• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using theories of Marx and, more broadly, utilitariansim, examine the ways in which Dickens and Dostoevsky creatively explore the impact of industrialisation on humanity and education.

Extracts from this document...


Using theories of Marx and, more broadly, utilitariansim, examine the ways in which Dickens and Dostoevsky creatively explore the impact of industrialisation on humanity and education. Dickens and Dostoevsky both critique the social effects of industrialisation and utilitarianism, though each has a different approach and a slightly different focus. Dickens employs parody, satire and caricature to ridicule the effects of the new political economy while Dostoevsky examines the consequences of rational morality taken to extremes. Dickens uses residents of a regional manufacturing town1 to illustrate the social consequences of industrialisation, and particularly the influence on education, while Dostoevsky focuses on the experiences of an urban individual to demonstrate the psychological and social consequences of utilitarianism. In Hard Times, Dickens' main characters represent different social groups and illustrate industrialisation's effect on society. For example, Gadgrind represents educators and politicians who advocate the principles of reason and utility but discount emotion, affection, imagination and aesthetics. He is a "man of realities. A man of... calculations". One who promotes fact over fancy until faced with the personal consequences of such a philosophy. Bounderby typifies wealthy factory owners and the beneficiaries of capitalism. He is a proud of his status as a self-made man, until the story of his success is exposed as a fiction designed to conceal his working class background. ...read more.


Dostoevsky twists the tenets of utilitarianism into a Gordian knot that denies each character access to their desired goal of self-determination. The various strands of pleasure and pain, transgression and penalty, endeavour and reward, action and consequence, rationality and the greater good form a tangled web which traps the subject at its centre. For the individual, utilitarianism is self-defeating and destructive. For Luzhin, relying on utility ruins his reputation, his engagement and his business strategy. For Svidrigailov, utilitarianism leads inevitably to nihilism, where good and evil are equivalent and murder or generosity are morally neutral. The rational consequent to such a meaningless life is suicide9. As for Rodya, when he confesses his crime to Sonya, she cries, "What have you done - what have you done to yourself?" And his response is just as clear, "Did I murder the old woman? I murdered myself, not her!" According to utilitarian ideals, punishment (pain) is the rational way to prevent further crime. Punishment reforms criminals or protects society from them or deters potential criminals through threat of penalty10. Dostoevsky, however, suggests that legislation and punishment are not the answer to anti-social behaviour. Rather, where reason and utility fail, a change of heart and a moral code succeed. ...read more.


8 For example, Razumikhin acknowledges his continued assistance of Rodya is influenced by his growing attraction to Dunya - yet his self-interest is rewarded and ultimately benefits a number of others. 9 Dostoevsky surrounds Rodya with comparable and contrasting others who mirror his own repressed inner self. The lives of those around him serve to reflect and illustrate his own inner dialogue. In particular, the polar opposites of Sonya (caring, compassionate, spiritual) and Svidrigailov (aggressive, detached, nihilistic) mirror the duality of Rodya's personality. Interesting that when Rodya meets Svidrigailov, he descends into the depths of a dark tavern, but he visits Sonya, he ascends to a spacious room with high ceilings. Interesting too, that Rodya's decision to confess is influenced as much by Svidrigailov's death as it is by Sonya's entreaties - the death of utility allows morality to prevail. 10 Interesting to note that English philosopher and Utilitarian, Jeremy Bentham, was also responsible for the concept of the Panopticon penitentiary. 11 Both events: occur a few weeks after the crucifixion/resurrection (Easter), follow a short period of introspection/guilt and an unexplained absence of the advocate, are located on the shore of a body of water at early morning, include a sudden appearance of the "saviour", and a tearful conversion. After his encounter with Sonya, Rodya "had risen again and he knew it" (p492). ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. HG Wells View Of Humanity - The Time Machine

    almost to the extent where one could say that Wells was ashamed or embarrassed to live in the era that he did and he portrayed this through the early chapters of The Time Machine. We can tell this by looking at the complexity of scientific understanding that Filby and The Time Traveller posses.

  2. 'Sociological Imagination'.

    Sociologists focus on the three basic concerns of the sociological imagination or perspective for explanations. Social structure, deals with the formation of society, how it was formed and why is it the way it is today. Giddens, A (1997) states "It is the business of sociology to investigate the connections

  1. Social and action theories

    Parsons considers that the roles played by the family and the education system are vital to social order and maintenance of the status quo. The Functionalists believe that everybody has the same opportunities in life, if you work hard and follow the norms and values of society then your objectives in life can be met.

  2. Working More Creatively With Groups.

    It was not so much in the group work class, but more so in the individual work. The group work centred on roles and scripts, and although I started to pick up on roles that I act out on a daily basis, I wouldn't count this as a skill.

  1. Structural and Action theories

    Which is where classes are formed. They are formed through generalisations. For instance: The type of job someone does could put him/her at an advantage over someone who has a lower-paid job. Acknowledging this sort of a difference in status may give those who are seen as having more of an advantage a perceived amount of power over the lesser ones.

  2. Both protagonists struggle to define themselves in a world that denies the development of ...

    Instead of telling him what she actually felt she just says, "I guess so" and leaves it at that. But what she really felt like saying was - "They're dust as dust as dust. I reckon a good poem last a whole lot longer than a hundred of those people put together".

  1. Capital Punishment

    Also most damage is being done to the innocent families of the criminal who are often brush to the side and overlooked and often say that "two wrongs don't make a right" it is argued that capital punishment removes any chance of rehabilitation and their giving something back to society.

  2. Foucault's Panopticon

    In my eyes, Foucault's analysis of power, also offers an [undermined by many] insight into the insidious practices of slavery. He commences Discipline and Punish14 by relaying gruesome eyewitness accounts of the drawing and quartering of the regicide, Damiens. Consonant with the method and strategy he pursues in his other

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work