largely a role of the society they live in.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work