• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using the factual accounts of the sinking of the Titanic, compare and contrast how the directors of 'Titanic' and 'A Night to Remember' portray the events that occurred.

Extracts from this document...


Oliver Simpson Mr Allenby English Media Coursework GCSE English Media Assignment Using the factual accounts of the sinking of the Titanic, compare and contrast how the directors of 'Titanic' and 'A Night to Remember' portray the events that occurred. On Monday April the 14th 1912, brought an event which was to change thousands of lives and change the course of history. The 'unsinkable' Titanic - the pride of the White Star fleet struck an iceberg and sank within hours causing a massive loss of life. This disaster has caught the imagination of many generations and has provided the source of many books and films both fact and fiction. The Titanic was on its maiden voyage to New York. It was the largest and greatest ship of its age, it was said to be like a floating city that carried 332 first class passengers in absolute luxury, 276 second class passengers and approximately 708 Steerage class or lower class passengers that suffered most casualties over the hours Titanic sank. The most famous films of the events surrounding the sinking of the Titanic are 'A Night to Remember' by Roy Baker in 1958 which was based on the true story of Titanic, and most recently the 11 Academy award winning film 'Titanic' by James Cameron in 1997 which is one of the most successful films of recent times. 'A Night to Remember' and 'Titanic' approach the telling of the story in totally different ways, but have very similar themes running throughout. 'A Night to Remember' is based on the book also called 'A night to Remember' by Walter Lord. ...read more.


Cameron's 'Titanic' makes a totally different approach to telling the story as it is based on fictional characters which are developed over a long period of time. It is basically a dramatic love story interwoven with the story of Titanic. The story develops between Rose, a rich girl who is forced into engagement to a multimillionaire steel baron - Cal Hockley. She feels trapped inside her own world causing her to feel like death is the only way out. However she is saved by Jack, a 3rd class passenger who makes a living out of pencil drawings. They soon fall into forbidden love as Rose's fianc´┐Że and her mother try to separate them several times. It uses flash backs from current times to the events in April 1912 through the eyes of a survivor of the disaster. The opening scenes of Titanic shows a salvage squad looking for a precious diamond that would be worth millions of pounds today. They finally find the safe which they believed it was kept in but they soon find out that the safe is empty apart from a drawing of a beautiful young girl wearing the diamond. This leads to a report on television which is seen by Rose who is now 104 years old as she recognises herself as the girl in the drawing. The salvage squad determined to find the diamond fly Rose out to the site where she recounts the events that lead to the sinking of Titanic. Throughout Titanic Cameron uses many different methods to represent the different classes by showing the contrast by focusing on the higher class to the middle class then to the lower class. ...read more.


As he is concerned that she might miss he asks her to practice on a cupboard, by hitting the cupboard, and then trying to hit the same spot for a second time, she misses by several feet, but as the situation is now frantic Jack urges her to chop through the chain. She manages it successfully, and they escape. Another example of humor is represented in the scene where the ship has sunk and jack says to Rose 'I don't know about you, but I intend to write a strongly worded letter to the White Star fleet about all this.' Cameron uses this comment to lighten the mood of the audience after witnessing such tragedy. Both films follow the same basic factual accounts of the sinking, and portray them in a similar way: the separation of children and women from their fathers; lack of life boats; priority given to 1st class passengers over 3rd class passengers to board the life boats; acts of cowardice, and the fact that the life boats did not return to help those in need. The main differences between the two representations are that 'Titanic' follows a forbidden love story, and a 'Night to Remember' focuses purely on the factual side of events. As 'A Night to Remember' is presented in a way that it frequently fools us into thinking that it's a documentary, I believe this makes the story less interesting. In my opinion as a film 'Titanic' is overall more successful in capturing the attention of the audience due to advantages of modern day special effects and the added striking love story. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Essay on "The Diamond Necklace".

    Maupassant uses three main symbols to help bring out the core theme: that the preoccupation with appearance is vain and worthless. The main icon within the short story is the necklace itself, which comes to symbolize Matilda's vanity. The true nature of the necklace Matilda has borrowed from Mrs.

  2. Explore conflicting accounts of Jewish Identity in

    "Why have you made yourself a Catholic to deny your Jewish blood?"[11][11] These questions lead to Barbara becoming uncertain and "displaced" within herself, "she felt her personal identity beginning to escape like smoke from among her bones"[12][12] and she gives in to the questioning "with the resigned dying-fall of a victim deprived of fresh air and civil rights".

  1. As a forty-four year old lady with a family, I was very nervous about ...

    The ship had begun its voyage and we had said our good byes and our best wishes, we were now ready for some luxury, well, not us, we were in the third class. But it was still luxury in comparison to what we were used to!

  2. Speech Smoking

    and it was more of political enmity and dissent that fortified the arms race rather than the cause of the weapons themselves, it is too far a link to join industrialization with the later eruption of the world war. At best, we can conclude that it did bring countries closer

  1. The ancient civilizations of Central and South America

    Some Mayan people were also hunters or fishers. They would generally hunt turkeys, rabbits, or deer. These animals were usually killed and then boiled into a stew. Some animals such as dogs and ducks were kept by the Mayans as domesticated animals.

  2. I am Sam [2001] directed by JessieNelson and The Curious Incident of the Dog ...

    As presented in this initial scene. Sam claps his hands and pounds every surface drumming out a beat to a song only he can hear. This quick paced opening constructs Sam to exist as the western society 'mist understood' individual. With the social status, emotional and intellectual state of the character being perpetuated endorsing the values

  1. Examine strategies adopted by the directors studied on the course to depict marginality in ...

    They are three characters that have not been accepted into society, even though they were born in France and are not immigrants. Almost all the characters in 'La Haine' are male and female characters; "underlining their disempowerment" (1) often boss the three main characters around.

  2. A voyage up on the Titanic.

    We found the dining room (finally it was dinner time) and a waiter showed us to a table for two. There were lots of valuable pictures on the walls for example one of Claude Monet's favourite and famous paintings.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work